Tomatoes

9300 Amherst Ave, Margate City
(609) 822-7535

Recent Reviews

Christine Stucke

As always the food options are plentiful, the dishes are delicious and filled with flavor, plus the service is very attentive and so pleasant!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

frfpatty1

Somewhat over priced menu as in relation to the quality and creativity of it.Very clean place, nice ambiance, friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Shante Athill

Nice place, pretty pricy for what you get but they had Chilean sea bass so that’s what we went for. It was Valentine’s Day so they gave us chocolates which was a nice gesture. The waitress was nice but I’m sure had a long day so we didn’t interact too much. No wait on Valentine’s Day and we were able to make

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Monica V.

Tomatoes is an awesome restaurant located bay front in Margate City, NJ. They have a parking lot behind the restaurant & it was easy to find a spot during the holidays, but this place gets super busy in the summer. Their menu is very eclectic with options ranging from American classics to healthy salads & a full sushi menu as well! Ambiance is fun & energetic with live music & a great bar area that's separate from the main dining room. I had the Ginger Cosmo & the Lycheetini to start off the evening. Both were fabulous, but the Lycheetini is on the sweeter side. The Alex roll was very fresh and flavorful. The Chop Chop was one of my favorite salads recently because their Russian dressing is made in house and super tasty. The star of the evening was the Euro Chicken. The skin was perfectly crispy & the meat was oh so tender. They use Mary's Organic chicken which is another plus & it paired so wonderfully with the truffle mac n cheese & broccolini. I can't wait to go back! Service was stellar too!

Lynn M.

Excellent all around, food, service & atmosphere. Not too loud despite a full room. Round tables perfect for a party of six. Creative menu with options for everyone including sushi and pizza as well as full on entrees. The bar area for a couple just looking to share a meal is an active and happening spot too. It's a tried and true treasure.

Julie D.

Sat at the bar- Sushi, cocktails and dessert were all so good!!! Great service and overall fun atmosphere.

Tony Crisci

Never disappointed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ramon Torres

It was

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Allisen Keith

The owner Mario likes to insult and harass women. Would never recommend an establishment like this.

bonnie mitnick

I had dinner last week with a group of friends. I ordered the cowboy steak and specifically asked if there was a bone. Waiter said yes. When steak arrived at table there was no bone. I should have been more assertive but the waiter blew us off.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 2

Am Sosa

Had to update my review ?. Gave tomatoes another chance. Instant regret. Regardless I know it’s going to be popular but blonde bartender needs to find a new job. Our food didn’t even come out. And this was just our official last time going. Down hill is an understatement.

Andy Scolnick

AMAZING! Been here many times but tonight I needed to let Carmen and everyone know everything was AWESOME! The food was great and our waitress Aine was incredible!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brad Klein

It was obnoxiously crowded + loud with the DJ blasting but it was the Saturday night after Labor Day so i guess that's what the villagers want.The food: SO DELICIOUS!! Split a burger and the pork chop with my friend. Both were so tasty and the pumpkin gnocci w the pork was very good.The service: once we were seated, service was good. We did have a 6person reservation for 9p but didn't get seated til almost 945; but the hostess was nice about it + worked with us to seat us further away from the music ("upstairs" aka 5 steps lol, towards the back of the restaurant)The drinks were fine - the first mezcal marg i got from the front bar was pretty good; the passionfruit-mezcalita was not that great.Overall the food is good but unless you're in a party mood, don't go on Saturday nightVegetarian options: Pescatarian in my group was able to find plenty of things she wanted to eat

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Karen G

Energetic atmosphere, friendly staff and great food. This was the perfect way to start our beach vacation

Morganx2

Excellent food as always and excellent service. They have the best martinis around too! Everything from the apps to dessert was amazing!

Load More