Lake Hiawatha Dairy

79 N Beverwyck Rd, Lake Hiawatha
(973) 316-6686

Recent Reviews

shortroundChris

Haven't been here in a LONG time and I grew up here. They have so many new flavors to choose from. Today I got a medium cup whoch gets you 3 scoops. I got the Taco Tuesday, PBnJ, and the Coach. Sooooo delicious. Flavor overload. I taste tested the Bees Knees, which is like a Graham cracker type flavor. That was pretty good too. Definitely will get next time. Medium costed just under $6. Not bad for great quality ice cream. Texture was perfect as well. Nice to come back to my childhood spot. I lived around the corner back then. They expanded the place so there is now more seating which is nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Coleen L.

Best ice cream around. We go here for our fix for hot fudge sundaes . Ice cream cakes are big and well worth the money

Gail Lavelle

Delicious ice creamKid-friendliness: What child doesn't love ice cream? And the have wonderful ice cream novelties.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chocolate Ice Cream, Ice Cream Treats, Vanilla Soft Serve

Sam Deo

We've passed by this place for years never going in, but a few weeks ago we need an ice cream fix, and we were not disappointed at all. They have some unique flavors like PeanutButter Cheese cake, which is excellent! But they also have your standard chocolate and such which are also outstanding.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Black Raspberry, Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream

Paul Dreifuss

Delicious ice cream served at perfect temperature. So MANY flavors to choose from. Great service and cute store!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sharon Barbosa

I have been in several ice cream parlors! They are the best I will eventually taste all flavors??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cakes

Natasha G.

The gem of Lake's Hiawatha's "Main Street." Classic ice cream parlor with all the standard flavors and soft serve. Newly expanded indoor seating. Highly recommend!

Dan Carey

This place is great! The products and service are always #1. Stop in and see for yourself.

Shawn Ashley

Really kind staff. Excellent flavors of ice cream. Will come back 1000 more times

Paul Romano

Excellent, homemade, adventurous flavors served by an incredibly polite staff.

Sussie

The cotton candy ice-cream was out of this world! Not too sweet and smoothly creamy ?

s Halstead

I visited this establishment yesterday seeking a hot fudge sundae with chopped nuts. I was informed that If I added nuts, it was not considered a sundae?? So, the nuts and hot fudge were charged separately as additional toppings. I have NEVER heard of such a things.Moreover, neither the ice cream or hot fudge were anything spectacular. I would not recommend this place.

Irene M. Candelaria

Better than the denville dairy! All staff are always super nice and friendly even during busy hours in the summer. Their ice cream cakes are to die for!

Tara N

The most underrated ice cream spot in Morris county. They make the best ice cream cakes in the area hands down

Cory

Hard to beat. Great ice cream shop all around.

Load More