BorderLine Bagel & Deli

440 Madison Ave., New Milford
(201) 599-1990

Recent Reviews

sandy lee

Bagels are daily baked fresh and perfect for breakfast & their deli lunch sandwiches are also very good ? this one is turkey, swiss, lettuce, tomato on lightly toasted whole wheat.

Ken Mamary

Terrible food,expensive. Not worth going there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

jenn kenn

I have not had a proper bagel since moving to the left coast. i received a dozen bagels when a friend came for a visit. BorderLine are still the best bagels in the country!

Food: 5

Janahi M.

The bagel was delicious and Very good service the boy in the front with the glasses was very helpful

richard kurack

Great bagels. Great service.Ephraim, Carlos are the best!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Scott Schlesinger

The young lady is the only issue here. She does not always get the order correct. Everything else is great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

John Norman

Check your order before you leave. Somewhat overpriced.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

F N.

They must be under new mgmt. Our last 4 orders were wrong every time, even though the receipt had correct info. For example; Veggie cream cheese on a sesame bagel became melted butter on an everything bagel. This isn't good for people with food allergies or restrictions. There is definitely a communication problem, speaking and reading. We gave it 4 tries before writing this review. This was our go-to place, but I'm afraid I can no longer recommend Borderline Bagel.

Maria Stafford

Bagel is dry hard and expensive

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Krystal L.

I've ordered here multiple times & I've always been satisfied with my bacon egg and cheese on a bagel. So far the best breakfast sandwiches in the town/area. A bacon egg and cheese sounds simple but it's rare to find all of its components cooked well. The breakfast potatoes are good as well, soft and flavorful. The employees are kind. The shop itself is small and comes with a nice vibe.

nancy metsch

This happen during Yom Kippour.My husband and I went to get bagels and spreads for breaking the fast and we were both very disappoinOur entire order was wrong.I'm not even talking about prices I'm talking about stupid.After our ordered was placed my husband was watching the guy put our orderer together.He kept getting the bagels wrong.THEN. After repeating how much spreads we wanted the man got that wrong too.We used to go here all the time. But you have lost a coustmer

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Zoe Florio

great food but i had it delivered and they left my food on the side of the road?? when i ordered face to face and the coffee didn’t specify what had what which is annoying when you order for a mass amount of ppl like i do. great place i just wouldn’t order for delivery!

Kevin Mangam

Have great bagels. That being said order has been wrong a few times and today by 11 completely sold out of everything bagels or any other bagel I would have wanted. If you have bagels in the name of the business how can you run out 4 hours before you close?

Josh

I've been going for years, but never again. Why would they give the bagels I ordered to the person who ordered after me. Also wrong order even though I gave it 3 times and tried to charge 35 dollars for 4 bagels with either butter or cream cheese. When I said that's a bit high, someone else rung me up for 10 dollars cheaper. They have gone downhill and I will never return.

Seungchan Kim

Fresh bagel all the time, I love their coffee.

Load More