Nutley Diner

372 Centre St, Nutley
(973) 235-0937

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+45 photos
+44 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Classic diner, been a number of years since I've been and first time with the kids. The staff was great, accommodating, super helpful and respectful. Food was exactly as you'd expect from a local diner, and my kids ate their meals as we came straight from playing at the nearby playground.
Had breakfast. Eggs were fine, bacon was chewy, home fries had chopped onions but they were bland and needed garlic, blk pepper and possibly some butter while cooking. Our Waitress (Biology Student) saved the day, she was polite, friendly and very professional. I haven't been there in a couple of years but the quality of the food went down hill. They didn't even have Heinze Ketchup. My friends grilled cheese wasn't melted all the way and some of her fries weren't...
Too much cheese on my sandwich so it didn't melt. The ketchup is awful so I didn't enjoy my french fries (get back Heinz!!!) or my sandwich. French fries were still hard in the middle so nit cooked all the way thru. Think the food was cooked too high & too fast. Our waitress was amazing & very friendly! Had tattoo on her right arm & wore glasses.

More Reviews