Florentinos

1148 NJ-35, Middletown
(732) 671-1801

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Brian Fabino

We used Florentinos catering for our housewarming party and the food was absolutely delicious. The picking up of the food was super easy and the instructions from the employees on how to heat up the food best was perfect! Can’t wait to go back and try new things here. Highly recommend!

Stephen Puleo

This place is as good as it gets for a deli sandwich. The bread is outstanding (crispy on the outside and soft inside) and the portions of delicious boars head meat is spot on.

Alexis H

It was my first time using Florentino's catering and the experience was great and food was delicious. Will definitely be ordering again for my next event!

Debra Lyons

I’ve used Florentinos now four occasions. They have never disappointed me. This weekend they even went beyond when I called to ask them if they had a tray of Italian cookies. Dave ran next-door to the bakery and bought them for me and sent them with my delivery. What superb service! I can’t say enough good things about the people and the food. They are definitely my go to place for catering.

Gary Olivero

I’m not one to always believe reviews, but having been given a suggestion to use this caterer and in looking at previous reviews, we gave it a try. They exceeded our expectations, not just in the manner of handing our affair with great people, but also in the terrific quality of the dishes provided. Believe the reviews, they are really this good.

Tom Carlson

Love their sandwiches and salads.... very friendly and polite staff.

Jill G

This place is truly outstanding! From start to finish, the service was flawless. The owners, Dave and Lenny, are not only professional but also incredibly friendly and personable. Lenny took the time to guide me through every preparation for my event, while Dave carried everything out to absolute perfection—it couldn’t have been easier. Their staff is just as wonderful: warm, attentive, and welcoming. And the food? Absolutely amazing—everyone loved every single dish. I feel blessed to have found this establishment and I can’t recommend it highly enough!

Eileen Fox

Catered from Florentinos for my 60th birthday party. Everyone commented how delicious the food was. So good, I hardly had any leftovers. Staff is awesome and so friendly while booking the party. Would highly recommend them for your catering needs.

Zach England

Some of the best Roast Beef I’ve ever had!!

Georgann Christiani

David and his crew catered my 70th birthday party yesterday! We had over 100 people and decided on the barbecue and it was the best choice we ever made! We honestly did nothing at all. He sent everything and his boys were totally self-sufficient, cleaned up, they were amazing. I highly recommend them. You can't go wrong with Florentinos.
PS don't forget the hot appetizers. One was even better than the next. .

Robert DuPuy

We hired catering service for our son's 8th grade graduation backyard BBQ, and I honestly can't say enough good things. From start to finish, everything was flawless and far exceeded our expectations.

The food was phenomenal fresh, delicious, cooked to perfection. My guests raved about it, and It turned a special day into something even more memorable.

The cook was incredible. He arrived early, set everything up without a single complaint during sweltering heat. Not only was he a master at the grill, but he also felt like part of the family. He was warm, engaging, and genuinely seemed to enjoy being part of our celebration. Just a really good guy who made a big impression on everyone.

And then there was the server, an absolute rockstar. He was attentive to every detail, whether it was keeping drinks filled, making sure the food was stocked, or even taking out the trash without being asked. His presence allowed us to relax and enjoy the day without worrying about a thing.

A huge thank you to the Florentino family for being such a big part of a great day. You helped create a moment we’ll never forget, and we’re so grateful. If you're looking for a catering service that delivers amazing food and even better people, look no further. Ask for Dave to set you up. His team is the real deal!

Jill Mercadante

Florentinos is the way to go for a seamless party! We did the bbq package for the second time yesterday and despite the rain it was a huge success! Nick from Florentinos was professional, courteous and efficient and a huge hit with our big family! We were able to enjoy our guests and not worry about a thing! We will definitely do it again!

Elizabeth Evarts

Florentino’s catered the BBQ at our house the day after our wedding - WOW. Working with Dave was a breeze, the food was spectacular, and the service was incredible. They made the weekend!

Elizabeth Banta

Florentino’s catered the BBQ at our house the day after our wedding - WOW. Working with Dave was a breeze, the food was spectacular, and the service was incredible. They made the weekend!

Steven Puccetti

We catered my son’s first birthday with Florentino’s and everything turned out great. Everything was very smooth from placing the order, to delivery of the food, to quality of the food, and returning the equipment. Definitely recommend!

Loading...