I’m sorry but the fact that people think this bakery is top notch.. absolutely not. The “donuts” (Boston cream and jelly) both have very odd flavors. They don’t have regular yeast donuts. The crumb cake was hard as a literal rock even though she claimed it was baked fresh that morning. The old lady claimed they are “the best bakery in NJ” LOL like have you been to any decent bakery in your life? I’m assuming people like this bakery because there’s no very close competition around. Abbate and Normandie are way better. But my go to will always be Muellers!
Ben Zimmerman
Great rainbow cookies, nice people
Lauren Filozof
I had a custom cake made for my baby shower and it looked just as great as it tasted! Couldn’t be happier with my experience and will be using them exclusively for any future events! Will definitely be recommending to friends and family as well!
Cooper Hanley
Anazing i apent 1cent on 1848 cakes
Precision Eyecare of NJ
Best bakery in Middletown! Always amazing service and great cookies! Matt is an amazing baker! We thank you so much for everything! Highly recommend!!!
Shawn Woodson
This place is amazing. If you have not experienced this shop you are missing out. From the cheesecake to the cupcakes this place is amazing
LOREEN Ferreira
I ordered a cake for daughter's wedding reception. The taste and flavor was out of this world. I ordered white cake with fresh strawberries and custard filling. It was fresh, moist, and very tasty. The icing was perfect semi-sweet. Was given a choice how sweet i wanted and every sample of cake I tried was a winner. My family had a hard time choosing what to pick, because all the samples tasted so good! Absolutely the Best! I recommend J&M Bakey. The service was excellent. I also ordered some french macaroons last minute and wedding cookies and they were still able to honor my request. From now on, I will order all my pastry needs from J&M Bakery. Definitely worth it!
Mercedes Loperena
Stopped by after eating nearby to get cannolis and the shells were soggy, how disappointing from an Italian bakery with good reviews. Will go else where next time.
Steve Webber
Very friendly service Pastries and cakes are highly recommended..... It's my go to bakery for all my occasions
BRIANNE GIGLIO
Best bakery! Best seeded twist and the freshest cookies
My guests loved the cake that J&M made for our baby shower - it was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt Reck
Purchased a birthday cake Christmas morning. Believe it was a double fudge cake. Regardless. The amount of praise it recieved was crazy. I don't even like chocolate and I was impressed. Thanks to the bakers for the great product and staff for great service. On Christmas morning no less. Astounding work J & M.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mary Jakub
This is the very best bakery ever. Cakes, cookies ect. not too sugary or processed. We go there once a week for cookies, pastries, coffee cakes ect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cannoli
Gianna Tedesco
The best BEST Italian bakery around. Authentic and delicious pastries and cakes! I always recommend coming to this bakery to get your goodies. Hands down AMAZING! Staff is awesome, bakery is super clean and displays are just beautiful. Best of the best!
Dietary restrictions: I have seen labels for gluten free and diabetic accommodating products. Just truly an amazing bakery.
Parking: There’s plenty of parking so no need to complain. It’s a wide open parking lot.
Kid-friendliness: They make the most adorable kids cookies and cakes. You can see their little faces light up when they come in and see the character cookies and cupcakes at their level. Just adorable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cannoli, Lobster Tails, Gift Basket
I’m sorry but the fact that people think this bakery is top notch.. absolutely not. The “donuts” (Boston cream and jelly) both have very odd flavors. They don’t have regular yeast donuts. The crumb cake was hard as a literal rock even though she claimed it was baked fresh that morning. The old lady claimed they are “the best bakery in NJ” LOL like have you been to any decent bakery in your life? I’m assuming people like this bakery because there’s no very close competition around. Abbate and Normandie are way better. But my go to will always be Muellers!
Great rainbow cookies, nice people
I had a custom cake made for my baby shower and it looked just as great as it tasted! Couldn’t be happier with my experience and will be using them exclusively for any future events! Will definitely be recommending to friends and family as well!
Anazing i apent 1cent on 1848 cakes
Best bakery in Middletown! Always amazing service and great cookies! Matt is an amazing baker! We thank you so much for everything! Highly recommend!!!
This place is amazing. If you have not experienced this shop you are missing out. From the cheesecake to the cupcakes this place is amazing
I ordered a cake for daughter's wedding reception. The taste and flavor was out of this world. I ordered white cake with fresh strawberries and custard filling. It was fresh, moist, and very tasty. The icing was perfect semi-sweet. Was given a choice how sweet i wanted and every sample of cake I tried was a winner. My family had a hard time choosing what to pick, because all the samples tasted so good! Absolutely the Best! I recommend J&M Bakey. The service was excellent. I also ordered some french macaroons last minute and wedding cookies and they were still able to honor my request. From now on, I will order all my pastry needs from J&M Bakery. Definitely worth it!
Stopped by after eating nearby to get cannolis and the shells were soggy, how disappointing from an Italian bakery with good reviews. Will go else where next time.
Very friendly service
Pastries and cakes are highly recommended.....
It's my go to bakery for all my occasions
Best bakery! Best seeded twist and the freshest cookies
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Simply the best. Old school bakery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My guests loved the cake that J&M made for our baby shower - it was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Purchased a birthday cake Christmas morning. Believe it was a double fudge cake. Regardless. The amount of praise it recieved was crazy. I don't even like chocolate and I was impressed. Thanks to the bakers for the great product and staff for great service. On Christmas morning no less. Astounding work J & M.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is the very best bakery ever. Cakes, cookies ect. not too sugary or processed. We go there once a week for cookies, pastries, coffee cakes ect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cannoli
The best BEST Italian bakery around. Authentic and delicious pastries and cakes! I always recommend coming to this bakery to get your goodies. Hands down AMAZING! Staff is awesome, bakery is super clean and displays are just beautiful. Best of the best!
Dietary restrictions: I have seen labels for gluten free and diabetic accommodating products. Just truly an amazing bakery.
Parking: There’s plenty of parking so no need to complain. It’s a wide open parking lot.
Kid-friendliness: They make the most adorable kids cookies and cakes. You can see their little faces light up when they come in and see the character cookies and cupcakes at their level. Just adorable!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Cannoli, Lobster Tails, Gift Basket
Loading...