Bagel Pantry

545 Middlesex Ave, Metuchen
(732) 632-3100

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Bagel with Taylor Ham Egg Cheese and Ketchup
Bacon Egg and Cheese on Poppy Seed Bagel
Egg and Cheese on an Everything Bagel
Toasted Plain Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bacon Egg and Cheese Bagel Sandwich
Sesame Bagel with Garlic Spread
Eggs and Cheese on Roll
Pork Roll and Cheese
Avocado Chicken Wrap
Roast Beef Sandwich

Menu

Breakfast Mains
Egg and Cheese
Breakfast sandwich with an egg and cheese.
Bagel with Butter
Bagel of your choice with butter.
Home Fries
Potatoes are diced, seasoned, and grilled.
Cheese Omelette
Three eggs scrambled with cheese.
French Toast Platter
One piece of french toast, 2 eggs, breakfast meat, and home fries.
Western Omelette
3 eggs scrambled with ham, peppers, and onions.
Texas French Toast (3 pcs)
Texas toast dipped in homemade french toast mix. Topped with butter and a sprinkle of powdered sugar.
Loaded Avocado Toast
Basic avocado toast with spinach and two eggs.
Vegetable Omelette
Three eggs scrambled with tomatoes, peppers, onions, and spinach.
OMG Grilled Cheese
Texas toast with melted American, Monterey Jack, and cheddar.
Basic Avocado Toast
Mashed avocado, onion, tomato, lemon, salt, and pepper on toast.

Speciality Sandwiches
Heart Healthy Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken, tomato, avocado, and arugula on a whole-grain roll.
Classic Reuben Sandwich
Your choice of pastrami or corned beef, swiss, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing served as a triple-decker on rye bread.

Lunch Combos
Chicken Mozzarella Sandwich
Grilled chicken, roasted red pepper, local mozzarella, lettuce, and balsamic dressing on a multigrain sub.
Pesto Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken, provolone, lettuce, roasted red pepper, and pesto mayonnaise.
BBQ Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken, cheddar, potato salad, bbq sauce, and lettuce.
Ham Dijonaise Wrap
Ham, swiss, dijonaise, and lettuce.

Salad Tree
Walnut Arugula
A bed of fresh arugula topped with cherry tomatoes, cranberries, walnuts, and blue cheese. Served with homemade apple honey balsamic dressing drizzled on top.
Garden Salad
Iceberg lettuce topped with tomato, sweet peppers, cucumbers, and carrots.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Grilled freshly chopped romaine lettuce topped with blue cheese, tomato, and chicken coated in buffalo sauce.
Classic Caesar
A bed of freshly chopped romaine lettuce topped with creamy caesar dressing and grated parmesan cheese.
Chef Salad
Our garden salad is topped with tuna, egg, or chicken salad. Make it vegetarian by choosing egg salad.

By the Pound
Whitefish
Smoked Salmon
Vegetable, scallion, bacon cheddar chive, blueberry, strawberry, walnut raisin, cranberry walnut, olive, chocolate chip, smoked salmon, jalapeño, and bacon cheddar chive.
Tuna
Chicken Salad
Speciality Cream Cheese

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+23 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+22 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

**⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5-Star Review for Bagel Pantry – Metuchen, NJ**

Fantastic spot for breakfast right in the heart of Metuchen! One of the few places in town with actual parking — a huge plus. The bagels were fresh, perfectly toasted, and paired so well with the jalapeño cream cheese. I also tried the blueberry cupcakes, and they were delicious!

The service was top-notch — lots of staff helping out, and billing was super...
July 2025
I have been coming here for years and have I have enjoyed the taste of the the bagels but on my last visit here noticed that the price was raised to $1.50 per bagel which seems a little high but let me tell you that the Everything bagel which I ate untoasted with butter was one of the top ten bagels I have ever eaten. I then toasted a sesame bagel the following morning and that bagel was also one of the best I have ever tasted. I am 60 years old from Staten Island originally...
February 2025
Amazing bagels... service is kool. ultimately it's a nice low key deli with really great bagels. I like coming here and would suggest it to others who aren't familiar with the area.. I dare to say they have the best bagels in town..but they have other stuff too that's not too shabby either. It can get packed on weekends and early mornings, so clearly they're doing something right! Inside is low key seedy but I doubt people go there for the ambiance.
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Friendly's - 550 Middlesex Ave
American, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers
Antonio's Brick Oven Pizza - 453 Main St
Pizza, Italian, Cheesesteaks, Vegetarian
Orchid Kosher - 455 Main St
Kosher, Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, Israeli, Vegan

Bagel Pantry

545 Middlesex Ave, Metuchen, NJ 08840
(732) 632-3100