Nasto's Ice Cream Co. — Old World Desserts
236 Jefferson St, Newark
(973) 589-3333
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Great Ice cream
The best ice cream!!!!! My favorite is strawberry, they have the best I have ever tried! The ice cream cake is soooo good! Has a layer of vanilla, chocolate and strawberry and in the middle is a nutty chocolate syrup! Yum! A must try!
great portions great price would come again
They’ve got the best milkshakes ever. Also shout out to the girls at the counter who are always super nice.
The best ice cream 🍦
Pretty good
Nasto’s is a great place to get ice cream of many flavors. In the summer they have lemon ice with lemon peel bits. My favorite is pistachio ice cream. They have ice cream cakes and logs at reasonable prices. There are sidewalk tables. I brought some friends from New York who were happy for our visit and loved their ice cream.
They once provided me with first aid in the form of plain ice after a hit and run accident from a pickup truck a block away.
I always try to get there!!
Nasto’s is a legend, a beacon of light, an anchor in any storm. The ice creams—in a very of Italian and Latin flavors—stun, but I can never resist a reginetta or a tartufo. Each is a handsome meal, or at least a hearty snack. It’s been going since 1939, and I hope it goes forever.
Wow! Blown away by the cappuccino ice cream. Delicious - will definitely come back! Staff was wonderful, and plenty of seating outside.
Great ice cream must try
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream in New Jersey. I recommend, you won’t regret
Amazing ice cream 🍨
Friendly and helpful staff. Perfect ice cream cakes every time, from writing and design to flavor and consistency. Shakes and regular ice cream are excellent as well.
Excellent!
This is a landmark it’s always the Best !
😊love it
The best ice cream you can buy. It is creamy, not too sweet and flavorful. Even the sorbets taste super fresh and not too sweet. Don’t let the street parking situation deter you. We have been going here for over 30 years.
Photo is a double scoop on a waffle cone.
Loading...