This is what your neighborhood pizzeria wants to be when it grows up. Pizzas are always perfect, service is quick, food is pretty much always delivered on time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda DeJessa
Had Baldwin cater numerous events and not only was the food fantastic, the service provided was phenomenal. Everyone enjoyed the food. It was super fresh, ready on time, and affordable. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ANON
Left their trash outside my door.
Confidential Services
DO NOT EAT HERE !!! Workers have no standards here. Whoever the bald guy is, was digging in his pants and shirt the whole time and he was drinking alcohol on the job. I’ve never seen such unprofessionalism from a Jersey pizza shop. NEVER GO HERE.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ruby
Hello I’m a chef from NewYork . You guys make good food but not GREAT food . I’ve ordered a hot dog from you guys & yall gave me no bun which is ridiculous for a price of $5 . Then I ordered hot wings from you guys twice & both times the Wings were Super hard and dry. Then another time I ordered a grilled chicken Caesar salad and you guys put the Caesar dressing on top of the salad so my lettuce was already super soggy. Couldn’t even enjoy the entire salad ! And that’s just one of many not so good orders from y’all. You guys have good potential but just need better help with your efforts on your food quality & taste. Don’t take this personal just take it as good criticism. Buona giornata👩🏾🍳
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Raeed Shaikh
Top notch pizza and cheesecake
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Top Secret
$40 dollars for a pizza is crazy your going to have to pay high TAX on food @ be overcharged for food that isn't the best anyways and drivers being 'used' over there is crazy! The poor driver[s] go thru a lot over their and are clueless on what's going on half the time with the orders. Tips and better atmosphere would be better if management knew how to manage but i know its hard managing a whole staff when you got alot going on. The pizza makers deserve 10 stars for the great job of them making the pizza i will say! I wonder if they were running the joint would this place would have a better result!
Morals: Not trying to do better at all!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dani O
After years away from Jersey, we decided to order a pie while stuck at the worst hotel in Parsippany. The Fairfield Inn was a disaster, but Baldwin Pizza saved the day. The pizza was the perfect taste of home, and they packed it up with more care than the hotel gave to anything. Thanks to Baldwin Pizza for being the best part of our trip and a true staple in the community. 10/10 recommend but don’t stay at the Fairfield Inn.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Baldwin Pizza
Navya Martin
We regularly get the Pizza from there, its a great shop family owned. The pizzas are perfect especially thai chicken and honey garlic.We love them🫶🏻🫶🏻
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gigi Nichols
Got pizza, eggplant roll, chicken fingers and chicken wings and all of themnwere really good. I would go back if I was in that area again.
We ordered a Extra Large Veggie pizza with fresh garlic instead of broccoli. Tasty sauce, cheese, and crust was all good! Have not tried the salads yet but they look good. Great experience.
Bryan D Barger
Absolutely love this place! Since I began working in the area, Ive tried pizza from EVERY pizza place in a 20 mile radius. Baldwin is the only place I return to. Best pizza around! The staff is extremely accommodating and warm!
Saty Smith
Lucky to have a great pizza place so close to my home. Have the tortellini soup too. And the eggplant rollatini is nice.
Majo Gutiérrez
I’d give more stars to this place if it was possible. I’ve been here a couple times, mostly for pick up and the staff is always so friendly and the food is AMAZING
This is what your neighborhood pizzeria wants to be when it grows up. Pizzas are always perfect, service is quick, food is pretty much always delivered on time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had Baldwin cater numerous events and not only was the food fantastic, the service provided was phenomenal. Everyone enjoyed the food. It was super fresh, ready on time, and affordable. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Left their trash outside my door.
DO NOT EAT HERE !!! Workers have no standards here. Whoever the bald guy is, was digging in his pants and shirt the whole time and he was drinking alcohol on the job. I’ve never seen such unprofessionalism from a Jersey pizza shop. NEVER GO HERE.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Hello I’m a chef from NewYork . You guys make good food but not GREAT food . I’ve ordered a hot dog from you guys & yall gave me no bun which is ridiculous for a price of $5 . Then I ordered hot wings from you guys twice & both times the Wings were Super hard and dry. Then another time I ordered a grilled chicken Caesar salad and you guys put the Caesar dressing on top of the salad so my lettuce was already super soggy. Couldn’t even enjoy the entire salad ! And that’s just one of many not so good orders from y’all. You guys have good potential but just need better help with your efforts on your food quality & taste.
Don’t take this personal just take it as good criticism. Buona giornata👩🏾🍳
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Top notch pizza and cheesecake
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
$40 dollars for a pizza is crazy your going to have to pay high TAX on food @ be overcharged for food that isn't the best anyways and drivers being 'used' over there is crazy! The poor driver[s] go thru a lot over their and are clueless on what's going on half the time with the orders. Tips and better atmosphere would be better if management knew how to manage but i know its hard managing a whole staff when you got alot going on. The pizza makers deserve 10 stars for the great job of them making the pizza i will say! I wonder if they were running the joint would this place would have a better result!
Morals: Not trying to do better at all!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
After years away from Jersey, we decided to order a pie while stuck at the worst hotel in Parsippany. The Fairfield Inn was a disaster, but Baldwin Pizza saved the day. The pizza was the perfect taste of home, and they packed it up with more care than the hotel gave to anything. Thanks to Baldwin Pizza for being the best part of our trip and a true staple in the community. 10/10 recommend but don’t stay at the Fairfield Inn.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Baldwin Pizza
We regularly get the Pizza from there, its a great shop family owned. The pizzas are perfect especially thai chicken and honey garlic.We love them🫶🏻🫶🏻
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got pizza, eggplant roll, chicken fingers and chicken wings and all of themnwere really good. I would go back if I was in that area again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food and staff! We love this place.
We ordered a Extra Large Veggie pizza with fresh garlic instead of broccoli. Tasty sauce, cheese, and crust was all good! Have not tried the salads yet but they look good.
Great experience.
Absolutely love this place! Since I began working in the area, Ive tried pizza from EVERY pizza place in a 20 mile radius. Baldwin is the only place I return to. Best pizza around! The staff is extremely accommodating and warm!
Lucky to have a great pizza place so close to my home. Have the tortellini soup too. And the eggplant rollatini is nice.
I’d give more stars to this place if it was possible. I’ve been here a couple times, mostly for pick up and the staff is always so friendly and the food is AMAZING
Loading...