Woodcroft Steakhouse & Seafood
24 Washington Ave, Nutley
(973) 235-0505
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Shame I could not give the service 10 stars. They accommodated a large party as well as some odd circumstances / demands that we had. They worked with us to find options for my autistic nephew by allowing us to go off menu as well. A few of us had ribs eye steaks which were average/above average. Everyone else went with seafood specials and they all raved about it. Will definitely look to return in the future.
Father's Day Dinner – Outstanding from Start to Finish We celebrated Father's Day at Woodcroft Steakhouse today and had an absolutely phenomenal experience. The surf & turf special was cooked to perfection—tender, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Every dish we had was rich with robust flavor, from the creamed spinach to the impressive seafood tower, which was fresh and expertly prepared. What truly elevated the evening was the service. Our server was gracious, attentive, and made spot-on recommendations throughout the meal. As a thoughtful finishing touch, the maître d' and server surprised us with a complimentary after-dinner Amaretto, which was both generous and memorable. Woodcroft continues to shine with its warm hospitality, elegant atmosphere, and standout cuisine. Highly recommended for anyone looking to enjoy a quality dining experience!
Usually I do not do reviews, but I think this one was needed. The food was absolutely phenomenal, every dish bursting with flavor and plated beautifully, the quantity was shareable for three people. But the service? A disaster. We waited 20 minutes just to get drinks and the menu, and the server seemed spaced out and was not attentive to our table. Also, to add the manager didn't really check in as he did with other tables. To note when I created the reservation it had notes as "Birthday" when we checked in, we were not asked about the birthday or anything. Towards the end of paying the waiter took forever to get the check or give us the check. we had to say something twice. It's a shame such incredible cuisine is paired with such poor hospitality."
Food was awesome! Very nice atmosphere. Pleasant and courteous staff. Malda the hostess was terrific! Bartender and waiter were both very nice and accomodating.
The steak was cooked to perfection, and all the appetizers — including the bacon and Italian sausage pasta — were exceptionally delicious. I was also very pleased with the cocktail; the Old Fashioned was particularly well-made. The quality of the aged meat was outstanding. Overall, the food was highly satisfying and full of flavor.
I held a dinner here for my daughter’s college graduation. The. Food, service and atmosphere were outstanding. Our guests are raving about it. Woodcroft has gained many new Customers.
Wonderful restaurant..great food, drinks were awesome and I enjoyed the music. Will definitely return.
Worst steak I ever had .. Rubberry , tasteless and cooked rare not med what I ordered . 240$
This was the 2nd time my wife and I have dined at Woodcroft. We have found that the service is fantastic,the food is prepared perfectly and always delicious. We love coming to Woodcroft,the value is great as is the overall experience.
Third time within the last 30 days. Staff was point on and the food was perfect. Yuri and his team do a great job. Highly recommend this restaurant.
Restaurantji Recommends
The steak and lobster special was great. We also had the baked clams. We celebrated my husbands birthday. The special came with a bottle of wine. We had a great experience service was great!
Sort in a magazine figured we'd give it a try. We were very happy with everything. Will be back soon.
Great local establishment. Priced right for the area, service is exceptional. Shrimp cocktail was on point. The Chilean Sea Bass stuffed with crabmeat was delicious. NY strip cooked to perfection.
The service was great and steak was perfectly cooked. Very good meal. I will be coming back to this nice place.
My husband and I went for my birthday dinner - mostly everything was fantastic. Food, music, waiting staff. Just lovely!!! The only odd thing was the manager on staff himself. He seemed to only greet customers and check on tables who ordered extra liquor or more expensive things? It wasn't crowded and there was plenty of staff so it seemed like he didn't have to wait those tables, it seemed like a choice. Out of like 7 tables he did this to 3 and the others that I noticed had a bit less he didn't stop by to even see how guests were doing, our table included and we spent a good amount so that left a bad impression. He only spoke to us when taking our checks to pay.... Yikes. BUT happy to say everything else was phenomenal. Please note: there was a short wait for appetizers - LONG wait for main courses. But I can see why. The food is very fresh, very quality made. Makes it worth it!
Loading...