South Street Creamery & Red Sea Café
146 South St, Morristown
(973) 267-8887
Customers' Favorites
Ham and Swiss Panini
Chicken Doro Tsebhi
Yellow Chicken
Injera Chips
Menu
Photos
+40 photos
+39 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I’ve been going to South Street Creamery for years, and their ice cream has not declined in quality. I love the homemade quality and abundance of flavors. The recent addition of the Red Sea Cafe has brought a refreshing variety to Morristown. The Eritrean dishes are exceptionally fresh and full of flavor—an absolute treat for anyone looking to try something new!
It might have been an off day based on the other reviews people have posted, but I went in craving a plain and simple sweet cream scoop. The person working there was attentive and sweet, and promptly handed me my ice cream. I waited to eat it until I got to my home not too far and with the first bite, I noticed that the flavor was off. It was a bit minty? Maybe where they made the previous batch wasn’t rinsed properly? Not sure, but then as I kept eating, I kept felting pieces...
This restaurant shares a space with South Street Creamery and only serves Eritrean food for dinner. The owner/chef is very friendly and always serves excellent food. There are usually at least 3 vegan options. My favorite is the lentil birsen and it is often the favorite when I bring non-vegans here. Unfortunately, there are no vegan ice cream flavors available. Typically $20-25/person.
You May Also Like
Stirling Tavern - 150 South St
![]()
Bar, Salad, Burgers, American, Vegan
Cluck-U Chicken - 162 South St
![]()
Chicken, Chicken Wings, Fast Food, American
Baklava Cafe - 164 South St
![]()
Cafe, Turkish, Coffee & Tea, Mediterranean