Polar Bear Ice Cream

130 NJ-36, North Middletown
(732) 787-2402

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Travis Bruno

Great owner, employees and prices
Can't find a better place than this for ice cream

Tian Carling

Been coming here for years after our annual beach trips ever since RJ's closed down. Always friendly, helpful and patient service from the staff. So many options to choose from! Enough bench seating on either side of the stand if it isn't too busy. First time going while it was still light out and there wasn't a long line only one person in front of us (usually the lines are long but so worth the wait). My Dad always gets a Turtle Sundae w/ Rocky Road and I get a Butterscotch Sundae. I got chocolate chip cookie dough as my ice cream. Next time I wana get what my friend got, the Rich & Famous because it has brownie and cookie dough pieces! ❤️‍🔥

Carol Vanessa

Great local spot for ice cream!

Nancy Miller

Best banana ice cream. Cash only.

Daniel Ostrowski

Best ice cream place around.

Nicole Esquilin

My husband and I stumbled upon the sweetest little ice cream shop today while passing through the area with our daughter. We promised our toddler ice cream, so of course we had to stop—and we’re so glad we did! The three young ladies working there were incredibly polite, super sweet, and made us feel instantly welcome. Their kindness and smiles made the whole experience even better, and the ice cream was absolutely delicious! Such a charming spot—can’t wait to come back next time we’re in the area!

Mark Cusano

The best ice cream around

Julia Hope Garcia

Ice cream was really good and inexpensive.

Christine Farley

The beat ice cream around!! 🍦🍨🍧
They have anything and everything you could want!🍨🍧🍦
The staff always greets you with a smile 😊 and they move the line quickly!!

Abigail Aponte

Always enjoy a banana split from this place.

Greg Stefanski

Good service , fair prices , good selection , very good . Owner very friendly guy

dave estes

This is my all time favorite icecream place I wish they were open earlier I’d get it for breakfast

Shani Solomon Ronen

Amazing ice cream after a hike!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

A (A)

Wife says best ice cream ever !!! She's cold hearted so she would know ???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Margie

The BEST milkshakes and soft serve

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...