MONTCLAIR PASTA COMPANY

33 Walnut St, Montclair
(973) 746-6778

Recent Reviews

Michael Kreie

Great interior fantastic

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread

Dallas Lamb

Makes delivery drivers stand outside in the cold. Terrible establishment.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Tim Baker

The food is pretty but extremely overpriced unless you do the buy one/get one free deal. Unfortunately that’s only limited to a few items.

Food: 3

MarcoMan1

Went to this restaurant late. It was empty. Server was friendly but not very knowledgeable. They pride themselves on homemade pasta but none was available. All entrees were good. Better choices in the area.

Gina D

Unorganized, under new management- Extremely unprofessional. Not equipped to host events for 20+ guests. Unable to handle volume. Disastrous-

Leah R

Recently attended an event: Sad to see such a well known local Montclair establishment fall into the hands of poor management. Cake was taken to the back kitchen and literally butchered and plastered onto plates. TERRIBLE presentation of what seemed to be a delicately crafted pastry. Extremely unorganized and incapable of handling high volume traffic for events it seems (less than 48 guests in room). Most importantly, not enough food for guests during buffet service!!!!!! -Alcohol servers had no idea how to pour wine. -Restaurant manager poorly dressed to be hosting a family-Sunday event. EXTREMELY disappointed….. Sad to say establishment has gone down the drain when hosting events.

Jazzi Jay

They put Montclair to shame. I would Expect better food to come out of that town. We ordered Uber eats. Food was $50 not including tip and it was pure trash. The chicken parm sandwiches were these tiny little things and the cheese were nonexistent. The calamari was the texture of cardboard and the mozzarella sticks were a joke as well. The bag was very light for the amount of money we paid. It has to be really bad if I leave a review. Save your money. Do not order here.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Berteal Butler

Okay so, the comments had me so afraid of receiving my order on Uber eats, but I agree with some of the comments others have left; I don’t see how this restaurant gets such negative reviews.I ordered the meatballs and penne with extra sauce and when I tell you they delivered and it is bomb. The food is fresh, flavorful, and I do not feel “sick”. If you’re going to order here base it off the description of the dish and not the negative comments because I ALMOST canceled my order based off “bad reviews”. I’m glad I did not.Time and time again we eat, enjoy, and go on about our day but, today I really want to pause and give flowers and credit where it’s due. This restaurant gets a good rating from me !

Chip

I ordered on 11/12/23 and was delivered through Ubereats. I ordered the ziti with arrabiata sauce and grilled chicken. The ziti was hard and stuck together. For the price and the wait, unacceptable. They looked more like chef boyardee beefaroni canned pasta. I couldn’t believe it. The sauce was nicely seasoned and paid extra for more, since it was recommended. Thank goodness because the pasta was dry and hard. The few pieces of chicken which was an extra $7 was good. Probably won’t order here again even though the price was reasonable smh.

Food: 2

Saudia Hydar

Honestly, each time I've ordered from here they have never failed me. I typically go with the chicken parm or baked ziti. This was my comfort food in the beginning of the year when I went through my battle with breast cancer and again now pregnant!! And you know pregnant taste buds are PICKY! THANK YOU GUYS for feeding me

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sonya Robinson

dont know whats been hoing on there lately..but they keep missing items. My kids penne is supposed to come with ice cream and gelato..i only got 1 (this is the 3rd time..smh). this item had such a small portion..i was mortified...usually its packed and i can get a 2nd round of serving for my kids...this time out of soo many times...it was such a small portion..i waited awhile for this! i called n complained to Stephanie since no mgr was around. last time i ordered this i picked up because the ubereats app said food was ready..had to wait at least 30 min outside in the rain only to get home and my pizza bread and ice cream were missing. The food tastes great but the servings ahave been depleting over a year or so and also missing items on orders seems to keep happening. Not happy AT ALL.

Food: 5

Service: 2

Karla de jesus

I don’t know why the reviews are so bad. The food was great and the garlic knots are delicious and BIG. Loved everything!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan, Garlic Knots

Christian Rios

The pasta was amazing , you can tell it’s fresh and real . Made with

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Nicole Degtjarew

I don’t understand all of the negative comments. I’ve ordered many time and never had a problem! Foods always been delicious. Just ordered from there tonight and got the chicken parm over penne with vodka sauce. It was so delicious!! Will continue to order from this establishment

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Tiramisu, Wings

Rachel Densing

We got fettuccini with Alfredo and Bolognese sauce and a side of garlic bread. Not only was our food delayed because the restaurant said it would take an additional 30min (I don't know why, it's pasta), the pasta had multiple areas of cold, hard pasta that you can't even swirl onto your fork or even bend! My first bite was just hard pasta. AND on top of that, we got food poisoning. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Load More