Insomnia Cookies

176 Easton Ave, New Brunswick
(732) 708-6218

Recent Reviews

Sort by
DonMono

Straight up trash! LOL

Mandakini D

Regular here since the location opened and this place never disappoints for the late night warm cookie craving

venkatesha murthy

Awesome vegan cookies

Jay Pandya

Wish i could give negative based on my experience Spent $50 at Insomnia Cookies and had a shockingly bad experience. Rude staff mocked my brother for asking about a cookie, denied me an ice cream sample while offering one to my sister, and escalated to shouting racist remarks and threats as we left. Unprofessional and unacceptable—management needs to address this ASAP.

Has anyone else had issues here? #InsomniaCookies #BadService”

Divyang Patel

Racist folks here, extremely rude service for no reason, I’ve been here before but the current staff is very dissatisfying

Raj G

My family and I visited Insomnia Cookies and spent over $40 on a 6-pack and other items. From the beginning, the employees were extremely rude and unprofessional. When my brother asked about a cookie that wasn’t available, one of the workers slapped the menu and aggressively asked him if he could read. It was completely unnecessary and confrontational.

After receiving our order, I asked to sample an ice cream flavor and was flat-out denied. The woman at the counter said no and refused to speak to me—but then offered a sample to my sister. The way she handled it felt intentionally disrespectful and discriminatory.

We told them the service had been awful and that we’d be leaving a review. As we were leaving, both employees ran out of the store after us, shouting obscenities, including racist remarks. One of them even said “Thank you, come again” in a mocking Indian accent. They also said they wanted to fight us, which was completely unprovoked.

This experience was not only rude—it was threatening and deeply inappropriate. No customer should ever be treated this way. I hope management takes this seriously and addresses the behavior of the staff working that day.

Jason Rybka

The cookies are outrageously good. The staff is fast, efficient, and friendly. The store is clean and pleasing to the eye. Will be visiting again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Raisin, Chocolate Chip, Peanut Butter Chip, Cookies

Nicholas Bartlett

I went for the 1 dollar 2 cookie deal and the employees were disorganized and really rude. I went in and told one employee my name and she said it wasn’t there - I showed her my app and she said to wait and took a few other customers on the register - no big deal. Then, the other employee comes out and asks if anyone has pickup orders and since the other employee told me to wait I didn’t say anything. Finally, the first employee told the second employee to check and she found my order. She then hassled me saying “I already asked for pickup orders”. Just really rude after I was already waiting due to the first employees lack of organization

Service: 1

hatter

bad service

Delilah H

Best cookies I've ever had. Wayyy better than Crumble!!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Chip, Cookies

Chris Benz

Warmed up 711 cookies for 4x the price. Bad atmosphere n rude counter person

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Arianna Perez

The lady gave us bad service, giving us attitude the whole time. If she doesn’t like the job then don’t work there?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Cookies

Leafthrower 96

Came in to order a Gluten free cookie. When I come in near closing, I occasionally get blessed with some extra cookies because the GF ones aren't sold as often.

Coming in 20 minutes before close, I ordered a single GF cookie and received one--i wish i could have gotten more, but no big deal

That was, until my friend ordered a single peanut butter cookie and got an entire box of multiple cookie flavors--for the price of one

I'm not against people getting extra cookies, but the blatant favoritism was disappointing

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 2

Ganesh Kumar Jothi Kumar

We’ve found our new favorite spot for ice cream and desserts! Tried their s’mores cookie with Caramellionaire, and it was amazing. Perfectly sweet and gooey – just what we were craving. Can’t wait to go back and try more treats!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Salted Caramel, Cookies

LyAsia H

Cookies Were basically raw . Needed to be cooked a lil while longer . Area was Clean smelt great . But them cookies not a cup of tea . Please Cook the cookies longer at least a good 30 mins .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 2

Loading...