Nutley Bagel Boy

244A Franklin Ave, Nutley
(973) 542-8288

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Angel R

First time ordering delivery here. 15 mins away & the toasted sesame bagels were still warm on arrival. Fresh & delicious. Keep up the great work. Will definitely return. Place also looks clean in all the other reviews.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dennis McGhee

It's great here!! 😀

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Walter Gorman

Great bagels and friendly staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

susan Dean

Great bagels and fast service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steven Carroll (Stomper Boot)

Great bagel sandwiches close to school so watch out it could get crowded with young people. Otherwise Good Town bagel shop

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Reeve Cooper

I always have a great time and I’m obsessed with the French toast bagel 😭😭

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Lou Saga

Good luck getting your order right. They screwed up our orders so many times. Enough that I had to leave a poor review. Their service and response when you call to let them know about your wrong order, AGAIN, was also poor. Get it together, breakfast orders aren't rocket science.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jennifer Campbell

I stopped by for a quick breakfast after taking hot Pilates across the street — just a plain MINI bagel with scallion cream cheese and a regular iced coffee. The bagel was decent, nothing extraordinary, and the coffee was your standard brew. So imagine my surprise when the bill came out to over $10.

For that price, I expected something a bit more memorable — maybe freshly baked artisan bread or a specialty roast. Instead, it felt like I paid gourmet prices for average fare.

The vibe of the place is nice, and the staff was friendly, but unless they adjust their pricing or upgrade their offerings, it’s hard to justify the cost for such a basic combo.

Alyssa Menechini

Ordered a cinnamon raisin bagel w cream cheese for take out, got home and it was an everything bagel. I called back to get my order right and they said they were out of cinnamon raisin and demanded me to bring my bagel in if I wanted another one. Horrible customer service.

Service: 1

luis Saga

I’m tired of giving this bagel shop my business. Every single time I come in, it’s a coin flip whether they’ll get my order right.

Today, I ordered a sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich and asked if they had hash browns. When they said yes, I ordered some as a side. I did not ask for the hash browns to be put in my sandwich. But that’s what they did. Mistakes happen, and I would have been fine if they’d just fixed it.

Instead, when I pointed out the mistake, the young lady at the counter didn’t apologize or offer to remake it. Instead, she lectured me that I should have specified that I didn’t want the hash browns inside the sandwich if I ordered them as a side. That’s rude and terrible customer service.

I’m done coming here. Not only do they consistently mess up orders, but they also treat customers poorly and blame them for the mistake they made when both taking the order and preparing it.

This was on top of the other mistakes they've made with my orders, including not packaging items correctly, missing items, messed up orders.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Oscar Benavides

Well - if you look at my reviews, I always try to give a positive review. Not this time - ordered a bagel with an omelet. Guy had his gloves on when serving. However, when he took my money to charge me, he never took his gloves off and when the next person came in, he proceeded to grab the bagel for the next order with the same gloves. I left - didn't even want my money back.

Service: 1

Taty

Best veggie cream cheese !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Top Cat

Fast an good food fresh.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Fatima

Best bagels in town.

JC

Was so excited to try this place out, Rude staff- came in a 35 mins before they closed- had two people telling me I needed to order right away, I barely got two seconds to look at the menu before getting rushed again. Ended up just walking out. Very disappointing

Loading...