Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill
353 Mendham Rd W, Mendham
(973) 543-7675
Customers' Favorites
True Surf and Turf Whole Lobster 12 Oz Filet
Bone-In Dry-Aged New York Strip
Shrimp Scampi Sammys Style
Half Order of Vodka Pasta
Oil and Garlic Spaghetti
2 Whole Maine Lobsters
Stuffed Mushrooms
Double Lobsters
Corn on the Cob
Prawn Cocktail
Menu
Photos
+73 photos
+72 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Sammy's has been a favorite of mine for some time. It is one of those spots that you hope always stays the way it is. A unique ordering experience which provides you with just the right amount of time to have a couple negronis in the basement bar before being shown to your table. Steak for 2, med rare. Hopefully no big changes are coming with the new ownership on the way.
after fifty years of going to Sammy's, our meals the other night were nothing less than perfect. From the moment we arrived to the closing of the door at the end of the night, as busy as it was- we never felt hurried, nor ignored. From the salad with that tangy, vinegar laden dressing, to a perfect sesame bread- with salty butter, to a shrimp cocktail (3) with their signature cocktail sauce and shrimp- redolent of the ocean and sweet as can be- then the double lobsters, soft...
I have been coming here for several decades, only downside is I have to pay the bill now. Love the food and atmosphere. We normally will order shrimp scampi and the two pastas as appetizers, T-bone steak and lobster for mains. Fries are the best you’re going to find anywhere and personally, I love the salad and desserts.
Now as a full blown carnivore, it’s worth addressing the confusion over steak temperature. That is a perfect medium rare T-bone from a...
Now as a full blown carnivore, it’s worth addressing the confusion over steak temperature. That is a perfect medium rare T-bone from a...
You May Also Like
Simple Coffee - 15 W Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Cafe
Sapori d'Italia - 7 W Main St
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Salad