Been coming to this place for a while and it was great. Until recently when they started cutting back on their sandwiches. Protein seems to get thinner and thinner every week. If there’s a shortage just let the customer know don’t just start cutting costs and hope no one says anything.This is what the chicken special looked like
Yash Thakur
This place serves the best sandwiches and salads.
Mark J
I got here before they closed but they wouldn’t let me order. They should really take orders until their advertised closing time.
John Banks
Why go to Starbucks or D&D when you can support a truly local business. I really enjoyed their Taylor ham, egg and cheese on an everything bagel. You can tell it’s made with fresh ingredients! They have great coffee too. Highly recommend - five stars!!
Bob Manix-Cramer
A decent sandwich but there's a 40% chance that they'll answer your call around lunch time. So we often eat elsewhere after wasting time figuring out which sandwiches our group wants
Nevan J. Medina (Smartboard Kicks)
Went here with a friend and had a GRAND OLD TIME
Angel L Rodriguez
Consistently great sandwiches and food. I love how economical the prices are at this establishment especially in this neighborhood.
Sue P.
Love this place! Food is great, they never make a mistake with an order, and everyone is really kind. Sandwiches are all very good. (Highly recommend their honey mustard!) Also love the breakfast options.
Frances M.
Cuban sandwich!!! Really good! My go to!!! Theyre always so nice and fresh with my sandwich. I usually order for pickup and they never disappoint. The grab and gos are really good too!!
love this place very good veggie gluten free sandwich
Paul Schuler
Great food that is super fast. Staff is friendly and the daily special sandwiches are on point.
Marques Eley
I have only visited Sandwich Theory once but the sandwich I had was excellent. I ordered the grilled chicken panini. The wait for my food was not long, probably 10 minutes. The chicken was juicy without being undercooked, and the mozzarella was think as were the red pepper slices. The pesto was very good, not too salty and not blad either. The portion size was generous.I had a Joe Tea for my beverage. Love their iced tea!The restaurant staff was nice, no complaints.The only ding against this place is the price of the sandwich. It was $9 at the time of this review which is a bit excessive for what it was but I know it includes the "Montclair Mark-up".I would definitely eat here again.
Cylinda Whitted
Chicken Quesedilla. I have been here a few times before so I know what I like and I dove right in, as usual, and decided late on taking a pic so excuse the bite. I also LOVE their lemon bars. Mmmmm. They are a small cafe that is great for take out in this environment. Food is nice and fresh.
Joyce A.
Purely based on service. I ordered online and paid when I got there 5 minutes before pick up time. The order was being bagged up she said. I waited 20 more minutes and I finally asked how much longer since my meter was up and it was sitting on the counter next to her. Waste of my time. Add on... I came home and was missing a soup even though I asked if this was everything. 3 1/2 sandwich soups should come with 3 soups! Ugh
Panini was perfect, bread was perfectly crunchy:)
Been coming to this place for a while and it was great. Until recently when they started cutting back on their sandwiches. Protein seems to get thinner and thinner every week. If there’s a shortage just let the customer know don’t just start cutting costs and hope no one says anything.This is what the chicken special looked like
This place serves the best sandwiches and salads.
I got here before they closed but they wouldn’t let me order. They should really take orders until their advertised closing time.
Why go to Starbucks or D&D when you can support a truly local business. I really enjoyed their Taylor ham, egg and cheese on an everything bagel. You can tell it’s made with fresh ingredients! They have great coffee too. Highly recommend - five stars!!
A decent sandwich but there's a 40% chance that they'll answer your call around lunch time. So we often eat elsewhere after wasting time figuring out which sandwiches our group wants
Went here with a friend and had a GRAND OLD TIME
Consistently great sandwiches and food. I love how economical the prices are at this establishment especially in this neighborhood.
Love this place! Food is great, they never make a mistake with an order, and everyone is really kind. Sandwiches are all very good. (Highly recommend their honey mustard!) Also love the breakfast options.
Cuban sandwich!!! Really good! My go to!!! Theyre always so nice and fresh with my sandwich. I usually order for pickup and they never disappoint. The grab and gos are really good too!!
Restaurantji Recommends
love this place very good veggie gluten free sandwich
Great food that is super fast. Staff is friendly and the daily special sandwiches are on point.
I have only visited Sandwich Theory once but the sandwich I had was excellent. I ordered the grilled chicken panini. The wait for my food was not long, probably 10 minutes. The chicken was juicy without being undercooked, and the mozzarella was think as were the red pepper slices. The pesto was very good, not too salty and not blad either. The portion size was generous.I had a Joe Tea for my beverage. Love their iced tea!The restaurant staff was nice, no complaints.The only ding against this place is the price of the sandwich. It was $9 at the time of this review which is a bit excessive for what it was but I know it includes the "Montclair Mark-up".I would definitely eat here again.
Chicken Quesedilla. I have been here a few times before so I know what I like and I dove right in, as usual, and decided late on taking a pic so excuse the bite. I also LOVE their lemon bars. Mmmmm. They are a small cafe that is great for take out in this environment. Food is nice and fresh.
Purely based on service. I ordered online and paid when I got there 5 minutes before pick up time. The order was being bagged up she said. I waited 20 more minutes and I finally asked how much longer since my meter was up and it was sitting on the counter next to her. Waste of my time. Add on... I came home and was missing a soup even though I asked if this was everything. 3 1/2 sandwich soups should come with 3 soups! Ugh