It is one the best pies around and you have to go and enjoy the quality of the pie.. sauce crust cheese... always consistent! all so evenly prepared... dinners are solid as well.. order a pie as soon as u get there.. then review the menu for dinner!
Mike
Tonight I had the pleasure of trying and made my Patsy’s debut. Fantastic old school vibe and atmosphere. Came for the show stealer the pizza. Pizza is a very sacred thing to me, pizza is pizza but GREAT pizza is completely different. This one was FANTASTIC. I really enjoyed the large pie with a nice thin crust and well rounded kept together slices. I would get this pie every day if I could it was that good!Thanks again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe N
Pizza is amazing! Crust so crispy and zero flop!
Food: 5
Kristine S.
Found this neighborhood gem during COVID while doing a recommended pizza crawl. At the time there was no indoor dining because of COVID. While we had been twice during COVID this was our first time dining in. Quaint no frills ambience steeped in a lot of history. Don't think much has changed in many years other than the prices. Staff there is warm and inviting. What makes the pizza so good is the crispy flaky crust...yes flaky. So good. Ordered an appetizer of mussels that was so good we dug into it before we could take a good photo. App came with homemade Italian bread which was so yummy. Bring cash or your ATM card as cash is King here...they do have an onsite ATM to withdraw money for dinner. Reservations are a must if coming on a Friday or Saturday night as the place is packed. Parking can be a challenge as this is clearly a neighborhood Tavern and Pizzeria. Highly recommend!!!
Frank Capasso
Pizza was good, service was good, but this is the second time the place stunk like a dirty bathroom nasty urine smell....
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 4
Marc G.
Great classic bar pizza. Hand rolled dough. Not too thick. Extra crispy. Not shy w the topping. I ordered for pick up and was told to "come to the back". I'm thinking to myself - what am I in for now? Turns out - super easy and it doesn't disturb the dine-in crowd which I actually love. Wish more places did it like that. Might be my new favorite bar pie in north jersey? Might have to take my regular date. I'm not sure she would appreciate the timeless interior decorating but I do.
Georgeann Vellis-Naclerio
Best pizza in the Tri-State area!Ask Dave Portnoy.....his final rating was 9.1- 9.2 and that's superior!I live in Delaware now and I'm looking so forward to going back to Jersey next week to see my family and plan on making reservations for Saturday night!!Btw....everything on the menu is delicious.???
Such a great place. Great vibe. Old world Italian charm. Felt like I was walking into a speakeasy. Tried the pizza and didn’t disappoint. It’s a well done pie hut not burnt. The cheese is cooked. The base of the slice is very firm and crispy. When you pick up the slice and hold it straight out, it stays firm. No flop. Turn it vertical and the cheese does not fall off at all. It’s exactly how we like pizza. Crispy. One large pie fed 2 men ok. Might need 2 :) very nice server too. Very attentive. Def make a reservation!Kid-friendliness: Lots of family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Issa W
Best Italian food in North Jersey. The hype is real.
It is one the best pies around and you have to go and enjoy the quality of the pie.. sauce crust cheese... always consistent! all so evenly prepared... dinners are solid as well.. order a pie as soon as u get there.. then review the menu for dinner!
Tonight I had the pleasure of trying and made my Patsy’s debut. Fantastic old school vibe and atmosphere. Came for the show stealer the pizza. Pizza is a very sacred thing to me, pizza is pizza but GREAT pizza is completely different. This one was FANTASTIC. I really enjoyed the large pie with a nice thin crust and well rounded kept together slices. I would get this pie every day if I could it was that good!Thanks again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is amazing! Crust so crispy and zero flop!
Food: 5
Found this neighborhood gem during COVID while doing a recommended pizza crawl. At the time there was no indoor dining because of COVID. While we had been twice during COVID this was our first time dining in. Quaint no frills ambience steeped in a lot of history. Don't think much has changed in many years other than the prices. Staff there is warm and inviting. What makes the pizza so good is the crispy flaky crust...yes flaky. So good. Ordered an appetizer of mussels that was so good we dug into it before we could take a good photo. App came with homemade Italian bread which was so yummy. Bring cash or your ATM card as cash is King here...they do have an onsite ATM to withdraw money for dinner. Reservations are a must if coming on a Friday or Saturday night as the place is packed. Parking can be a challenge as this is clearly a neighborhood Tavern and Pizzeria. Highly recommend!!!
Pizza was good, service was good, but this is the second time the place stunk like a dirty bathroom nasty urine smell....
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great classic bar pizza. Hand rolled dough. Not too thick. Extra crispy. Not shy w the topping. I ordered for pick up and was told to "come to the back". I'm thinking to myself - what am I in for now? Turns out - super easy and it doesn't disturb the dine-in crowd which I actually love. Wish more places did it like that. Might be my new favorite bar pie in north jersey? Might have to take my regular date. I'm not sure she would appreciate the timeless interior decorating but I do.
Best pizza in the Tri-State area!Ask Dave Portnoy.....his final rating was 9.1- 9.2 and that's superior!I live in Delaware now and I'm looking so forward to going back to Jersey next week to see my family and plan on making reservations for Saturday night!!Btw....everything on the menu is delicious.???
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rice Balls, Vodka Sauce, Antipasto, Stella Draft, Chicken Parmigiana, Half Pepperoni Pizza, Stuffed Artichoke
Only bad things are the small
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such a great place. Great vibe. Old world Italian charm. Felt like I was walking into a speakeasy. Tried the pizza and didn’t disappoint. It’s a well done pie hut not burnt. The cheese is cooked. The base of the slice is very firm and crispy. When you pick up the slice and hold it straight out, it stays firm. No flop. Turn it vertical and the cheese does not fall off at all. It’s exactly how we like pizza. Crispy. One large pie fed 2 men ok. Might need 2 :) very nice server too. Very attentive. Def make a reservation!Kid-friendliness: Lots of family
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Italian food in North Jersey. The hype is real.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Awesome place for pizza. Appetizers are delicious. Very friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Long Hots with Sausage & Potatoes, Mussels in Red Sauce, Garlic Bread, Rice Balls, Half Pepperoni Pizza
Legendary for a reason. Great pizza and atmosphere. Love this place. Get the long hots they'll blow the back of your head off..so hot.
Food was great!Service was great!The only reason you would go there!Went there for the pizza.Definitely worth the hype!!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garbage Pie
Best pizza anywhere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent!Better quality napkins would be appreciated ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Shrimp Fra Diablo, Rice Balls, Pepperoni Garlic and Hot Peppers Pizza, Specialty Pizza, Half Pepperoni Pizza