Celestino's Pizza & Restaurant (New Providence)
Customers' Favorites
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Penne Vodka
Garlic Knots
Meatballs
Grandma
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Got a Plain slice and Chicken Parm sub. They had so much variety for slices which I like. The slice is a good size but was overheated by staff burning my mouth. (Even after waiting). The chicken parm was amazing. Fully loaded up with fresh chicken cutlets and cheese on a soft toasty roll.
Stopped in with my kids for a slice… Best slice of pizza I’ve had in years! The kids agreed! I’ll drive the 20 min away to get pizza from here from now on.
Entirely shocked. Was visiting and a friend took me for dinner. I don’t frequently leave reviews but when the pizza is this good (try the Hot Honey Roni), and the atmosphere that on point, I feel the need to let others know.
10/10 from a harsh food critic. Staff was wonderful too!
10/10 from a harsh food critic. Staff was wonderful too!