Nasto's Ice Cream Co. — Old World Desserts

236 Jefferson St, Newark
(973) 589-3333

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel and Sweet Corn Lemon Ice
Coffee and Banana Ice Cream Waffle Bowl
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Mango Pineapple Ice Cream
Small Ice Cream Sandwich
Chocolate Chocolate Chip
Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Cookie Dough with M&ms
1 2 Gallon Ice Cream
Strawberry Ice Cream

Menu

Mains
Tortoni ( Box of 12 cups )
Special Tartufo (Box of 4)
Pistacho, Peanut Butter, White Chocolate Raspberry and Assorted. Type your flavor(s) in the special instructions box at the bottom.
Regular Tartufo (Box of 4)
Traditional Vanilla and Chocolate with a cherry in the middle. (Contains nuts)
Tiramisu Tray
Cake Roll
Half-Gallon Ice Cream
Vanilla, Chocolate,Strawberry, Cookie dough, Cookies & Cream, Mint Chocolate Chip, Pistacho, Cake Batter, Mudslide, Dulce de Leche, Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel, Vanilla Chocolate Chip, Rocky Road, Vanilla Peanut Butter, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Cherry Vanilla, Butter Pecan, Cookie Monster, Coffee, Hazelnut, Banana, Sweet Corn, Black Raspberry, Mango, Coconut, and Pineapple. Type your flavor(s) in the special instructions box all the way at the bottom.
Medium Cup ( 2 flavors )
Vanilla, Chocolate,Strawberry, Cookie dough, Cookies & Cream, Mint Chocolate Chip, Pistacho, Cake Batter, Mudslide, Dulce de Leche, Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel, Vanilla Chocolate Chip, Rocky Road, Vanilla Peanut Butter, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Cherry Vanilla, Butter Pecan, Cookie Monster, Banana, Sweet Corn, Black Raspberry, Mango, Coconut, and Pineapple. Type your flavor in the special instructions box at the bottom.
Small Cup ( 2 flavors )
Vanilla, Chocolate,Strawberry, Cookie dough, Cookies & Cream, Mint Chocolate Chip, Pistacho, Cake Batter, Mudslide, Dulce de Leche, Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel, Vanilla Chocolate Chip, Rocky Road, Vanilla Peanut Butter, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Cherry Vanilla, Butter Pecan, Cookie Monster, Banana, Sweet Corn, Black Raspberry, Mango, Coconut, and Pineapple. Type your flavor in the special instructions box at the bottom.
Pint Gelato ( 1 flavor per pint )
Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Chocolate Hazelnut, Hazelnut, Cappuccino, Banana Nutella, Toasted Almond, Pistacho, Dulce de Leche, Mint Chocolate Chip, Lemon & Raspberry Sorbet. Type your flavor(s) in the special instructions box at the bottom.
Milkshake
Vanilla, Chocolate,Strawberry, Cookie dough, Cookies & Cream, Mint Chocolate Chip, Pistacho, Cake Batter, Mudslide, Dulce de Leche, Sea Salt Caramel Pretzel, Vanilla Chocolate Chip, Rocky Road, Vanilla Peanut Butter, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Cherry Vanilla, Butter Pecan, Mallomar, Cookie Monster, Banana, Sweet Corn, Black Raspberry, Mango, Coconut, and Pineapple. Type your flavor in the special instructions box at the bottom.
Tres Leches Tray
Lava Cake
Nutlog
Large Plain Cannoli
Spumoni ( 8 Slices per box )
Large Chocolate Cannoli
Brownie
Tiramisu Cup
Mini Chocolate Cannoli
Toasted Almond Tray
Mini Plain Cannoli
Toasted Almond Cup

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+48 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+47 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I drove all the way from nyc to try this icecream. Its cute inside. I cant believe its open 86 years. Historical and iconic. The watermelon ice was the best I've ever had. Memorable. The peach icecream had real peaches in it. Fantastic. I tried so many flavors. All amazing. I had the tartufo. It blew my mind. The chocolate was elegance in the mouth. Id drive over the bridge and back into the congestion zone for that any day. Greatest staff. I need to try a cake next time.
July 2025
REALLY GOOD. I don’t normally like fruits in my ice cream but got the vanilla cherry. Was amazing. Also brought the rum raisin for my mom. She said it’s the best she’s ever had and i ate some chocolate gelato which was very good as well.
July 2025
Have been going since I was a kid. N it's still 1 of the best ice cream places I've been to.

Vegetarian options: I had a seasonal option. Sweet corn & pumpkin ice cream!

Parking: They have cakes & ice cream for takeout
November 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Casa Seabra - 255 Jefferson St
Portuguese
No Pão at Café Caffé- Chestnut Street - 274 Chestnut St
Cafe
Casa d'Paco - 73 Warwick St
Spanish, Tapas Bar, Wine Bar, Vegan, Vegetarian

Nasto's Ice Cream Co. — Old World Desserts

236 Jefferson St, Newark, NJ 07105
(973) 589-3333