Mendham Creamery

2a Hilltop Rd, Mendham
(973) 348-5854

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Aon

Good ice cream shop with some classic flavors. Texture was good, but not exceptional. Friendly staff and a clean shop. No inside sitting arrangement. Worth a try if you're in the area, but not a must-visit.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Alexandra N

The ice cream there is SO good and all the people that work there are so nice and never rude. They are also all locals so they know some kids from boro camp and siblings. Just overall a GREAT place to go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cotton Candy, Orange Blossom, Raspberry Sorbet, Strawberry, Lemon Sorbet, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

Ron Weissman

Parking: Easy, available parking within a few footsteps

Kid-friendliness: Sponsor of middle school events

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Strawberry Fields, Orange Blossom, Strawberry

Mariah T

So delicious!!

Eric Anderson

Great place.

Rose B

They have great service and an amazing location. It is a very cute store right in the heart of town. A small business like this is exactly what Mendham needs and I love to see how crowded it gets after school. For a while, Mendham sorely was missing a family-owned ice cream shop like this one.The reason I bump it down may mostly be due to my personal preference and in fairness to the other local shops that serve homemade ice cream. I wish the ice cream was a bit creamier and that it was homemade by them. The ice cream is still GOOD and I definitely enjoy it in the summer. It seems they import it from the The Hershey Creamery Company ice cream which does have wholesome ingredients, it is just not as fresh and creamy as it could be if it was technically homemade by them.

Bryan Wezwick

Always a Mendham favorite.

Rosemary Dunlap

Great ice cream. Friendly and helpful staff.

D F (HappyNana)

Two try's to make a milkshake. Still tastes like milk. Only slightly thicker the second time. And not full.

Firdaush Contractor

Awesome family run business with great ice cream

Bill Newman

Great shake, but they only had 1 person working as school let out & the wait was very long.

Andrew Bisceglia

Good selection of ice cream and great accommodating staff.

Lori Perrelly

Delicious, wow really great ice cream!

mikeinsunshine

Good ice cream, a bit expensive and small portions. But enjoyed sitting outside to eat. Recommended.

Heather Ferrante

Great day for ice cream

Loading...