Great local tavern. Having a bad day? Grab a beer at the local tavern. Your girlfriend dumped you? Have a beer and some wings at the local tavern. Got fired from your job? Grab a beer and a bar pizza from the local tavern. In the grand scheme of things, the local tavern is the place to be. Priceless memories and even better prices at your local tavern.
Miche
What a beautiful little restaurant on the lake. such nice service. Food was hot and fresh and flavorful. We saw everyone enjoying a tater tot appetizer and we couldn't resist it!! I would definitely wanna come back I really love this little gem
laurenced136
Take a table outside. Nice views on the lake. Fast and friendly service. Good food. Big portions. Recommend the meatloaf. Delicious.
Chris_NJ_1
Went on the suggestion of our B+B host. Lunch was delicious. Partner had the Red Snapper, I had the corned beef really tender. The Chicken noodle soup was excellent. Loved the lake view. If we are in the area again we will go back,
Lynn D.
Very tasty dinners there tonight, pleasant staff and very efficient ! Would def. Go back !
Tim W.
Fajitas were good. Nachoes as well. Decent portion size. Waitstaff was friendly and helpful. (Early on a Saturday, was ao.ewhat quiet). Would go again.
Jocelyn R.
Sheridan's has been a family favorite for a quick bite to eat! I'm personally a huge fan of the mexican chicken salad :) Waiting time for food is between average and pretty quick. Though I can't sit at the bar, Sheridan's is definitely packed at the bar! Staff is super kind and helpful. Be sure to tip the waiters/waitresses!!
John D.
Loyal customer for years, I had people coming out for a get together from out of State 14 to be Exact made Reservations almost a month ahead of time days before our get together I Received a call from the owner days before to tell me they could not Accommodate us in the Restaurant area but could put us at the bar, thanks Bob you just lost a loyal customer
William M.
We had been away for a couple of months. And last week decided, let's go to Sheridan for dinner. We ordered the shrimp pizza and the Jersey burger. I love pizza and was at first skeptical that my wife's selection would be good. It was beyond good, it was great, and delicious and we will definitely order it again. Just the right combination of ricotta cheese, plenty of shrimp, and spinach on a delicious perfect crust. I had the Jersey burger with sweet potato fries. It's been a very long time since I enjoyed a burger this much. Start with the roll, they thankfully do not go cheap here....fresh, substantial and up to the task. The burger was medium well, just right, and Taylor ham and egg on top. Indescribably delicious! It tastes 10 times better than I described it. Service was excellent. Will return next week for repeat performance!
Steve Kuzmiak
Quite simply, a nice place to enjoy a meal at a reasonable price over a few drinks.
A small restaurant in a small town, kind of explains itself. This place has some good dishes and many not so good. I'd recommend sticking to easily made meals, sandwiches, fried dishes, salads. It's mostly all just mediocre at best. I've been here on a few separate occasions and I've had very consistent service. The food comes out quickly, the waitresses and waiters are pleasant, and the beer is CHEAP. $4-$5 for a beer? Boston could never. The restaurant has a nice overlook onto a pond during the warmer months, but there's nothing here to make me go out of my way. The only reason I come back is because I'm invited out by family. I don't recommend any steak dishes, the quality is very poor. Food: 2/5 Quality: 2/5 Quantity: 5/5 Service: 4/5 Overall: 3/5
Brielle G.
The only positive comment to say was that the appetizer Parmesan calamari was absolutely delicious. Along with the portion size is on the larger side. Waited over an hour for our soups. And then an hour and half for our entrées (Mac and cheese and meatloaf). The meatloaf was not my favorite- it was listed as a house favorite ... 1/10. The Mac and cheese was also on the bland side; "just ok". Would we ever come again? Only for the bar, if that. This is more for the elderly crowd.
Tmaher1
Requested a Smokey Mountain - why is it smokey? Because it includes smoked cheddar cheese.. Well, I guess they didn't have smoked cheddar cheese, or any cheese because I got none. Double check with these knuckleheads before finalizing your order and then double-check it upon receiving it. You've been warned.
Patti Schultz
Fitst time there. The service was awesome in spite of being short staffed. Very efficient and friendly.
John I.
I love this place, it was a great little find years ago, and holds special memories. Great views, giant bar, good food, drinks and music, what else do you need?
Great local tavern. Having a bad day? Grab a beer at the local tavern. Your girlfriend dumped you? Have a beer and some wings at the local tavern. Got fired from your job? Grab a beer and a bar pizza from the local tavern. In the grand scheme of things, the local tavern is the place to be. Priceless memories and even better prices at your local tavern.
What a beautiful little restaurant on the lake. such nice service. Food was hot and fresh and flavorful. We saw everyone enjoying a tater tot appetizer and we couldn't resist it!! I would definitely wanna come back I really love this little gem
Take a table outside. Nice views on the lake. Fast and friendly service. Good food. Big portions. Recommend the meatloaf. Delicious.
Went on the suggestion of our B+B host. Lunch was delicious. Partner had the Red Snapper, I had the corned beef really tender. The Chicken noodle soup was excellent. Loved the lake view. If we are in the area again we will go back,
Very tasty dinners there tonight, pleasant staff and very efficient ! Would def. Go back !
Fajitas were good. Nachoes as well. Decent portion size. Waitstaff was friendly and helpful. (Early on a Saturday, was ao.ewhat quiet). Would go again.
Sheridan's has been a family favorite for a quick bite to eat! I'm personally a huge fan of the mexican chicken salad :) Waiting time for food is between average and pretty quick. Though I can't sit at the bar, Sheridan's is definitely packed at the bar! Staff is super kind and helpful. Be sure to tip the waiters/waitresses!!
Loyal customer for years, I had people coming out for a get together from out of State 14 to be Exact made Reservations almost a month ahead of time days before our get together I Received a call from the owner days before to tell me they could not Accommodate us in the Restaurant area but could put us at the bar, thanks Bob you just lost a loyal customer
We had been away for a couple of months. And last week decided, let's go to Sheridan for dinner. We ordered the shrimp pizza and the Jersey burger. I love pizza and was at first skeptical that my wife's selection would be good. It was beyond good, it was great, and delicious and we will definitely order it again. Just the right combination of ricotta cheese, plenty of shrimp, and spinach on a delicious perfect crust. I had the Jersey burger with sweet potato fries. It's been a very long time since I enjoyed a burger this much. Start with the roll, they thankfully do not go cheap here....fresh, substantial and up to the task. The burger was medium well, just right, and Taylor ham and egg on top. Indescribably delicious! It tastes 10 times better than I described it. Service was excellent. Will return next week for repeat performance!
Quite simply, a nice place to enjoy a meal at a reasonable price over a few drinks.
Restaurantji Recommends
A small restaurant in a small town, kind of explains itself. This place has some good dishes and many not so good. I'd recommend sticking to easily made meals, sandwiches, fried dishes, salads. It's mostly all just mediocre at best. I've been here on a few separate occasions and I've had very consistent service. The food comes out quickly, the waitresses and waiters are pleasant, and the beer is CHEAP. $4-$5 for a beer? Boston could never. The restaurant has a nice overlook onto a pond during the warmer months, but there's nothing here to make me go out of my way. The only reason I come back is because I'm invited out by family. I don't recommend any steak dishes, the quality is very poor. Food: 2/5 Quality: 2/5 Quantity: 5/5 Service: 4/5 Overall: 3/5
The only positive comment to say was that the appetizer Parmesan calamari was absolutely delicious. Along with the portion size is on the larger side. Waited over an hour for our soups. And then an hour and half for our entrées (Mac and cheese and meatloaf). The meatloaf was not my favorite- it was listed as a house favorite ... 1/10. The Mac and cheese was also on the bland side; "just ok". Would we ever come again? Only for the bar, if that. This is more for the elderly crowd.
Requested a Smokey Mountain - why is it smokey? Because it includes smoked cheddar cheese.. Well, I guess they didn't have smoked cheddar cheese, or any cheese because I got none. Double check with these knuckleheads before finalizing your order and then double-check it upon receiving it. You've been warned.
Fitst time there. The service was awesome in spite of being short staffed. Very efficient and friendly.
I love this place, it was a great little find years ago, and holds special memories. Great views, giant bar, good food, drinks and music, what else do you need?