We have been here for dinner a few times and it has always been fantastic. From the warmth and care of the service to the food being made with precision and love. There was no doubt this is where we wanted to have our wedding dinner. After our initial inquiry about the event, the manager Arianna, was so receptive and accommodating to all of our requests. From the menu creation and adjustments to our needs and wants, she outdid herself at every turn. Then came time for the event itself.
Blown away!!
The room was set up wonderfully and even with that, she allowed our family to come in and redecorate the day before without any hesitation. The night of the event the party showed up 30 minutes early and they were ready and waiting. Appetizers came right out and wine was poured right on time. Being a BYOB, they made sure our wine was available and kept the glasses filled throughout the night, most times without us noticing. When we arrived they allowed us to greet everyone and get our bearings before the first course came out. Throughout the meal, everything was paced perfectly, even allowing time to bring extra dishes before dinner to make sure everyone got a chance to enjoy them. The food speaks for itself, A+ from start to finish, you can’t go wrong with anything here!!
The staff was professional and accommodating without being overbearing and as a lifelong restaurant professional, I notice these things. I can not thank them enough as they made the evening of our special day the perfect ending!! If you are looking for somewhere to have an event or even just dinner, do yourself a favor and call them, you won’t regret it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peggy Reilly
We were looking forward to a cousins reunion and Ariana was great to work with planning the space and menu. Unfortunately we had a sudden death in the family and had to cancel days in advance. We appreciated their understanding and refund of our deposit. Look forward to trying the food in the future.
Nancy Han
Been wanting to come here for a while now, but their reservation system is a little bit challenging for making reservations, but we finally did it last night.
Food was very good and atmosphere is very romantic. We used to go to Support Italiano and now I think this is our new place. Chef makes authentic Italian food and brought us back to Italy with the pasta dishes. Just note the spaghetti is actually Pici type of noodles, not your typical American spaghetti but very tasty.
BYOB like most of the places here in Cape May. We hope they will fix the reservation system and make it a little bit more friendly to use. We had a reservation but it was written on their book so it was not in their system. We didn’t have to wait like Crazy amount of time but did have us wait around 20 minutes. Not too bad, but we all have areas of improvements. In summary, I highly recommend this place if you want to have authentic Italian food in a very romantic place this is it. I especially like their light fixtures. Almost forgot to mention that their dessert is one of the best. We had a pumpkin cheesecake dessert. It was light, delicious, full of flavor and super fresh. Our dinner had an amazing happy ending.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pumpkin Cheesecake
Anthony Limongelli
We had the pleasure of dining here September 9, 2024. We were warmly greeted and received flawless service throughout the duration of our dinner. We are definitely foodies and wanted to try a little bit of everything. We started with the scallops and homemade ziti as our first course. Both were phenomenal. We also had the fried calamari, butternut squash soup, braciole and pollo al pepperoni. Every dish had layers of flavors, each more delicious than the next. The food was hot and portions were perfect considering this is meant to be a traditional Italian dinner (with multiple courses). We finished with the house made crème brûlée and orange ricotta cheesecake. Again, depths of flavor. Our waitress brought over complimentary limoncello as a finisher which was a very nice touch. It is important to note— this is a fine dining experience and the prices are reflective of such, but it is truly worth it if you value fresh, flavorful food -exquisitely prepared.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bracioli, Scallops with Spinach and Lemon Cream Sauce Appetizer, Ziti Alla Vodka
Karly Daplyn
Went to Andreas this past weekend - it was amazing. The arugula salad with the truffle oil was one of the best I've ever had. We also got the scallop special for an app- sooo good. We both got pasta dishes for our meal- 10/10! Service was great - we will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sylvia Glass
Excellent service, Excellent food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Ravalli
This was the worst dining experience ever. I asked for gnocchi bolongese and was told by the waiter that it was impossible to do that. He suggested I should have the gnocchi with tomatoe sauce. That did not make any sense since the bolongese sauce was available with fettuccine. When the dish arrived the portion was ridiculously small. The overall experience leaves alot to be desired.
Nancy Gagliano
I've been going to Cape May for over 26 years and never have had a dining experience so poorly. Each year I try to visit a few restaurants I've never been to and this year one of them was Andrea Trattoria. We arrived and sat on the porch (tables are very close together). We wanted to order appetizers first as we didn't know what we wanted for a main meal. The waiter told us we had to order everything up front. I said fine, we will just go with the apps then. He said he needed to talk to his manager. She then came over and told us it was a policy that everything need to be ordered at once, but since they were not busy she would allow it but know for the future this will not be accommodated. We were a little taken back but still ordered the apps. The waiter then came over and said he needed to take our menus so they wouldn't get dirty (as I was looking for our main meal) and would return them after our apps. It's the most bizarre dinner experience I've every had and will NOT be back. The reason for my 2 star review was that the apps were good quality.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Michael Flusk
Everything was delicious and may have been some of the best food I have eaten in my life! Dessert was amazing! Highly recommend this restaurant! The complimentary homemade lemoncello was great!
Love this small quaint restraunt. Everything was prepared terrific and pasta we shared was the best I ever tasted. Our meals were delicious as well. Will be coming back end of the month. A new fave for sure. A Gem.
Amazing! Best Gnocchi of my life. Excellent service and experience.
Me
The portion size is ridiculously small for that price and there's no salad with it. No bread or nothing. It was a waste of money
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ciro Armenino
Food outstanding service really friendly and caring! I will definitely recommend to my friends and family Finally a great italian restaurant in Cape May! Bravo Andrea !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joseph Serianni
Great little place with a professional crew but can’t understand how they can serve Veal Milanese deep fried to death and placed over some greens. Completely inedible. Absolutely no flavor because it was exterminated in a French fryer not pan fried as expected. Also had the sea bass that was uninspired and tasteless. You can do better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Andrew Saunders
You’re going to want to lick the plate. Get the scallops and gnocchi.
We have been here for dinner a few times and it has always been fantastic. From the warmth and care of the service to the food being made with precision and love. There was no doubt this is where we wanted to have our wedding dinner.
After our initial inquiry about the event, the manager Arianna, was so receptive and accommodating to all of our requests. From the menu creation and adjustments to our needs and wants, she outdid herself at every turn. Then came time for the event itself.
Blown away!!
The room was set up wonderfully and even with that, she allowed our family to come in and redecorate the day before without any hesitation. The night of the event the party showed up 30 minutes early and they were ready and waiting. Appetizers came right out and wine was poured right on time. Being a BYOB, they made sure our wine was available and kept the glasses filled throughout the night, most times without us noticing.
When we arrived they allowed us to greet everyone and get our bearings before the first course came out. Throughout the meal, everything was paced perfectly, even allowing time to bring extra dishes before dinner to make sure everyone got a chance to enjoy them.
The food speaks for itself, A+ from start to finish, you can’t go wrong with anything here!!
The staff was professional and accommodating without being overbearing and as a lifelong restaurant professional, I notice these things. I can not thank them enough as they made the evening of our special day the perfect ending!!
If you are looking for somewhere to have an event or even just dinner, do yourself a favor and call them, you won’t regret it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were looking forward to a cousins reunion and Ariana was great to work with planning the space and menu. Unfortunately we had a sudden death in the family and had to cancel days in advance. We appreciated their understanding and refund of our deposit. Look forward to trying the food in the future.
Been wanting to come here for a while now, but their reservation system is a little bit challenging for making reservations, but we finally did it last night.
Food was very good and atmosphere is very romantic. We used to go to Support Italiano and now I think this is our new place. Chef makes authentic Italian food and brought us back to Italy with the pasta dishes. Just note the spaghetti is actually Pici type of noodles, not your typical American spaghetti but very tasty.
BYOB like most of the places here in Cape May. We hope they will fix the reservation system and make it a little bit more friendly to use. We had a reservation but it was written on their book so it was not in their system. We didn’t have to wait like Crazy amount of time but did have us wait around 20 minutes. Not too bad, but we all have areas of improvements. In summary, I highly recommend this place if you want to have authentic Italian food in a very romantic place this is it. I especially like their light fixtures. Almost forgot to mention that their dessert is one of the best. We had a pumpkin cheesecake dessert. It was light, delicious, full of flavor and super fresh. Our dinner had an amazing happy ending.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pumpkin Cheesecake
We had the pleasure of dining here September 9, 2024. We were warmly greeted and received flawless service throughout the duration of our dinner. We are definitely foodies and wanted to try a little bit of everything. We started with the scallops and homemade ziti as our first course. Both were phenomenal. We also had the fried calamari, butternut squash soup, braciole and pollo al pepperoni. Every dish had layers of flavors, each more delicious than the next. The food was hot and portions were perfect considering this is meant to be a traditional Italian dinner (with multiple courses). We finished with the house made crème brûlée and orange ricotta cheesecake. Again, depths of flavor. Our waitress brought over complimentary limoncello as a finisher which was a very nice touch. It is important to note— this is a fine dining experience and the prices are reflective of such, but it is truly worth it if you value fresh, flavorful food -exquisitely prepared.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bracioli, Scallops with Spinach and Lemon Cream Sauce Appetizer, Ziti Alla Vodka
Went to Andreas this past weekend - it was amazing. The arugula salad with the truffle oil was one of the best I've ever had. We also got the scallop special for an app- sooo good. We both got pasta dishes for our meal- 10/10! Service was great - we will be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent service, Excellent food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was the worst dining experience ever. I asked for gnocchi bolongese and was told by the waiter that it was impossible to do that. He suggested I should have the gnocchi with tomatoe sauce. That did not make any sense since the bolongese sauce was available with fettuccine.
When the dish arrived the portion was ridiculously small.
The overall experience leaves alot to be desired.
I've been going to Cape May for over 26 years and never have had a dining experience so poorly. Each year I try to visit a few restaurants I've never been to and this year one of them was Andrea Trattoria. We arrived and sat on the porch (tables are very close together). We wanted to order appetizers first as we didn't know what we wanted for a main meal. The waiter told us we had to order everything up front. I said fine, we will just go with the apps then. He said he needed to talk to his manager. She then came over and told us it was a policy that everything need to be ordered at once, but since they were not busy she would allow it but know for the future this will not be accommodated. We were a little taken back but still ordered the apps. The waiter then came over and said he needed to take our menus so they wouldn't get dirty (as I was looking for our main meal) and would return them after our apps. It's the most bizarre dinner experience I've every had and will NOT be back. The reason for my 2 star review was that the apps were good quality.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Everything was delicious and may have been some of the best food I have eaten in my life! Dessert was amazing! Highly recommend this restaurant! The complimentary homemade lemoncello was great!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scallop App, Striped Bass, Veal Valdostano
Love this small quaint restraunt. Everything was prepared terrific and pasta we shared was the best I ever tasted. Our meals were delicious as well. Will be coming back end of the month. A new fave for sure. A Gem.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing! Best Gnocchi of my life. Excellent service and experience.
The portion size is ridiculously small for that price and there's no salad with it. No bread or nothing. It was a waste of money
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Food outstanding service really friendly and caring! I will definitely recommend to my friends and family Finally a great italian restaurant in Cape May! Bravo Andrea !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great little place with a professional crew but can’t understand how they can serve Veal Milanese deep fried to death and placed over some greens. Completely inedible. Absolutely no flavor because it was exterminated in a French fryer not pan fried as expected. Also had the sea bass that was uninspired and tasteless. You can do better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
You’re going to want to lick the plate. Get the scallops and gnocchi.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...