The Oakley -- Kitchen & Cocktails

I’ve had dinner and cocktails here numerous times and I’m never disappointed! Drinks are fantastic! You’ll also have a good chance of having some live music during dinner, which is always a nice added touch.

I also had the pleasure of working directly with Khris for a school event on the 2nd floor. It was a comedy night (which I had never hosted before) so his suggestions and guidance made everything feel so easy. On the night of the event, the staff was very attentive to our party of over 80 people, which was definitely an integral part of the event’s success.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The place was huge, food and service was very good. Annie Oakley Awesome decor and a very nice atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was my second and most likely last time here. My 1st was pretty good, there was a private event downstairs and so my friend and I sat upstairs at the bar and the food and drinks were good. Tonight my husband and I went for dinner and we ordered 2 glasses of red wine. The glasses were small and not even half full and at $15 per glass I was not thrilled. My burger was good but the French fries were so salty and had so much black pepper that I was not able to eat it. It’s not like the place was busy as it was so cold out, we were the only 2 people in the dining area.
My husband was not happy that he even left his boneless chicken wing and he was not even mad. Will not return.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

I really enjoyed the Oakley. The food was good, but what was most important to me was that the staff was friendly and funny. I'm definitely going to become a regular customer.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love the Oakley. Always guaranteed to have great food and excellent service. Everything was perfect, I can't wait to go back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

WHY are the doors open when a Pre-K is attached to them?? Is Nutley teaching our pre-k students about alcohol consumption? Many reasons, specifically the owner. I had the most terrible experience of working there for about 3 or 4 shifts before I saw 👀 what was really going on! NOPE and NOPE! Still waiting for the tips I earned working while his son “worked too” AKA hung out 🤣🤣 I’ll pray 🙏🏽 for them Nepotism is never worth it. GREEDY How are they still operating?

I went to Oakley Kitchen in Nutley to celebrate my birthday, and it was the worst dining experiences I’ve ever had. The restaurant wasn’t even busy, yet our food took over an hour to come out. When we brought it up, there was no apology, no explanation, and no attempt to make things right.

To make matters worse, the staff was rude and dismissive from the moment we said something. And the manager, Nicole, was especially unprofessional. Her customer service skills seriously need work — instead of trying to resolve the issue, she acted like we were the problem.

For a place that presents itself as a nicer local spot, the service was unacceptable. I would never go back, and I definitely wouldn’t recommend it to anyone — especially if you’re planning a special occasion. Total disappointment. I’m a local resident of Nutley and will be sure to let everyone know of my terrible experience at your establishment. I even asked for the owner number and they refused to provide it. I found it anyway and I left a voicemail. I will be expecting a call back Kristopher.

Edit:
Your response says everything I needed to know about how this place is run. Instead of addressing the service issues I experienced, you chose to insult a customer and bring up irrelevant personal details. That’s incredibly unprofessional for an owner.
My review was based on how I was treated during my visit — dismissively and without any attempt to correct the situation. Your reaction here just reinforces exactly why the experience was so disappointing.
Thank you for confirming that the problem wasn’t the staff, but the leadership. I stand by every word of my review.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

We had a party there Chris the manager was amazing he took care of everything. The staff and the food was great.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thank you for your hospitality during these times ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Crab cakes were cold, French fries were stuck together. Hamburger was overcooked and the bun was too small for the burger. French Onion Soup was warm, but still better than last time. We gave it another chance from the last we were disappointed. We will not be returning. The dining room could use some decorating.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

I had my husbands 50th birthday here. The upstairs party room is perfect to host your party. Drinks were flowing, food was amazing, and the service was impeccable.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The owner is very personable. Food and service were great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I really enjoyed this place. The pizza was phenomenal and the staff was super-friendly. I especially appreciate Oakley has done recently for people who depend on SNAP. I salute them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Had fun on trivia night every other Wednesdays 👍 team Rutgers round up winning second place! Go RU, Go Scarlet Knights!
Thank you Oakley for helping out the community of people who may be in need (during the crisis) 🙏🏼 blessings ❤️

Very good