Amici Bakery & Pastry Shop

I just had the best cake for my son’s 50th. Not only did it look great but it was delicious! I will be back for every event! Their pastries were amazing as well and the girl behind the counter couldn’t have been more helpful. She even brought the cake to my car!!

I asked for a strawberry short cake for my daughters bday and asked if it would be okay to put a couple of blue dots on the boarder of the cake and write happy birthday on it. They quoted me a price and when I went to pick it up the lady added an extra $5 to the price because since they added literally 3 dots of blue icing that makes it a “custom cake” even the young girl that worked there was so confused on the price and originally thought the lady misspoke. So yea go here if you like feeling taken advantage of for a mediocre cake.

I moved from North Jersey about it 18 months ago. I finally found an Italian bakery that’s comparable to anyone where I used to live. The food is amazing. The people are fantastic. The cookies too.

I have been a fan of Amici bakery since they opened in Monroe Township.
Growing up in Brooklyn it was frustrating when our family moved to NJ in 2000 as pizza , bakery goods, Italian foods etc were dear to our hearts but something was missing. Slowly but surely the pizza & bakery started showing signs of bringing out the quality I remembered.
When Amici bakery opened I prayed that it would live up to the bakeries I remembered, Luigi Alba to name the Earliest of my memories.
I know these days are hard for the Mom & Pop shops to make it but on Easter .I saw the owner sitting on the side of the counter when I picked up a birthday cake on Easter & had a conversation with him. It's a rough buisiness & hours are long. I truly appreciate you & your family for bringing the quality that I,we remember .

Thank you , Tony

This is a family favorite bakery. And it's worth the trip! Owned by amazing family. I cannot say enough good things about their staff. Or their cookies!

Great friendly staff, well stocked... Super clean.

Amici was so helpful with designing an Elmo cake for our son's birthday. They did an amazing job and the cake was delicious! Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ordered a really last minute cake for my husbands birthday. Amici’s did a great job! Couldn’t have been happier. I told them he loved to golf and they decorated it so well. Would highly recommend them!

Food: 5

Service: 5

I live in somerset county where I experience sticker shock with many bakeries. I traveled to a nursery nearby to purchase my holiday greens and found this gem. I needed a cake for a lady’s night dinner. When I walked into Amici, the smell of baked goods was heavenly. The prices were fair with a nice price range that didn’t break the bank. I bought a fabulous checkerboard cake and it was a huge hit. I will definitely stop by again when I’m in the area. Wonderful business with friendly service and pride.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I called to check if they can make Coco Tres Leche cake and they quickly confirmed but I was little hesitant so I visited the store and showed them the picture , the girl at the front desk noted all as the baker was not there, then comes a day of pick up , the cake dint had Coco and it had a THICK layer of vanilla icing, cake was moist but which tres leche cake has vanilla icing. Paid $35 and it was not worth it at all. Waisted time and money. I don’t get it if you cannot make Tres Leche correctly then why take an order and waste customers money.👎

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Whenever we visit Old Bridge NJ, we always try to visit Amici, this wonderful bakery that makes fresh cookies, pastries, cakes…every day. I always pack goodies for my Doctor and neighbors. Delicious and worth every visit. Customer service is helpful and great. Kudos to the owners.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This place is ok…. Not my first choice the best is L'Affaire II Bake Shoppe everything is amazing and in my opinion better flavor and the cheese cake will keep you coming for more. I drive from Pennsylvania and this is my first stop.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

I want to swim in the French cream! Yes, that amazing. I'm never disappointed getting dessert here! Best carrot cake and Italian mini pastries. Haven't tried their ice cream cake yet, but it's on the list.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommend grain pie, fruit tart. Both are the best I’ve ever had.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 2

Great cannolis

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cannoli