Gigi NY Pizza

758 Boardwalk, Ocean City
(609) 231-6595

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jason H

$5.89. RIP OFF. GARBAGE. AVOID. TINY

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Naomi Mattei

Well, its so overpriced for small servings, no cheese, taste like out if the can cause pizza. Will not be eating here again. Sadly, we chose to pick this one when there are so many great pizza places on OC NJ boardwalk! One more thing, the music the young men who were working that day, were playing was so vulgar, I could not stand near the place and wait for our order!!

Justyna Sanzari

We go back to Ocean City every summer, and we also visit Gigi NY pizza every vacation. Their GF pizza AND stromboli are amazing!!! My husband has celiac, so it's awesome that he has these choices on the boardwalk, but I actually enjoyed the cauliflower crust pizza so much, I got it for myself one of the days because it was that tasty!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sammy Saie

I had a really disappointing experience here. My family had ordered food in the promenade where this restaurant is located on the OC boardwalk, and when I came in to sit with them carrying a Manco & Manco pizza box, the owner and employees of this restaurant actually kicked us all out. Instead of letting me join my family which I had mentioned they purchased food in the promenade already (just not theirs), they chose to make a scene.

This kind of behavior really shows insecurity — it feels like the owner is self-conscious about people preferring other pizza over his. And based on other reviews, it seems I’m not alone in noticing issues with the poor service and unfriendly personalities of the staff.

There are plenty of places at the shore where the food is good and the people treat you with respect. Unfortunately, this place is not one of them. Continue to take your business elsewhere.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Carol Vechini

I just had the best Gluten free pizza, staff was great, I will definitely come back to try others GF options they offer 10/10!!

Derrick Moyer

We have gotten the gluten free stromboli three times and it was Amazing every time!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristina Marshall

Rude owner! Go next door to manco for good service and better food

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Stacy M

Brought my celiac niece there for GF pizza. The staff was amazing, explaining their GF process! They even gave other GF recommendations. And she said the pizza was the best she’s had in a while !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

p azar

Orders a full pie, plain pizza non peak time around 2pm our pizza was ready but the attendant cut it for sale in pieces to others that came 10 mins after us. It took another 20 minutes for our pizza to be done. I complained to the manager but he simply didn't care. Awful experience highly recommend ordering from another restaurant, many options at the boardwalk to choose from. The pizza was also nothing special for a total price of $30 including tax.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Mary G

Unfortunately the pizza was very salty, the crust was good. We sat upstairs and enjoyed people watching on the boardwalk. They have a good deal $9 for 2 slices + a soda. We will not be back - 3 Brothers is the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Paul Kaser

Recently heard that this pizza place, located inside the Promenade Food Court, had gluten-free stromboli, which is super rare to find. When we got there we were told that they usually sell out of them early, but since it wasn't super busy if we had 20 minutes to wait they could make them fresh for us. We were thrilled and ordered three of them: buffalo chicken, spinach and tomato, and 3 cheese. The pizza-maker, David, couldn't have been nicer and more accommodating. The strombolis were excellent, and I wish I grabbed a picture but they were devoured before I could get my phone out. This was a very positive experience at a rather nondescript pizza place, so we will definitely be back for the food quality and the service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nichole

They made us a gluten free Stromboli! It was delicious. The dough was wonderful. I would highly recommend them to anyone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Justin Donovan

I can’t comment on the food, as I did not eat here; however -

My fiancée and daughter got food from here, I walked in carrying a Manco & Manco box, and one of the workers yelled at me that I cannot come in with outside food. I explained to him I was going to sit down with my family, who were inside, and he asked me to leave my food outside. Who in their right mind would ask something so obtuse? Further, who would actually do that?

Ok, so I found a table outside and sat down to eat my slice of pizza in hurried fashion. Another older gentleman with glasses approached me and told me I needed to leave because no outside food was allowed. He was extremely rude and said “I spy” as he approached and pointed at his eyes then over to me.

I’ve seen similar comments on reviews for this place. Honestly I don’t wish ill will - I hope these people either change or are rewarded with consequences of their terrible behavior.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Kenny Deimler

I would give 0 stars if I could. Ignorant personal cause I asked why we were still waiting while others after were givin pizza we were waiting. Then it was so black burnt. I wouldn’t recommend to anyone. As me and wife attempted to eat they gazed laughing. I hope karma comes a knocking.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ryan Freeman

The Sicilian pie is fantastic. The guys behind the counter were great.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...