Family owned and ran! Best subs and chicken cutlets. Pizza is good too and they have San Benedetto ice tea which is hard to come by these day. When I’m in town I always stop here for lunch :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin Boyan
An old school authentic Italian deli run by mom, dad, and their son. The food is outstanding, I had an Italian Combo and my wife had a turkey sub, there was no skimping on the ingredients, WOW! As for the pizza ? we traveled here from Cape Cod in search of the best pizza from Rockland County NY through Bergen County NJ. We eventually landed here at Petrillos and met John and his parents working behind the counter. An old school hard-working family making traditional pizzas. We were blown away by what they had created, a super tasty combination of classic sauce and the perfect amount of cheese on a slightly crispy underbody with a soft but crisp crust. We ordered 13 pizzas that day, 10 plain,1 green pepper & onion, and 2 chicken cutlet and cherry pepper. After trying the Chicken cutlet and cherry pepper I called the next morning and ordered 3 more...wow it was awesome. Upon picking up the pizzas Sunday morning we discovered John making breakfast on the flat-top grill so my wife ordered French toast and bacon, yum! We gave this establishment a 5-star review but on a scale of 1-10 we gave our highest review 9.8 only because there has to be room for something higher, we just haven't found it yet. Keep up the good work, this will always be a stop on our road trips from the Cape. You are officially part of our food world family, La Famiglia. Thank you, from Kevin & Melanie
James P.
Prices on the website was not up to date when I picked up the food to go. So just be aware.
Jenny Y.
What a great local deli! I got the Italian sandwich and it came packed with meat. There was a great balance between the meat and veggies as well. Would highly recommend if you're craving an authentic Italian sandwich.
Tom Z.
We have been coming to Petrillo's for many years. John and his mom and dad do a great job. They make the best sandwich in the area.
Penny Zack
Love everything I get from here. Their daily hot specials are always delicious. And everyone is so sweet, willing to help.
Evan K.
First time coming here had an order of two stuffed peppers got two meals out if it. Will return nice family working here, please support the har working family, great food and nice business
Michael C
Can't go wrong here!! Everything I've eaten at Petrillo's has been delicious!!
Donnie Niccoll
Real Italian deli serving good quality food. Best part, they don't skimp on portions, something hard to find nowadays. People behind the counter are good hearted people who clearly take pride in their cooking. 10/10.
Called in catering order, easy reasonable and delish!
John D.
Excellent Italian deli. Stuffed sandwiches. Very good pizza. My favorite. Very good lunch or dinner dishes. Staff is excellent at getting your order quickly and accurately. My favorite deli.
Greg Gmax3
Has been the best place to eat for more than 28 years for me.
Emma P.
We had an Italian sub and macaroni and potato salad which was delicious!! We met John, very nice and attentive.
Go B.
Neighborhood institution. A family operation run by dad, mom and their son.Used to order from here often when we lived nearby. Nice to come back. It's definitely worth the hour drive to check out the old neighborhood, especially Petrillo's.One of our favorite deli in NJ, along with Fiori in Hoboken. Food is wonderful, but twice the portion compared to other places and with very reasonable prices. Check out their daily specials, especially their meat loaf, hot turkey, pepper steak, ribs, stuffed peppers, pasta, etc. They also make wonderful pizza with their sicilian being our favorite.Wonderful service.Highest recommendations.: 10 herosNote: This place gets very busy, especially during weekday lunch, so best to call and place your order.
Great quick sandwiches.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Family owned and ran! Best subs and chicken cutlets. Pizza is good too and they have San Benedetto ice tea which is hard to come by these day. When I’m in town I always stop here for lunch :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
An old school authentic Italian deli run by mom, dad, and their son. The food is outstanding, I had an Italian Combo and my wife had a turkey sub, there was no skimping on the ingredients, WOW! As for the pizza ? we traveled here from Cape Cod in search of the best pizza from Rockland County NY through Bergen County NJ. We eventually landed here at Petrillos and met John and his parents working behind the counter. An old school hard-working family making traditional pizzas. We were blown away by what they had created, a super tasty combination of classic sauce and the perfect amount of cheese on a slightly crispy underbody with a soft but crisp crust. We ordered 13 pizzas that day, 10 plain,1 green pepper & onion, and 2 chicken cutlet and cherry pepper. After trying the Chicken cutlet and cherry pepper I called the next morning and ordered 3 more...wow it was awesome. Upon picking up the pizzas Sunday morning we discovered John making breakfast on the flat-top grill so my wife ordered French toast and bacon, yum! We gave this establishment a 5-star review but on a scale of 1-10 we gave our highest review 9.8 only because there has to be room for something higher, we just haven't found it yet. Keep up the good work, this will always be a stop on our road trips from the Cape. You are officially part of our food world family, La Famiglia. Thank you, from Kevin & Melanie
Prices on the website was not up to date when I picked up the food to go. So just be aware.
What a great local deli! I got the Italian sandwich and it came packed with meat. There was a great balance between the meat and veggies as well. Would highly recommend if you're craving an authentic Italian sandwich.
We have been coming to Petrillo's for many years. John and his mom and dad do a great job. They make the best sandwich in the area.
Love everything I get from here. Their daily hot specials are always delicious. And everyone is so sweet, willing to help.
First time coming here had an order of two stuffed peppers got two meals out if it. Will return nice family working here, please support the har working family, great food and nice business
Can't go wrong here!! Everything I've eaten at Petrillo's has been delicious!!
Real Italian deli serving good quality food. Best part, they don't skimp on portions, something hard to find nowadays. People behind the counter are good hearted people who clearly take pride in their cooking. 10/10.
Restaurantji Recommends
Called in catering order, easy reasonable and delish!
Excellent Italian deli. Stuffed sandwiches. Very good pizza. My favorite. Very good lunch or dinner dishes. Staff is excellent at getting your order quickly and accurately. My favorite deli.
Has been the best place to eat for more than 28 years for me.
We had an Italian sub and macaroni and potato salad which was delicious!! We met John, very nice and attentive.
Neighborhood institution. A family operation run by dad, mom and their son.Used to order from here often when we lived nearby. Nice to come back. It's definitely worth the hour drive to check out the old neighborhood, especially Petrillo's.One of our favorite deli in NJ, along with Fiori in Hoboken. Food is wonderful, but twice the portion compared to other places and with very reasonable prices. Check out their daily specials, especially their meat loaf, hot turkey, pepper steak, ribs, stuffed peppers, pasta, etc. They also make wonderful pizza with their sicilian being our favorite.Wonderful service.Highest recommendations.: 10 herosNote: This place gets very busy, especially during weekday lunch, so best to call and place your order.