Schuyler Bagels

Order Online Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese

Egg White Veggie Platter

Bacon Egg and Cheese

French Toast Bagel

Dozen Bagels

Egg Salad

Hot Pastrami Bagel or Roll $9.55
Philly Cheesesteak Sandwich (Hero Subs) $11.55
Cuban Sandwich Hero $11.55
Cheeseburger $8.80
Chicken Cuttle Bagel or Roll $9.45
Hot Grilled Pastrami Hero $11.70
Chicken Parm Sandwich Hero $11.55
Chicken Cutlet Sandwich Hero $11.55
BBQ Pork Rib Meat Sandwich Hero $11.55
Fish Filet Sandwich Hero $12.80
Grilled Chicken Sandwich Hero $11.55
Chicken Parm Bagel or Roll $9.45
Fish Fillet Bagel or Roll $9.45
Grill Chicken Bagel or Roll $9.45
BBQ Pork Rib Bagel or Roll $9.45

Panini Sandwiches

Grilled Chicken Panini Sandwich $11.80
Special Grilled Chicken Panini $11.80
Hot Roast Beef Panini Sandwich $11.80
Chicken Cutlet Cordon Bleu Panini Sandwich $11.80
Reuben Panini Sandwich $11.80
Vegetarian Panini Sandwich $10.00

Specialty Items

French Fries $5.20
Chicken Nuggets $5.20
Mozzarella Sticks $5.20
Onions Rings $5.20

Dell Sandwiches

Egg Salad Sandwich Bagel or Roll $7.90
Liverwurst Sandwich $8.35
Pastrami and Cheese Bagel or Roll $10.75
Turkey Hero Sandwich $11.45
Tuna Salad Sandwich Bagel or Roll $9.80
Nova Scotia Lox Sandwich $13.10
Tuna Salad Hero Sandwich $11.70
Liverwurst and Cheese Sandwich $9.10
Liverwurst Hero Sandwich $9.80
Ham Sandwich $9.45
Ham and Cheese Bagel or Roll $10.25
Ham Sandwich Sub $11.45
Turkey Sandwich $9.45
Turkey and Cheese Bagel or Roll $5.95
Pastrami Sandwich $10.00
Pastrami Hero Sandwich $11.80
Roasted Beef Sandwich $10.25
Roasted Beef and Cheese Bagel or Roll $10.25
Roasted Beef Hero Sandwich $11.45
Salami Sandwich $9.10
Salami and Cheese Bagel or Roll $9.90
Salami Hero Sandwich $11.00
Bologna Sandwich $8.35
Bologna and Cheese Bagel or Roll $9.10
Bologna Hero Sandwich $9.80
Chicken Salad Sandwich Bagel or Roll $9.70
Chicken Salad Hero Sandwich $11.55
Cheese Sandwich Bagel or Roll $5.50
Cheese Hero Sandwich $7.25
Egg Salad Hero Sandwich $9.15

Wrap Sandwich

Chicken Caesar Wrap $11.55
Mediterranean Wrap Sandwich $11.55
Chicken Cordon Bleu Wrap Sandwich (Hero Subs) $11.55
Antipasto Wrap Sandwich (Hero Subs) $11.55
Vegetarian Wrap Sandwich $10.00
Tuna Wrap $11.55
Philly Monterey Steak Wrap $11.55
Gyro Wrap $10.50

Breakfast Sandwich

Taylor, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich $8.00
Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich $8.00
Side Order of Hash Browns (2 pcs) $3.70
Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich $8.00
Ham, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich $9.25
Special Burrito $11.80
Taylor and Egg Sandwich $7.50
Turkey, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich $9.25
Taylor Sandwich $5.52
Egg Whites Veggie Omelet Wrap $7.70
Turkey Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich $9.25
Side Order of Home Fries $5.20
Egg & Cheese Sandwich $5.40
Sausage and Egg Sandwich $7.50
Egg White Veggie Omelet Sandwich $7.70
Egg Sandwich $4.70
Taylor and Cheese Sandwich $7.50
Sausage Sandwich $6.50
Sausage and Cheese Sandwich $7.50
Bacon Sandwich $6.50
Bacon and Egg Sandwich $7.50
Bacon Cheese Sandwich $7.50
Turkey Bacon Sandwich $6.90
Turkey Sausage Sandwich $6.90
Turkey Sausage and Egg Sandwich $8.50
Turkey Sausage and Cheese Sandwich $8.50
Turkey Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Sandwich $9.25
Ham and Egg Sandwich $8.50
Ham and Cheese Sandwich $8.50
Turkey and Egg Sandwich $8.50
Turkey and Cheese Sandwich $8.50
Western Omelet Sandwich $10.08

Sweets

Croissant (Plain) $2.95
French Toast Bagel $2.60
Asiago Cheese Bagel $2.60
Muffin (Yogurt) $3.30
Apple Turnover $2.95
Muffin with Butter (Toasted) $3.80
Crumb Cake $3.80
Brownie $3.90

Photos

+24 photos

+23 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Ubereats

Doordash

Recent Reviews

Just placed an order on the phone, gave us a number, did not take our name. When we got home the order was wrong. We ordered 3 sandwiches not 2 sandwiches. We had to go all the way back to get our order because they issued two of the same order numbers. I feel they should not have charged us for the additional sandwich for all our troubles. They did though, will rethink our choices next time. I think there are different owners as well.

January 2026

Clean, fast, terrific selection. Easy in and out parking. Had good old egg and sausage on a roll = best I’ve ever had. Great coffee, offered 1/2 and 1/2 self serve. No waiting in line. Make it while they make your sandwich. If I commuted this would be my every morning spot.

December 2025

I live 2 towns away from here and pass 7-8 bagel shops on my immediate route there . I never stop at any of them anymore since I found this place . This is a real sandwhich unlike the rest of these places make

March 2025

More Reviews