This place has big slices, good flavor. This is a boardwalk must when I visit OCNJ.
Richard A.
I definitely enjoyed my big slice here on the Ocean City boardwalk! It's at least 20" and on the thin side. I liked the cheese the most out of the three pizza parts. I would give the nod to Manco and Manco overall, but this is still a great slice. Ambiance is nice - I would LOVE to try eating an entire pie in under an hour and earning a reward! Maybe next time I'm in Ocean City...
Lauren V
Very friendly and helpful staff. Cut our child’s piece smaller and into bite size pieces. And ensured that we were satisfied. Pizza has a sweeter sauce but very good and huge slices! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve S.
I'm trying to expand my Ocean City pizza options. I have to say I was truly torn on this slice. In a lot of ways I liked it. It tasted decent. The sauce flavor was nice and sweet with a little savory to it. There's nothing wrong with it. But at the same time it is very inconsistent throughout. The sauce is spotty. Some bites had the flavor and others didn't. It's almost like they concentrate on the slice being too big instead of evenly flavored. And nothing about the flavor when it hits made me think that I would crave this over other choices when I come back here. I'm sure other slices here are better with different toppings. But I judge the merits of a pizza place on whether they can wow me on the basics. Maybe they still can if they make their pies consistently, which is always a problem on the boardwalk.
Joe Bakanas
I have been coming to Three Brothers since I was 14. I always look forward to getting at least a slice of the Buffalo Chicken Pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Kate
Huge slices!!! Super good $5 a piece for a slice that’s the size of about two normal pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Harry McCormick
Tiny shop but super cool. Perhaps amongst the best boardwalk pizza any of us has ever had. Huge slices quick service. The pies are huge and the servers help serve you. Super cool experence!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza Slice
BuddyCrafted
After placing an order we were given incorrect change. The older Italian woman behind the counter refused to give us the correct change because she jumped to another customer while we were in the process of finishing the transaction. The pizza was fine but not the reason why we will never be returning here ever again. If you do plan on coming here PAY WITH A CARD.Kid-friendliness: Not a lick of friendliness
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Joseph Gardner (Krazeguy)
Amazingly humongous slices of delicious pizza!Came back a year later and guess what?Still amazing!Kid-friendliness: What kid doesn't like gigantic pizza?!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Sausage and Pineapple Pizza, Spinach Ricotta Cheese Pizza Slice
Middling pizza place on the boardwalk with mediocre slices and exorbitant prices. The spinach and tomato we got was nothing special (although I will admit the crust was great) and it somehow cost $8. We'll come back at some point and give it another try by buying a full pie, but at $40 per pie that might be a tough ask -- we'll see. I understand they're whole schtick is big slices but realistically I'd rather normal sized slices, better quality, and more realistic prices. 3-star option!
Eastern S.
After placing an order we were given incorrect change. The older Italian woman behind the counter refused to give us the correct change because she jumped to another customer while we were in the process of finishing the transaction. The pizza was fine but not the reason why we will never be returning here ever again. If you do plan on coming here PAY WITH A CARD.
sisna g
pizza was sooooooo good and i ate that yummy crispy but doughy pizza in 5 seconds i’d eat that pizza everyday if i could. it’s unfortunate that i don’t have this pizza place in my home town but maybe it’s a good thing so i don’t get fat from eating it everyday. the crust was one point, it was just the right crispness the cheese was cooked just right and the sauce was diligently positioned throughout the pizza very thoughtfully. this pizza is by far the best on the boardwalk and in my personal experience the best pizza i’ve ever gobbled in my life.
kturcz23
Huge slices!!! Super good $5 a piece for a slice that’s the size of about two normal pizza slices
Jennifer Pastore
No flavour, gave kids a slice half the size of the adults in front of us...same
The pizza was huge and delicious ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
This place has big slices, good flavor. This is a boardwalk must when I visit OCNJ.
I definitely enjoyed my big slice here on the Ocean City boardwalk! It's at least 20" and on the thin side. I liked the cheese the most out of the three pizza parts. I would give the nod to Manco and Manco overall, but this is still a great slice. Ambiance is nice - I would LOVE to try eating an entire pie in under an hour and earning a reward! Maybe next time I'm in Ocean City...
Very friendly and helpful staff. Cut our child’s piece smaller and into bite size pieces. And ensured that we were satisfied. Pizza has a sweeter sauce but very good and huge slices! Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm trying to expand my Ocean City pizza options. I have to say I was truly torn on this slice. In a lot of ways I liked it. It tasted decent. The sauce flavor was nice and sweet with a little savory to it. There's nothing wrong with it. But at the same time it is very inconsistent throughout. The sauce is spotty. Some bites had the flavor and others didn't. It's almost like they concentrate on the slice being too big instead of evenly flavored. And nothing about the flavor when it hits made me think that I would crave this over other choices when I come back here. I'm sure other slices here are better with different toppings. But I judge the merits of a pizza place on whether they can wow me on the basics. Maybe they still can if they make their pies consistently, which is always a problem on the boardwalk.
I have been coming to Three Brothers since I was 14. I always look forward to getting at least a slice of the Buffalo Chicken Pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Huge slices!!! Super good $5 a piece for a slice that’s the size of about two normal pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiny shop but super cool. Perhaps amongst the best boardwalk pizza any of us has ever had. Huge slices quick service. The pies are huge and the servers help serve you. Super cool experence!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza Slice
After placing an order we were given incorrect change. The older Italian woman behind the counter refused to give us the correct change because she jumped to another customer while we were in the process of finishing the transaction. The pizza was fine but not the reason why we will never be returning here ever again. If you do plan on coming here PAY WITH A CARD.Kid-friendliness: Not a lick of friendliness
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Amazingly humongous slices of delicious pizza!Came back a year later and guess what?Still amazing!Kid-friendliness: What kid doesn't like gigantic pizza?!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Sausage and Pineapple Pizza, Spinach Ricotta Cheese Pizza Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
Middling pizza place on the boardwalk with mediocre slices and exorbitant prices. The spinach and tomato we got was nothing special (although I will admit the crust was great) and it somehow cost $8. We'll come back at some point and give it another try by buying a full pie, but at $40 per pie that might be a tough ask -- we'll see. I understand they're whole schtick is big slices but realistically I'd rather normal sized slices, better quality, and more realistic prices. 3-star option!
After placing an order we were given incorrect change. The older Italian woman behind the counter refused to give us the correct change because she jumped to another customer while we were in the process of finishing the transaction. The pizza was fine but not the reason why we will never be returning here ever again. If you do plan on coming here PAY WITH A CARD.
pizza was sooooooo good and i ate that yummy crispy but doughy pizza in 5 seconds i’d eat that pizza everyday if i could. it’s unfortunate that i don’t have this pizza place in my home town but maybe it’s a good thing so i don’t get fat from eating it everyday. the crust was one point, it was just the right crispness the cheese was cooked just right and the sauce was diligently positioned throughout the pizza very thoughtfully. this pizza is by far the best on the boardwalk and in my personal experience the best pizza i’ve ever gobbled in my life.
Huge slices!!! Super good $5 a piece for a slice that’s the size of about two normal pizza slices
No flavour, gave kids a slice half the size of the adults in front of us...same
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2