Pizza Mia

40 Jersey Ave, New Brunswick
(732) 640-1786

Recent Reviews

Alexia Wargacki

Who knew we would be this ripped off. We ordered from PIZZA MIA, not “Mozzarella” we paid $28 with tip for a wrong pizza and a 2 liter of sprite. We ordered a PLAIN cheese medium pie over the phone and we got a pepperoni medium pie. We had called back to ask why it was so expensive when the menu (that the delivery diver just handed us) said 10.95 and that we got the wrong pie and the lady was very nasty over the phone telling us we were wrong and that the price had gone up. The pizza was lukewarm when it arrived. We are not happy and will never be going back. I’m just very disappointed to pay almost $30 for something that bad

Mike Jones

Tried to place a order for delivery to this place I live 8 minutes away I gave the guy my address he told me I would have to tip the driver 10 dollars for that far of a trip

Case Hinton

This restaurant is my first choice site. Of all restaurants I know I favor it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to that place. Whenever I want to go to a special supper, this restaurant comes straightaway to my head. best and food and a large list of dishes.trained crew, and great mood. Not less important, the price is fair. I suggest this spot with great pleasure.

Jess D.

It's all about the tacos this time !! Omg these tacos were delicious I had the carne Asada and the pork tacos. Meat was perfectly cooked and flavorful. They also have salsa verde and red sauce to top it off if you like. 3 tacos come with each order and I don't think you will want to share . They also serve up jugs of mango, pineapple and horchata drinks . Who would have thought a mexican/italian restaurant would be turning out some delicious street eats . So good I will definitely be back .

Casey S.

This place was a flavorful surprise. From beginning to the end everything was delicious. This restaurant does both Italian and Mexican food right. It refreshing to see that a restaurant is not taking shortcuts during this pandemic you can tell everything is freshly made. Their lobster ravioli has lobster inside and on top of the ravioli. Their fried calamari was perfectly cooked and most importantly it wasn't over battered. The staff were welcoming and patient. This is a hidden gem and will be a weekly spot. Dont let the area deter you from stopping and trying their dishes you will not be disappointed.

Gavin Johnston

Pizza, so great. one of the best spots of its kind in the area. looking forward to returning with my coworkers. this place has a good atmosphere. i can see why they have so many great reviews.

Google User

It must be under new ownership because when I ate here Back 2012 I never had a badly pizza like that. Living in Jersey. I was shocked at how bad it was both times I was done and it was expensive too and very slow . I guess it finally went under real ownership management! It sure shows!

Noé G.

The place is nice but the people who work there they not know what to do, I order something and I came back because they got confused they changed it and it was the same for me it is bad the service will not come back. El lugar está bonito pero las personas que trabajan ahí no saben lo qué hacen ordene algo y regrese porque se confundieron me lo cambiaron y me salió lo mismo para mi es pésimo el servicio ya no regresaré

Joseline R.

Amazing lasagna great pasta came with chicken noodle soup tasting amazing and some great tasting rolls best I had so far from an Italian pizza spot .. everything was about 30$ yummyyyy

Cyndi F.

If I didn't have to hit 1 star, I wouldn't have. Ordering through Yelp should be a convenience especially when your Mother is in RWJ hospital. Little did I know, this would cause me to pay twice because the workers do not know how to use the system. Now I have to fight with my bank, and the restaurant. Extremely infuriating!!!

Tom Connelly

Hit or miss. Pizza is decent when its cooked right, and when it's made when you order. Once my pie was clearly forgotten about and made after I showed up. Which they lied about. Another time my pizza was completely raw in the center.

David S

They're so rude

Angie S.

This is among the worst (bottom two) pizza I've ever had. I ordered a small pizza with an assortment of vegetable toppings. What arrived I can only describe as a cheese pizza salad. The cheese was clearly cooked with the pizza but the vegetables were clearly added afterward so they were uncooked. Additionally there was little flavor where do you get those mild flavored onions from? You don't use garlic to season your crust? What a let down. Never again! So bad. And what is with that cheese? I could've been chewing plastic with the flavor profiles I was getting from this experience. ADDITIONALLY the cost was completely unreasonable for the product delivered. Fuk that nasty pizza I'm still mad about that!

Vilas Urtekar

They make the pizza just the way you like it.

Cora Griffin

pizza here - very tasty. Good place to catch up with friends. I look forward to going back again. Prices are appropriate. Feeling here is similar to a cafe in San Jose I liked.

Load More