Old Oar House Irish Pub

123 N High St, Millville
(856) 293-1200

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jake Jake

this is my favorite bar. the staff is really friendly and inviting, especially tiff! this bar wouldnt be the same without her! she always has the best recommendations from the beer tap

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

jakeofmillville

the food is amazing, the staff is even better, and the drinks are cold! tiffany is my absolute favorite bartender, very attentive and super nice! thank you for the best bar in town

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lindsey Slimmer

Wonderful bar, always an amazing welcoming experience. Great food and drinks and even better staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Guiness Stew Beef, Wings

Bill Nichols

Service , drinks and food are amazing. Even with a sold out show at the Levoy Theatre . Parents who bring their children to a pub at max capacity on a Saturday night should not leave them unattended.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Reuben Sandwich

Patricia Crockett

Amazing food and service, there was a show at Levoy and bar and servers were amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jasen Sigafuse

Very friendly service reasonable prices and very welcoming environment. I highly recommend the ribeye

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathy Hughes

Slow service, overcrowded, had to sit in beergarden at nite in Dec, it ws freezing

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Itay Hamerman

We had a bug party, we had two waiters one was really nice but the other was very rude, she threw the check on the table she yelled at the kids, and she said no to a request

Jennifer A. Allen

Tiffany is a great bartender!

Tracie Dzindzio

Bartender outside was extremely rude. Definitely will not be returning. Our party of 8 left without ordering food.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Thomas Turner

Great spot, food and drinks are really good. The decore is unique. Only issue we had for a table of 7 is the food took way too long. About 45-50 mins after ordering.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Crab Cake Sandwich

Carol Caola

I got the Chili Burger & Sweet Potato Fries. I didn't need anything on my burger, no condiments because the chili had just the right amount of spice. I did a bunless burger. The sweet potato fries were awesome and on point! I would go back for both!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Edna TittleWright

Its a bar/pub/tavern that's why I gave 3 star for atmosphere. I must say its a very clean pub and the food is great! The Ruben is the best I have ever had, they make their own corned beef and it is delicious.They also have a great Fish n Chips. They always have wide variety of great beer on tap. Debbie is also a great bar tender and all around server, she always make you feel welcome and will always steer you in the right direction for food and drink If out for a day or a trip home from the shore a great place to stop for food and drink.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Guiness Stew Beef, Fish and Chips, Corned Beef Sandwich, BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger

Tammy Rappa Brown

The Reuben bites were amazing. I ordered some To take home as well. Self. I felt like the Irish stew had too much flour or roux in it. And the shepherd's pie was very watery. It wasn't dense at all like a pie should be. It was more like shepherd's pie soup but a little bit thicker than that. I threw it away. But we have great service and Good original cocktails. The bartender makes great drinks it's a nice little place. I like pubs. I like the paneling and the darkness. It is smaller than some of the pubs I've been to. It's more like a corner bar type of deal but with pub like characteristics.PS
The pineapple cup (which I forgot lol) is complimentary, if you order that drink which was amazing!!!!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fried Pickles

HouseMusic609

If you want an attitude from walking in for NO reason, then go there. If you walk in with a bottle don't assume (new waiter apparently) we are drinking alcohol, how about you communicate the rules, not give us an attitude the whole time. So me and my friends stopped in after karting and we were met with an attitude from the start. Once we were seated and ordered food the heavyset female waiter had an attitude the whole time. Everytime we asked for anything her response was I only have two hands, not something along the lines of I got you. SHE NEVER STOPPED BY OUR TABLE ONCE TO ASK/CHECK IF WE NEEDED ANYTHING after we ordered or got our food. Never brought us more water or napkins. SHE PLAIN IGNORED US LIKE WE WERE NOT THERE! I dont know how you ignore your customers, and expect a TIP.Then she proceeds to throw our food at us, had to grab the platter or it would have slipped off the table, talk about rude. Then smacks the ketchup bottle on the table. What was her deal?, anyones guess. Once i brought this up the HEATHER( bartender) to be civil, I was told the waiter was NEW, to my surprise.I tried to explain to heather how we felt, but it fell on deaf ears. I only asked for the waiter to relax, as she is hostile and all heather could respond with was "shes new, do you live around here?", "have you worked in customer service job before?" Is that supposed to validate the disrespect? Unbelievable to show no compassion. I understand people have bad days, but if we knew that is how we would have been treated we would have done business with someone else. AVOID AVOID AVOID! Whoever is in charge of the front staff, you need to retrain them, as this is how they treat your paying customers. Despicable!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Loading...