Pasquale's Pizzeria III

147 Cherry Tree Farm Rd, Middletown
(732) 615-9800

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Spotos

This place was recommended to me by a friend for their buffalo chicken pizza and I don’t know how. This was one of the worst Buffalo chicken pizzas I’ve ever tried. Instead of Buffalo sauce they give you this like orange creamy Alfredo sauce that doesn’t take like buffalo sauce at all. I seriously don’t know how you guys are known for your Buffalo chicken pizza. It was also very watery the sauce and fell off when I picked up a slice. However they did give a refund which I appreciate. If I try this place again it definitely won’t be there buffalo chicken pizza. Wish I had taken a picture of the pizza when I had it.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Douglas Bennett

Place is consistent I’ll give it that. Nothing to be crazy about. Been going here since 2007. Has always been just okay. Fair prices and staff has always been good. Pizza is okay but not the best.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Rob H

Ordered a vegan cheese steak as a part of a larger order and they delivered a non-vegan one. They wouldn't deliver a new one, they told us we have to come get it.

It shows a careless staff and poor customer service. I've always had good food from here, but mistakes like this are frustrating especially when they won't cooperate to fix it.

Dietary restrictions: Double and triple check your vegan orders because it seems they easily mess up transferring your Uber Eats order to the kitchen.

Food: 5

Service: 1

Shannon Carey

The staff made a mistake on my order and gave me extra food and charged me so I let them know there was a mistake made on their end. The girl on the phone was very rude and was making smart remarks trying to make it seem like I was the one who made the mistake. The owner overall was very sweet and not only refunded me but let me also keep the extra food. Food is great as well but if you want a friendly and comfortable atmosphere this is not the place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 4

Nick Oreckinto

Ordered a gluten free through doordash which states it comes with grilled chicken broccoli and mozzerella and it literally came just cheese and pizza and the owner had no care when i called him to explain my frustration of being mislead and instead blamed me and put it on me.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Julia DeTommaso

Placed and order for store through door dash. Door dash says location delivers their own orders and to contact them regarding order status. Called after my order was 30 minutes late. Rang and rang and Rang. No answer. Order was marked as delivered and wasn’t delivered. Tried to call again no answer. Absolute scammers

Food: 1

Service: 1

jay Berg

This is some of the worst pizza I have ever had. Crust has no flavor, the toppings, cheese and sauces make this a soup on a crust. I ate half of two different speciality slices and felt I abused myself eating it.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

Elizabeth

I have to say I went to this place once and was purchasing the pizza. I noticed the man had gloves on touching the pizza pie, which was good, BUT when he started using the cash register and took my money, He kept the plastic gloves on.
Seriously, there was no point in that, I thought he was using the gloves to keep his dirty fingers from touching the pizza after handling money.
Well, I never went there again.

Rita Martinez

Vegan review: I usually order the vegan bacon cheeseburger pizza but the last 2x they must have changed the bacon because it was gross. Then yesterday i ordered the vegan cheese steak and that was tasteless, there wasn’t a grain of salt on the “steak” it’s crazy cause i really wanted to love them… i asked them to put mayo and ketchup in the sandwich or the ket/mayo sauce they put on the pizza but they just gave me dry tasteless seitan with onions and a GREAT vegan cheese (only flavor on the sandwich)
I know their regular non vegan food smacks… 5* but not the vegan, yall are lacking

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

TC

I didn't like the pizza. Way too much cheese.

Ice Queen

Vegan veggie sampler was fabulous!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Valerie Bonsu

The vegan pizza is definable one of the best I’ve ever had. I’m not sure what kind of vegan cheese they use but *chefs kiss*

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edwin Velez

I ordered the Chicken Marsala and it was very delicious and the delivery driver was very pleasant

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

A (A)

Pesto chicken pizza is

Food: 4

Service: 4

A V

This place is good but this is just an unacceptable amount of sauce for garlic knots . I’m a sauce guy this is just bad

Loading...