Baldwin Pizzeria
142 Baldwin Rd, Parsippany
(973) 335-7731
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
Got pizza, eggplant roll, chicken fingers and chicken wings and all of themnwere really good. I would go back if I was in that area again.
Excellent food and staff! We love this place.
We ordered a Extra Large Veggie pizza with fresh garlic instead of broccoli. Tasty sauce, cheese, and crust was all good! Have not tried the salads yet but they look good.
Great experience.
Absolutely love this place! Since I began working in the area, Ive tried pizza from EVERY pizza place in a 20 mile radius. Baldwin is the only place I return to. Best pizza around! The staff is extremely accommodating and warm!
Lucky to have a great pizza place so close to my home. Have the tortellini soup too. And the eggplant rollatini is nice.
I’d give more stars to this place if it was possible. I’ve been here a couple times, mostly for pick up and the staff is always so friendly and the food is AMAZING
Pizza was great! Just stopped to grab a slice. Just a average pizzeria.
The pizza is of good quality. However, they got my utterly simplistic order wrong a couple of times in a one-month period. I can’t understand why this happens. When I called them out on this, one of the staff took the opportunity to make a dig at my intelligence, asserting that I called and placed the order at another pizzeria. It’ll be the last order that I will place with this pizzeria.
I ordered 2 rice balls. They were awful. After 2 bites all I tasted one, all I tasted was cheddar cheese and fried crust. I was wondering where was the rice??? There was another kind of cheese in it. It was not parmesan cheese. It was extremely heavy and left me with abdominal pain and feeling sick.
My husband had a rice ball that had cheddar cheese and ground beef. You needed a microscope to find the rice.
As an Italian every time I had a rice ball it was mostly rice with grated parmesan cheese and sometimes a small cheese in the middle. Or if you ordered a meat rice ball, rice was the main ingredient with some meat inside with some grated parmesan cheese.
We ordered a margarita pizza. I had a slice. It was cold and the cheese on top was hard.
Big disappointment . I took out before but this time it was awful.
I can't rate the pizza...because I don't like pizza... I know crazy right! But the calzones, fried mushrooms, chicken parm.....always fantastic......service impeccable....even the delivery people are amazing! Love this local spot!
Restaurantji Recommends
Uber eats only start making orders when you get here. Takes forever. Put a symbol on the map and decline all orders from here. Time is money. No other restaurant is not ready after 7pm. 5pm rush, understandable.
This is a perfect place to eat some real good pizza!!! I really recommend the “meat lovers” 😜👍🏽🍕 Iam actually from Germany, but when Iam around and rent a car at the Enterprise next door!!! Iam always looking for some slices and a cool chat with the owner! Really cool guy! Can’t wait to see you guys again! Best regards Miky from 👉🏼🇩🇪😉
Outrageously good pizza. In town for work and decided to stop here- the pizza was delicious, the service was great, Im a very happy customer
Grilled chicken and raviolis, hit the spot! They make more then Pizza. Playing 90s country and 80s rock.
Strip mall gem. Some of the best Italian food I've ever had. Love these owner/ chef places that make you feel at home the minute you walk in.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...