Jersey Cookie Girl
441 Millstone Rd, Millstone
(732) 213-0590
Customers' Favorites
Orange Creamsicle Cookies
Thanksgiving Cookies
Sugar Cookies
Sugar Cookie
Cookie Kits
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I recently worked with Jersey Cookie Girl to create custom cookies for my baby sprinkle, and the experience was wonderful. Nicole was incredibly easy to work with and took the time to connect with me several times by phone and email to ensure my vision aligned perfectly with her design process. I would absolutely recommend Jersey Cookie Girl to friends and family and will definitely be a returning customer!
After stopping into the shop in Red Bank many times enjoying different cookies each time, my daughter asked if we could get cookies as the favors for her Mermaid and Pirates themed birthday party.
We sent some inspiration along with our order request, and they came out absolutely adorable- my daughter (7) said they were exactly what she wanted. The process of ordering was easy, they were ready to go as planned (and I really appreciate the individual packaging). Even...
We sent some inspiration along with our order request, and they came out absolutely adorable- my daughter (7) said they were exactly what she wanted. The process of ordering was easy, they were ready to go as planned (and I really appreciate the individual packaging). Even...
Nicole is absolutely incredible! She’s so talented and kind. I went to her last minute wanting cookies for a bachelorette party, not even knowing what I wanted, and she showed me some inspiration pics and had cookies ready for me a few days later!!! You can tell she really loves what she does and goes above and beyond to make customers happy!
You May Also Like
Bella Napoli - 441 Millstone Rd
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Dairy Queen Brazier - 40 Trenton Lakewood Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers
GianMarco's - 504 Monmouth Rd
![]()
Pizza, American, Italian, New American, Vegetarian