Florentinos

1148 NJ-35, Middletown
(732) 671-1801

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Elizabeth Banta

Florentino’s catered the BBQ at our house the day after our wedding - WOW. Working with Dave was a breeze, the food was spectacular, and the service was incredible. They made the weekend!

Steven Puccetti

We catered my son’s first birthday with Florentino’s and everything turned out great. Everything was very smooth from placing the order, to delivery of the food, to quality of the food, and returning the equipment. Definitely recommend!

nathaniellorence325

I used Florentino’s as the caterer for my son’s birthday party and the food was amazing. Everyone at the party loved the food! Lenny and David are super nice and were both extremely helpful throughout the booking. They were accommodating when I needed to make adjustments to my order and answered all of my questions. Chuck was super helpful with the delivery and everything came out great in time for the party. Alicia was the waitress and she was fantastic as well, helping with all we needed during the party! If you are looking for a caterer for your party, I would highly recommend Florentino’s!

Nick D

This place is an institution. The sandwiches, food and staff are what makes this place incredible. My only cons are they got rid of whole length bread for their subs. So if you order a whole you get two shorter ones. Slaters did this too and I don’t understand it. Also red onions instead of white but that’s forgivable and a personal preference. The sandwiches here are incredible - the good old Italian, turkey and cheese, and roast beef with mozz are excellent. I always come here when I’m in need of a good sandwich. Thank you Florentino’s!

John Daly

Extremely fresh food, friendly staff,delicious, first time and definitely won’t be my last time! Thank you!

Karen Derrick

Recently used Florentino's for a corporate event. The registration continued to grow at the last minute. Dave consistently went above and beyond to ensure our satisfaction. He provided valuable feedback that helped us improve the final product significantly. The variety of food offerings ensured everyone dietary preferences were met. Also very delicious; as many guest stated!

John Riordan

Delicious food and extremely friendly staff. Highly recommended for your catering needs.

Paul Thal

Great experience from start to finish with our Christmas Eve catering order. Food ready as promised, tasted great and it is niw our goto deli.

John Braun

Do yourself a favor, get your catering here. This was our second Christmas in a row catering from Florentino’s. With 30-40 people at the house, cooking just hasn’t seemed like an option. The food itself has been an absolute hit with the guests - from stuffed chicken (chicken Florentino) to baked ziti…from spiral ham to eggplant rollatini and all the sides, every dish we’ve had has been delicious.

But if you don’t come for the quality of the food, come for the quality of the service and the friendliness of the staff. They run their catering like a well-oiled machine. On Christmas Eve they greeted us at the door, checked our order and provided up with a delicious chicken cutlet sandwich to eat while we waited. When the order was ready, they called us back, double checked that everything was included, provided all the racks and sternos I would need, and rang up my order. They printed out hearing instructions and helped carry everything to the car - all with a smile, gratitude and a handshake.

If you’re considering Florentino’s, don’t even hesitate. If you’re not…well, you should.

Rebecca Rhoads

From the first phone call Florentinos I knew it was the right caterer for our condominium association holiday event. Everyone I interacted with is knowledgeable, friendly and incredibly responsive. Dave handled our event two years in a row, and both times everything went so smoothly down to the last detail. Trust that you're in good hands. Thank you! Thank you! What a wonderful customer centered business. You can't go wrong.

Samantha L

We’ve ordered our Christmas catering from Florentinos for the past 2 years and it’s always a hit. The staff is so pleasant and helpful and the food is amazing. We will definitely be using them for years to come.

Michael Morris

I placed a catering order with Florentinos for this past Tuesday night (12/17) for an organizational party. Unlike other establishments around town they were very professional and accommodating. The food was outstanding and there wasn't a leftover insight! Florentinos does a great job all around and I couldn't recommend them any more highly!

Dennis Rhoads

Catered holiday party for 40. Great customer service from start to finish. Clearly care about their clients. Food delivered right on time, set-up and delicious. Well-prepared and visually appealing. Highly recommend. Used them last year too and will return next year.

Kenneth Lee

The best sandwiches and cold cuts.

Ray Kelly

A big thank you to Lenny, Dave and staff for making our daughters Halloween theme wedding,a big success. The food was fantastic, our guest were raving about it as they went up for 2nds.
Highly recommend them,will definitely use them for future events..the Kellys

Loading...