Coffee Mill Roasters

41 Main St, Millburn
(973) 218-6559

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rose F L

Very bad coffee, ordered an iced cappuccino it tasted like water. Had to throw it out, waste of money and I really thought it would be good since they are a roaster place.

Food: 1

Caroline Laufer

The owner, Adele is very friendly and can have a fun conversation with you, he is from Egypt. The quality of the coffee is very good, organic. It does not taste like your average Wawa, Quickcheck, or Dunkin coffee. There's a lot of Care that goes into the making of the coffee. There is also a sweet ambience in the coffee shop, and you can have your coffee inside or outside. Highly recommend if you want to stop by town.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

April B

Disappointing! We travelled to NJ for a concert. Heading home Saturday morning we wanted patronize a local business instead of a chain. Does not look like online pics. There were not many pastries to choose from. Out of bagels. I ordered a chia that did not taste like chai at all. And you could tell that cleanliness was not a priority.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 3

shirley

very cute

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Irina C

We visited this coffee shop multiple times in the past. But always ordered familiar items like halva and baclava.
But one day we got a surprise bag thru GoodToGo and we amazed at the tast and flavors of various wonderful bakery items in our surprise bag. The muffin was the best we had in a long time; the “everything “ bagel was soft and delicious, the danish with cardamom was sumptuous, raspberries tart is soon good! And it was not all - almond croissant, golden raisins danish etc. And Adel added a slice of rose water halva! Now , that we tasted some of his goodies, we will be stopping at this shop more often for amazing , unique sweet treats!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

LaTonya Ford

Bad service!! Owner is a bully!!

Ayesha Zulfiqar

One of the worst café experiences I've had. Save your money. The place is very unhygienic — I was served cold empanadas, and when I asked to have them heated, they were microwaved to the point of being soggy and inedible. I wouldn’t be surprised if I end up with a stomach bug. The staff, especially the man at the counter, was extremely rude and offered pathetic customer service. I ended up leaving the empanadas on the counter and walking out. Avoid this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

LoL

went there for coffee. ordered a latte and it was terrible. it is burning hot, and the milk did not froth well. negative note of coffee is.very personal so i can only say i had one sip and tossed the whole.thing.

Irene Bornios

I got a too good to go order that I could pick up from 4 to 7 got there around 6:45 and they were closed.

M B

The short version…if you’re looking for a good cup of coffee in Milburn, skip Starbucks and go here instead. I had a fantastic cup of fresh roasted Sumatra. I’ve roasted my own coffee in the past, so I can tell the difference between someone that’s taking the time to really put the effort into making a good cup of coffee versus Starbucks, etc. :-) The guy who served me could not have been any nicer or more helpful or prouder about the quality of his product. It’s really nice to see a small coffee shop a couple of doors down from “the big guy” competing and making a much better cup of coffee. As a few other reviewers have noted, about the only constructive criticism I can come up with is to expand the quantity and types of food they’re offering, and maybe make more of the existing space to provide seating for customers, although that could be a challenge. Actually, it was a pretty great experience and made my day. If you’re looking for a cup of coffee in Millburn, forget Starbucks go here instead.

Neha Naveen

Beautiful local coffee shop with a personalized touch!

Samantha Hastick

My friend got a drink from here and it didn’t taste anything like what it was supposed to very big variety of drinks, but we only tried one. It was disappointed. It’s very cute though outside. Maybe I’ll have to try again.

Varvara Reznichenko

Great local spot!
Highly recommend!:)

Shaany Raut

The coffee was great. I just think you can improve this shop. People usually come to coffee shops with a laptop and notebook to do work. You can get larger tables that can fit about 2 laptops and install more outlets for customers to charge their items. There was free working Wi-Fi though! These tables are very tiny and easy to spill your drink. The coffee was good but you can add to your drink selection. The decaf coffee was unavailable. Which is surprising because its a popular drink for people who don't need caffeine in their diet.

Walter Behaylo

Came here for a catch up with my ex girlfriend. Great coffee and conversation, atmosphere was very warm and friendly. Got a cup of joe and it was quite delectable, as was the pastry.

Sat at a nice 2 top against the brick wall, with a dry plant behind me. The back window provided warm illumination. Not enough space for a large party here, I’d be curious to see it on a busy Saturday morning. But for a Wednesday afternoon, it was perfect.

Loading...