Jersey Cookie Girl
441 Millstone Rd, Millstone
(732) 213-0590
Customers' Favorites
Orange Creamsicle Cookies
Thanksgiving Cookies
Sugar Cookies
Sugar Cookie
Cookie Kits
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Jersey cookie girl, makes the most DELICIOUS, melt in your mouth cookies! She can make any custom sugar cookies, they come out amazing! I found her in early Feb, and it’s now March, a week or so from April, and I’ve ordered from her 3 more times in between and dropped in many many more to grab a few cookies. Be careful, they are addicting and you may find yourself there all the time once you have one of Nicole’s cookies. She made my son’s Sesame Street themed bday cookies...
I am so pleased with Jersey Cookie Girl! When I called to place my order, she took a lot of time learning about the personalities of the people they were for so that she could create custom cookies that were extra special for a 40th and 21st birthday party. Not only were the cookies adorable, they were absolutely delicious! I definitely recommend Jersey Cookie Girl and I look forward to finding an event so I can order again!
Hello , I ordered 70 cookies for my daughter’s graduation and these were the most delicious cookies we have ever had!!! All our guests raved at how beautifully made they were and how tasty ? they were! Nicole is a beautifully talented baker and so sweet which I believe is what makes her cookies so special…she genuinely loves what she does and cares for her customers. I HIGHLY recommend.
You May Also Like
Bella Napoli - 441 Millstone Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Dairy Queen Brazier - 40 Trenton Lakewood Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers
GianMarco's - 504 Monmouth Rd
![]()
Pizza, American, Italian, New American, Vegetarian