Roy's Fish Fry

231 Lyons Ave, Newark
(973) 399-1266

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Bruno Concepcion

Pretty good meal for what u spend always a definite

Food: 4

Service: 4

Kimberly Baez

Food was okay service was awful! Sweet potato pie is not their specialty. Needs a lesson in customer service.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Shaquanda Johnson

I ordered two pieces of carrot cake and it had mold on it I will never eat from there again

Food: 1

Liya Sonali

Went on my lunch break to try them for the first time. And got the 2pc whiting fish lunch special. For startes the rice was horrible the cabbage was okay. This fish smelled and tasted like ammonia thats how I knew the fish was bad cause fresh fish doesnt taste or smell like that..would say I want to try them again but its a no for me...couldn't even finish my food ..what a waste

Food: 1

Tracy Bracewell

The cat fish sandwiches are to die for, however; the cat fish nuggets are even better...
It does not matter when you order them they are ALWAYS fresh!
The other food items are just as delicious...
The young man who cooks the food is mannererable, humbled, and kind. The young lady who takes the food orders are patient, kind, and humbled.
The atmosphere is less than desirable, but the food is definitely chefs' kiss!
Go and you will not be disappointed 💚

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ty Phipps

I love close to the south orange ave location but I rather drive alil further for good food. I should have took a Pic 📸 of Lyons ave mac & cheese 🧀 it was delicious ITS GONE I forgot to take a photo 📸 ps. I'm also a chef at a close by carribean restaurant so Lyons ave keep up the great work 👍🏾

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

A.C. Johnson

So I shldv snapped a pic of their famous catfish nuggets, but...I ate them too fast 😳
I've returned multiple times and am happy to say you will not regret going for the aforementioned item nor their other fried items and potato salad. Unlike a few items, the seafood combos are decently priced. This must be why I've returned. Oh and did i mention the service was good each time.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Hollywood Pud (Hollywood)

Besides from the beggars in the overpricing of the fish this would be a good place fools tasty but very expensive

Kid-friendliness: No

Wheelchair accessibility: No

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Porgies Sandwich 2 pcs

Alneesha Wicks

The cashier isn't too friendly, they don't cut their greens as small as I would prefer and they do not serve cornbread with their soul food dishes.

Mark Artis

The staff was friendly and courteous. The food was great and when I had went home an saw I was missing an item they gave no fuss about it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jo Caraway

Something is off about the food here. Not a fan of the Mac and cheese from this location. It seems to be spoiled cheese used for my dish.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 5

Hakeemah Neal

Worse service EVER! Female that was taking orders wouldn't even get up out her seat to take my order and didn't even greet me as a customer spending my money on a overpriced fish sandwich. I ordered 2 fish sandwich that cost 28 dollars smh you'll think they would be more professional and greet their customers with respect.

Roxy Merceda

Friendly staff, always stocked up on all options. If they dont have it cooked up, they will cook it just for you.☺️I just discovered this place and they are more than a fish frying place. They have Caribbean food options as well, and it is good! Some may think it is pricey, but for the amount of food you receive, your plates will be more than the money you pay! It's worth every penny!

Parking: Near hospital and this is a store front restaurant. So take out is the best option. This place gets super crowded, so call in your order before you get there. Makes life easier. It's not the restaurant's fault the parking is trash! Use the hospital lot.

Kid-friendliness: Not sure, store front

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Potato Salad, Half Macaroni Cheese, Candy Yams, Catfish Sandwich 4 pcs, Catfish Nuggets, Catfish 4 pcs, String Beans, Stew Chicken, Hot Wings 5 pcs, BBQ Wings

Cyndi Wilson

Had the 8 piece fried fish..delicious! Came with tartar sauce and hot sauce but no bread. However, I asked for extra crispy fries, and they were on the money!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jamillah Smith-Zeigler

THIS IS THE LAST ON MY LIST OF WHERE TO GO AND

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Loading...