Best ice cream in the area. And it's fun to play a round of mini golf with the family after
Bianca Velasco
Jimmys is the place to be in the summer! My family loves it, always new flavors and so much to pick from! Their food is just as good! We played mini golf the other day and my kids had a great time!
Heather Miers
Love how nice employees are and the ice cream is delicious
Ronald Chicchi
Fresh homemade ice cream large selection of sundaes shakes etc they have hot foods burgers hot dogs French fries and much more
Kyle Keller
I'm sad to report that this place has gone seriously downhill. Considering that my parents had their first date here 50+ years ago, and I have been coming here for over 47 years, I am speaking from a very long long history with Jimmy's. When the new owners bought it years ago, I was extremely excited to see a bright new future for this place. Jimmy's always had the absolute best custard around. The recipe is not what it used to be. It tasted marshmallowy, airy, flat, and not like custard at all. I grew up playing in the creek alongside the picnic tables. They have let this become completely overgrown, taking away everything that made this special spot beautiful. Ticks are prevalent in the high grasses now, which makes this a no go for bringing your dogs with you. There was a significant amount of trash on the ground, which also makes for it being a no go for bringing your dog. I know I will get backlash for this review, and that's ok. Not many people remember the original Jimmy's, which we all called "The Cup". Doubtful we will be back, as there are many better ice cream stands in the area. Very sad about this.
Joshua Seguine
Friendly staff and quick service even when it is busy. The prices are more than reasonable for what you get. Tried the birthday cake dipped hard shell and it was pretty good!Its a great hometown ice cream stand and one you should go to!
Trattoria Di Fiore
Amazing family run business in the heart ofMilford. Always coming out with new delicious flavors. If you have been here then you already know how hard working and dedicated their team is. And if you haven’t, don’t give it a second thought, just go and experience it for yourself. You will never be disappointed!
Mark Gross
They do a great job with a limited menu. Their sandwiches are in the top 10% of any others around this area, and they do make a lot of their ice cream flavors themselves. It's tough to compete in this area with OhWowCow, one of the best gourmet ice cream makers in the US.
Ashley G.
I love driving over to Jimmy's on a summer night. I live in phillipsburg so it's about a 15 minute drive over there but worth the trip for the ice cream! My go to is hard chocolate BUT they do not have hard chocolate, only soft serve chocolate! Just an FYI but still plenty of other flavors to choose from!
Best ice cream you’ll find. Friendly staff, good prices, a local gem!
Jessica Ramos
Just had the worse experience today. The girl (Shila) who made my ice cream was rude and nasty... moving onto another ice cream shop... I paid for ice cream, not nastiness.
Carly F
Recently moved to the area and after a hot day we decided to try to find a local-ish ice-cream place. The Chocolate PeanutButter ice-cream was SO good! We didn't realize there was a WHOLE menu! The prices looked to be decent as well. This will be our go-to for ice cream from now on! We will try other food items as well. :)
Scarlett
Been going here quite literally since I was born, and nothing tastes quite the same as a Jimmy's burger and sundae. Prices are good considering the quality, and the seating and the creek are beautiful! Highly recommend.
Jan Canlapan
Excellent service and got recommended to this place by my brother becomes he knows two workers Here Stephanie and Maddison. Both were able to get my order correctly a butter pecan ice cream. Despite the payment being in cash only
Great service & lots of delicious choices!
Best ice cream in the area. And it's fun to play a round of mini golf with the family after
Jimmys is the place to be in the summer! My family loves it, always new flavors and so much to pick from! Their food is just as good! We played mini golf the other day and my kids had a great time!
Love how nice employees are and the ice cream is delicious
Fresh homemade ice cream large selection of sundaes shakes etc they have hot foods burgers hot dogs French fries and much more
I'm sad to report that this place has gone seriously downhill. Considering that my parents had their first date here 50+ years ago, and I have been coming here for over 47 years, I am speaking from a very long long history with Jimmy's. When the new owners bought it years ago, I was extremely excited to see a bright new future for this place. Jimmy's always had the absolute best custard around. The recipe is not what it used to be. It tasted marshmallowy, airy, flat, and not like custard at all. I grew up playing in the creek alongside the picnic tables. They have let this become completely overgrown, taking away everything that made this special spot beautiful. Ticks are prevalent in the high grasses now, which makes this a no go for bringing your dogs with you. There was a significant amount of trash on the ground, which also makes for it being a no go for bringing your dog. I know I will get backlash for this review, and that's ok. Not many people remember the original Jimmy's, which we all called "The Cup". Doubtful we will be back, as there are many better ice cream stands in the area. Very sad about this.
Friendly staff and quick service even when it is busy. The prices are more than reasonable for what you get. Tried the birthday cake dipped hard shell and it was pretty good!Its a great hometown ice cream stand and one you should go to!
Amazing family run business in the heart ofMilford. Always coming out with new delicious flavors. If you have been here then you already know how hard working and dedicated their team is. And if you haven’t, don’t give it a second thought, just go and experience it for yourself. You will never be disappointed!
They do a great job with a limited menu. Their sandwiches are in the top 10% of any others around this area, and they do make a lot of their ice cream flavors themselves. It's tough to compete in this area with OhWowCow, one of the best gourmet ice cream makers in the US.
I love driving over to Jimmy's on a summer night. I live in phillipsburg so it's about a 15 minute drive over there but worth the trip for the ice cream! My go to is hard chocolate BUT they do not have hard chocolate, only soft serve chocolate! Just an FYI but still plenty of other flavors to choose from!
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream you’ll find. Friendly staff, good prices, a local gem!
Just had the worse experience today. The girl (Shila) who made my ice cream was rude and nasty... moving onto another ice cream shop... I paid for ice cream, not nastiness.
Recently moved to the area and after a hot day we decided to try to find a local-ish ice-cream place. The Chocolate PeanutButter ice-cream was SO good! We didn't realize there was a WHOLE menu! The prices looked to be decent as well. This will be our go-to for ice cream from now on! We will try other food items as well. :)
Been going here quite literally since I was born, and nothing tastes quite the same as a Jimmy's burger and sundae. Prices are good considering the quality, and the seating and the creek are beautiful! Highly recommend.
Excellent service and got recommended to this place by my brother becomes he knows two workers Here Stephanie and Maddison. Both were able to get my order correctly a butter pecan ice cream. Despite the payment being in cash only