Peter's

61 Main St, Millburn
(973) 564-9600

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Michael MikeyDell Del Viscovo

Everything is amazing!

H Mccoy

I very much loved the dishes and customer service, excellent area close to my apartment. The staff members are always super nice. Will visit here again.

Kenneth Stanton

This site is my number one restaurant. Of all restaurants I know I like it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to this restaurant. Whenever I feel like having a fair meal, this is the place that comes first to my head. superb and many types of food and a rich menu.professional staff, and good atmosphere. And very important, the price is reasonable. I sent my friends to this place with great pleasure.

faridap2018

Life’s too much too short to spend any time at an average Italian restaurant with a rude owner. The owner, Pete, must think it’s cool to be rude to his customers or to not wear a mask.

John Tino

Always quality dining

Frank Sculco

Amazing!!

Jack Blewis

A truly fine Italian restaurant in Millburn. Food is super and the staff is friendly and helpful. Bread is great. Goes well with the Italian food. Prices are quite reasonably On a main thoroughfare and parking is just around the corner. Worth the visit. A must when I'm in Millburn.

Amahl Cain

Very disappointed at the service we recieved. We arrived and sat there for over 30 min before even getting a server. The server took our order didn't returned to see if we had gotten it delivered to us. My guest's food wasn't even placed. We decided to take our food to go since we had to wait for his to be made. I think what aggravated me more is the manager didn't even come to our table to apologize. We didn't ask for anything, paid our bill in full and still tipped more than 20% . I understand times are difficult right now, but as a fellow restaurant manager I learned to still make sure to wow everyone that walks into my establishment. Food for thought.Amahl

John martino

Always quality dining

Walter Cooper

I love this spot! They provide fantastic food, their menu is nice, The chief cook in that restaurant is very experienced, I like a lot trying all their dishes. The dishes are always of high class, the service towards the guests is friendly. I frequently visit this place and I was never unsatisfied. I highly recommend it.

625rickm

Good dependable basic Italian food, with very good fish specials. Go early if a table for 2 is required as there are only reservations for 4 or more. The restaurant is small and the owners (Peter and his father Peter) are great people!!

Steve & Judy Reichman

Good food, standard Italian. Small, cozy atmosphere. Good service. We'll be back.

Jeffrey

Great food and service. Loved everything we tried. Our waiter was attentive but not intrusive. Would definitely return.

Valentine's Day they seemed to be overbooked- food came at various times- no one asked us for a reservation- so even though we had one - they seemed to be seating anyone who walked in and therefore they seemed overwhelmed- ran out of foods never got to desert etc. could just be a everyone's experience on Valentine's Day - maybe not wise to go out anywhere on that day.

Opentable Diner

Valentine's Day they seemed to be overbooked- food came at various times- no one asked us for a reservation- so even though we had one - they seemed to be seating anyone who walked in and therefore they seemed overwhelmed- ran out of foods never got to desert etc. could just be a everyone's experience on Valentine's Day - maybe not wise to go out anywhere on that day.

Loading...