Sugar Tree Cafe

358 Passaic Ave, Nutley
(973) 437-2300

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Henry Pollio Sr

Quaint little place , nice decoration’s and the staff very friendly.

Mercedes Golderer

Atmosphere is super cute! Wish I had the time to sit down and enjoy something in house.

Sharon Digesu

My grand daughter and I both got the Nutley chicken sandwich. On the menu it said it contained a chicken cutlet but was instead a hard piece of chicken. It was not thin and fried like a chicken cutlet and tasted microwaved and cold. The menu also said that the bread would be tasted but instead was not and extremely chewy. On top of all this it was very expensive for the quality of the food. The cost for 3 drinks and one açaí bowl cost me $40. I would not recommend this place saying that there are so many better options in the area.

Natasia Martin

A nice cafe but not suitable for work from home/remote work. I went to sit to get some work done but WiFi is only offered for 30 mins. In addition the food was good but the service was a little harsh. I asked permission to have a table pushed together which one waitress kindly accommodated because I work from two laptops. Two minutes later another comes over and tells me that the tables can’t be pushed together in a strict tone which made me uncomfortable. Then a loud party of ladies came in and because I still felt uncomfortable I finished my food and left. I understand a place of business has rules, but the restaurant was empty, and I would have kindly complied with moving the tables once it became busy. Unfortunately I will not be back.

Lounge Garra

Found this place on a tik tok
video, wasnt disappointed! The selction of food and drinks is awesome. The food ordered was amazing. The environment is so cool, sucj a fun place !

Cheryl Perumal

Wow!! 12/10 experience. My sister and I were the keepers of the gender and Jack was phenomenal!! He surprised us, had us sobbing with joy! We look forward to many, many more.

Abdulkadir Korucuk

It was a very pleasant experience, and my guests liked it very much.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

mynamessalma

Amazing atmosphere, food and service. We had the notorious BLT and Greens & Things power salad, which was completely delicious. The host girl and server were also super sweet and professional. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

chaya sanders

Such a cool cafe. Such good vibes. The food and drinks were great.

Kid-friendliness: Not very kids friendly

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Avocado Toast, S'Mores Milkshakes

Laura Ragusa

I'm honestly shocked about some of the food reviews on here. I was there this morning and thought the food was so outstanding that I needed to get on here are write a review immediately. We got the avo toast and a veggie omelet to split. I thought both were incredibly delicious; way above average, esp. the omelet.

Ambiance of course was cute. Coffee was solid. I like the way they set up the service actually; it's like you get the best of both worlds–fast-casual and sit-down service. Wish I had taken pics but would definitely recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Avocado Toast

Denisse Quinteros

The food was so delicious. I had the chicken sandwich. Omg so fresh and so good. The music and atmosphere was calm, perfect for a Monday morning.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Nutley Chicken Sandwich

Jim D

I’m not one to write a bad review but this place is beyond hyped up. I understand it’s “viral” online but it truly shouldn’t be. My wife did a TGTG order I know it’s only $6 but man I’ve gotten better bakery items from ShopRite for that price. We got 3 croissants and a burnt mini cookie. The croissants were hard and had absolutely no flavor. Not what we were expecting from a “viral” place. Disappointed, mind you we do TGTG for fun not expecting high standards.

Food: 1

Jalyssa Stewart

The smell of the bathrooms over powers the entire back area. Coffee wasn’t good. Food was ok. Staff were friendly. One & done. Don’t ever need to go back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Yaminah Smith

Aesthetically, this is a beautiful cafe. However, aside from its aesthetic, I would not recommend. The food was below average in taste and served at an inadequate temperature. Additionally, some of the workers were extremely unpleasant and rude. Although this cafe advertises itself as a great place to take photos, they became hostile when my friend and I attempted to take a photo of ourselves by the flower wall. We did not cause any disturbance nor interference with any of the other customers. We were simply taking a photo as we waited for our food.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Altina Iseni

no space to seat.Its ridicolus the fact that has to wait to seat just for coffe.Only 5 tables and each table one person with computers meanwhile if you go as a group you get seated in a stupid corner

Atmosphere: 1

Loading...