Michael's Pastaria

143 Franklin Ave, Nutley
(973) 661-5252

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ndñgü Mingxië

If you think you've failed in forex trading, I'm glad to introduce you to the most amazing manager Mrs Ami Brenda in fact all hope was lost until I met this amazing manager who changed my life within one week. I invested just $500 and within 5 days I made $6700. My friends I will forever be grateful to Mrs Ami Brenda for helping me recovered all my losses. Words cannot explain or express how grateful I am. If you had lost a lot in forex trade give Mrs Ami Brenda a trial… you can reach her via Email: [email protected]

Opentable Diner

Restaurant was closed and reservations still open on OpenTable. Went all the way to door to find a sign

Gail Cirigliano Solleder

excellent food..great service

John Stofik Sr.

Charming place with great food and staff.

MARGIE NOTTE

Cozy and warm atmosphere. Delicious food. Unpretentious and fresh..Chicken pastina soup was comforting and delicious.

Bennett Smith

Unbelievable...food is great...people are great.. gonna put this one on the tippy top of my list.

Opentable Diner

We were so happy that Michael's re-opened after the pandemic! The two young men that waited on us were very pleasant and worked hard so that we could enjoy our meal. The thinny- thin pizza is still amazing. Thank you! You are back in our rotation of restaurants and we plan to see you very soon!

We were so happy that Michael's re-opened after the pandemic! The two young men that waited on us were very pleasant and worked hard so that we could enjoy our meal. The thinny- thin pizza is still amazing. Thank you! You are back in our rotation of restaurants and we plan to see you very soon!

Louis Perrone

Excellent pizza (GinaMarie) and Chicken Cacciatore was superb. Give it a try.

Griselle A.Alvarez

Excellent service by Julio our server. Good food. New owner. Check it out.

Leonardo Guzman

I had the Chicken Parm.. delicious. Very large piece of chicken. Also tried the Penne Vodka which was the best penn vodka I've ever had. The service has always been great. Im a big fan of Michael's. Pizza here always taste amazing.

Jean Stefanelli

Danielle thank you for the best meatballs ever, taste like my grandmother's & my moms old school recipe.You won't be disappointed delicious

marcos medina

Hands down BEST Italian restaurant in Nutley NJ, we love everything we had, meatballs are a must have! Excellent from service, appetizers to deserts.

Jean Smith

Thank you to Jerry, Danielle the wonderful staff & my nephew Tiny, for a great dining experience...The food was great, service excellent, and great desserts! I highly recommend Michaels...You won't be disappointed!

Annmarie Rodrigues

The best pizza around ! The staff is super friendly and the food is absolutely amazing! Highly recommended!!

Loading...