Maynard's Cafe

9306 Amherst Ave, Margate City
(609) 822-8423

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jenn W

Best hole in Margate
Cheers- everyone knows your name

Likhitha Reddy

Do not go here after 10 pm. Quickly becomes over capacity to the point that it’s a fire hazard. Only 1 bar outside takes credit card (which they’re annoyed about) and the other 2 are cash only. After waiting for 20+ mins at the credit bar to not even be close to getting a drink, we had to elbow our way out as there was literally no room to even walk. Also 50% of the patrons are clearly under 21 with fake IDs - the bouncers obviously don’t care about as long as they get that $5 cover.

The Philip Cavalcanto Team

Very fun, very active with friends and family. Always lots going on. As the summer gets going watch for the bands on the patio and great night time excitement.

David Martino

The legendary Maynards. Never fails, always available good time

Ronald Day

Phillies excitement!

Nick Pontillo

A Margate tradition. Good wings, tenders and other bar food. A little pricey these days, but always consistent.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cate Migioia

Great, comfy, festive atmosphere in their side courtyard, service was attentive, and we all loved our food too. Drinks were fresh and tasty as well!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pork Roll Sandwich, Roast Beef Sandwich

JG

Maynard’s is an example of a restaurant that does high volume and has high marks for keeping service organized while making great food.

My wife had the chicken stir fry with sauce on the side and she really loved it. She is picky so I knew it was as good as she exclaimed.

I had the Sour Dough Patty Melt and the burger was very tasty. I do prefer a patty melt on rye, so the sour dough was more fluffy than I would have liked and I suggest maybe adding butter to the inside of bread to lessen the dryness, but it tasted great and the caramelized onions were spot on.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Denise Dennin

Sat at a high top table and were totally ignored by all employees. No one even acknowledged our presence. We left and ate at Betty's Seafood across the street...good decision!

Matthew Wilson

Terrible experience here. HOMOPHOBIC bouncers and staff. Please do NOT come here. I would recommend you go to any bar but here if you are queer or LGBTQ+.

The bouncer should’ve been more worried about the vomit in the sink rather than two gay men pee’ing….

Michael Mazzoni

A staple in Margate for a reason. Great staff, atmosphere, food and drinks...

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jill Paciga

cruz made me feel comfortable of course you are gonna get weird people at the bar but he made me feel comfortable at the bar. i felt okay and so happy once i knew him cause he made me feel comfortable about going there. genuinely he deserves a raise. he deserves better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Ristagno

Brain hemerange shots

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Kevin Seelig

Ask for Erica she is great! Is a skilled mixologist who treated us like long time friends. Definitely a must go

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ian Kampmeyer

Maynard’s does not care about their customers at all! I watched a girl black out drunk who clearly needed help and no one would help even their staff. I witnessed their staff talk bad about things girl while she was suffering on the curb.

Loading...