Really disappointed in this place. Not because of the okay pizza but because of the man child working the counter. I had the pizza. It was rushed, bottom wasn’t crunchy at all, but still not a bad pie. But this man baby working the counter, sheesh. I watched a customer walk in and ask for a personal pie and proceeded to watch the man child throw a tantrum. Dude chastised the hell out of the patron just because it was passed 2pm and they don’t make personal pies past that apparently. Talked to this poor man like a child because of a question. And after all that proceeds to make the pie after the customer goes to leave SMH. If you were gonna make it, why act like a child and throw the tantrum. Really left a bad impression on me. I owned a very successful restaurant in Chatham township and would never turn away a potential customer, let alone treat them in this manor over a technicality. Mind you, it wasn’t like 5 and it ends at 2. It just turned 3pm. With the economy being so weak and people literally penny pinching, turning away customers or treating them like this is a dumb move. DO BETTER!!!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Brian Kernan
Located on Main Street in Millburn, New Jersey, Vinnie offers 15 types of pizza, plus soups, salads, sandwiches, pasta and parmesan dishes. I had the personal cheese pie (10 inches or so), and the ingredients are high quality and fresh. I found the bread to be exceptional and the cheese very good and the sauce perhaps uneventful. The pizza crust lacks a cornicione (the outer edge, typically bread only), and Vinnie boasts of this approach on its stylish site. The dining area is small (2 tables) but clean and modern, and the service is friendly.
A M
It’s okay pizza , but $31 for a pie is ridiculous. The pepperoni is long thin slices… they should really tell you that when you order but whatever. & they said they don’t have “specialty” pizzas, I had asked for chicken cutlet pizza. The slices in a pie are SMALL, not sure if single slices are bigger but I won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Gerson Chapin
Good food
Maria Molina
Good pizza, good eggplant parm and nice place to stop for a bite
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Taylor Marion
Walked in with my mom with high hopes. Wasn’t busy it’s was one family enjoying their pizza and one other person waiting for his order. Stood there for five mins and was never acknowledged by the two workers. They continued to have meaningless conversation with the customer waiting for his order. Awkwardly we stood there looking at the two workers and eachother and decided to walk out. Very careful about where I spend my money. Hoping this isn’t a reflection of the pizza itself… but the rudeness was a complete turn off. High hopes, very disappointing. We decided to go to Joes in Springfield where the pizza is amazing and we are always welcomed. Thankfully it was only a seven minute ride.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Joe Faraldi
Ordered last night. Pasta fagioli, pizza and a salad. Pizza was overcooked and dry. The soup was mostly pasta and the $24 salad, while good, was small and worth maybe half of that amount.
Not sure what the big deal is with this place. Basic NJ pizzeria, super over-priced.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tori Bunn
Stephanie great customer experience thank you !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter Mercuri Channel 24
Great Pizza, also fresh made Pasta e Fagioli, house salad ALL GREAT!
The best pizza in town hands down! We dropped by on a fluke and custom made a Vinnie's plain with hot peppers, onions and mushrooms. They were so nice and let us sit inside even though they were about to close in 20 mins. The pizza was super thin, and burnt, tasty cheese was all the way to the crust. The sauce was out of the world and we finished a 16 inch pizza in 20 mins flat. Highly highly recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Vinnie Pizza
Julia Egan
We had a party for 25 adults at our house. Ordered 10 pizzas. Ordering process was smooth and easy. Pizzas were delivered on time. Got a lot of compliments! Everyone loved them. Staff at Vinnie's were really friendly and the whole experience was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaushik Chakravarty
Amazing pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Gramps
Martino Chesney
Pizza is very good!! Crispy, great taste, and amazing flavor !!!!!
J Gray
Very good pizza. Crispy bottom, perfect amount of sauce, and delicious toppings. Very good service too. We came in from out of state and asked for the personal pizza. Even though they didn't serve personal pizzas at the time of day we came, they offered to do it for us. Over all a great experience.
top pie and the best crust and great staff
Really disappointed in this place. Not because of the okay pizza but because of the man child working the counter. I had the pizza. It was rushed, bottom wasn’t crunchy at all, but still not a bad pie. But this man baby working the counter, sheesh. I watched a customer walk in and ask for a personal pie and proceeded to watch the man child throw a tantrum. Dude chastised the hell out of the patron just because it was passed 2pm and they don’t make personal pies past that apparently. Talked to this poor man like a child because of a question. And after all that proceeds to make the pie after the customer goes to leave SMH. If you were gonna make it, why act like a child and throw the tantrum. Really left a bad impression on me. I owned a very successful restaurant in Chatham township and would never turn away a potential customer, let alone treat them in this manor over a technicality. Mind you, it wasn’t like 5 and it ends at 2. It just turned 3pm. With the economy being so weak and people literally penny pinching, turning away customers or treating them like this is a dumb move. DO BETTER!!!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Located on Main Street in Millburn, New Jersey, Vinnie offers 15 types of pizza, plus soups, salads, sandwiches, pasta and parmesan dishes. I had the personal cheese pie (10 inches or so), and the ingredients are high quality and fresh. I found the bread to be exceptional and the cheese very good and the sauce perhaps uneventful. The pizza crust lacks a cornicione (the outer edge, typically bread only), and Vinnie boasts of this approach on its stylish site. The dining area is small (2 tables) but clean and modern, and the service is friendly.
It’s okay pizza , but $31 for a pie is ridiculous. The pepperoni is long thin slices… they should really tell you that when you order but whatever. & they said they don’t have “specialty” pizzas, I had asked for chicken cutlet pizza. The slices in a pie are SMALL, not sure if single slices are bigger but I won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Good food
Good pizza, good eggplant parm and nice place to stop for a bite
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Walked in with my mom with high hopes. Wasn’t busy it’s was one family enjoying their pizza and one other person waiting for his order. Stood there for five mins and was never acknowledged by the two workers. They continued to have meaningless conversation with the customer waiting for his order. Awkwardly we stood there looking at the two workers and eachother and decided to walk out. Very careful about where I spend my money. Hoping this isn’t a reflection of the pizza itself… but the rudeness was a complete turn off. High hopes, very disappointing. We decided to go to Joes in Springfield where the pizza is amazing and we are always welcomed. Thankfully it was only a seven minute ride.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Ordered last night. Pasta fagioli, pizza and a salad. Pizza was overcooked and dry. The soup was mostly pasta and the $24 salad, while good, was small and worth maybe half of that amount.
Not sure what the big deal is with this place. Basic NJ pizzeria, super over-priced.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Stephanie great customer experience thank you !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Pizza, also fresh made Pasta e Fagioli, house salad ALL GREAT!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Vinnie Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
The best pizza in town hands down! We dropped by on a fluke and custom made a Vinnie's plain with hot peppers, onions and mushrooms. They were so nice and let us sit inside even though they were about to close in 20 mins. The pizza was super thin, and burnt, tasty cheese was all the way to the crust. The sauce was out of the world and we finished a 16 inch pizza in 20 mins flat. Highly highly recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Vinnie Pizza
We had a party for 25 adults at our house. Ordered 10 pizzas. Ordering process was smooth and easy. Pizzas were delivered on time. Got a lot of compliments! Everyone loved them. Staff at Vinnie's were really friendly and the whole experience was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Gramps
Pizza is very good!! Crispy, great taste, and amazing flavor !!!!!
Very good pizza. Crispy bottom, perfect amount of sauce, and delicious toppings. Very good service too. We came in from out of state and asked for the personal pizza. Even though they didn't serve personal pizzas at the time of day we came, they offered to do it for us. Over all a great experience.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Roni Pizza
Loading...