Gigi NY Pizza

758 Boardwalk, Ocean City
(609) 231-6595

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mary G

Unfortunately the pizza was very salty, the crust was good. We sat upstairs and enjoyed people watching on the boardwalk. They have a good deal $9 for 2 slices + a soda. We will not be back - 3 Brothers is the best!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Paul Kaser

Recently heard that this pizza place, located inside the Promenade Food Court, had gluten-free stromboli, which is super rare to find. When we got there we were told that they usually sell out of them early, but since it wasn't super busy if we had 20 minutes to wait they could make them fresh for us. We were thrilled and ordered three of them: buffalo chicken, spinach and tomato, and 3 cheese. The pizza-maker, David, couldn't have been nicer and more accommodating. The strombolis were excellent, and I wish I grabbed a picture but they were devoured before I could get my phone out. This was a very positive experience at a rather nondescript pizza place, so we will definitely be back for the food quality and the service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nichole

They made us a gluten free Stromboli! It was delicious. The dough was wonderful. I would highly recommend them to anyone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Justin Donovan

I can’t comment on the food, as I did not eat here; however -

My fiancée and daughter got food from here, I walked in carrying a Manco & Manco box, and one of the workers yelled at me that I cannot come in with outside food. I explained to him I was going to sit down with my family, who were inside, and he asked me to leave my food outside. Who in their right mind would ask something so obtuse? Further, who would actually do that?

Ok, so I found a table outside and sat down to eat my slice of pizza in hurried fashion. Another older gentleman with glasses approached me and told me I needed to leave because no outside food was allowed. He was extremely rude and said “I spy” as he approached and pointed at his eyes then over to me.

I’ve seen similar comments on reviews for this place. Honestly I don’t wish ill will - I hope these people either change or are rewarded with consequences of their terrible behavior.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Kenny Deimler

I would give 0 stars if I could. Ignorant personal cause I asked why we were still waiting while others after were givin pizza we were waiting. Then it was so black burnt. I wouldn’t recommend to anyone. As me and wife attempted to eat they gazed laughing. I hope karma comes a knocking.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ryan Freeman

The Sicilian pie is fantastic. The guys behind the counter were great.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carissa Wallace

Congratulations you guys are receiving my very first 1 star review! Click on my profile, I’m against leaving 1 star reviews because I feel like you should talk to the company face to face to handle a problem, but I did try that avenue so here I am letting everyone know! The way you talk to your customers is unacceptable and these reviews will be flowing in if you don’t change

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Emma Cathlene

I highly recommend Manco and Manco over this place. Let me paint a picture for you, it’s pouring out, I am 8 months pregnant wrangling 3 kids with my husband and sister in law, my brother in law walks over to our table in front of Gigis and the juice place, that I just spent 20$ for fresh pressed juice, and he sits down with Manco and Manco pizza. Some guy from Gigis comes out and says we can’t sit at that table because we have a Manco and Manco pizza box. So not only was he rude, but he then begins to point out signs that apparently exist saying we can’t have “outside food” at this table even though I just spent 20$ on juice. Even if their food is good, their morals are trash, find yourself a place that’s going to respect the sanctity of families trying to seek shelter from the rain to eat their dinner.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Matt Laverty

DO NOT EAT HERE. Terrible service, awful food that I regretted eating immediately, even after this incident occurred. My wife, my dad and me all got food from here. Not ONLY did we get food from here, but we bought drinks to go with our dinner from the juice place in this same food court. My Son wasn’t excited (got good reason) to get food from here so he and his friend went up to another pizza place to get two slices. My wife, me and my dad sat and ate there, and then my son comes back and sits down with us. This aggressive guy with short hair and glasses from this place came over about 20 seconds after my son sat down with us. To yell at us in a very rude way that the tables are for customers only. My wife and I both tried to explain that we were customers, and I was still holding in my hand my tray, leftovers (because it was awful so I didn’t eat half of it) and drink. He rudely repeated himself in a more aggressive way, my son and his friend politely got up with their pizza, walked across the boardwalk to sit on a bench. And this guy as he walks away from us makes a snide remark that our kids are doing the right thing. All of this was completely unnecessary. Afterwards, we saw this exact same incident occur with another dad and his family, and this same guy called the police over.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nolan Russell

Wonderful rootbeer pour.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marion Caragias Evans

Just got my favorite, pizza, and it is the BEST!!

Marion Evans

Just got my favorite, pizza, and it is the BEST!!

Hamza Asad

Food tasted like cardboard. Extremely rude staff, saw the owner cursing out many

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chelsea Quirino

Love this pizza. The guys that run this place have the best energy as well. Such good vibes. The sauce on the plain slice is better than so many others I’ve had down the shore!!! Def recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dana Andrie

Kids did a boardwalk Pizza tour and ranked Gigi’s the best on the boardwalk!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...