Pizza Man Trattoria Italiano

574 Newark Pompton Turnpike #5, Pompton Plains
(973) 835-3383

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Primo Bisbal

Picked up an order was leaking called back spoke to a manager a Spanish speaking woman said there’s nothing they can do. This is how you treat a customer that spends money you forgot to close the lid on tight and then you tell me there’s nothing you can do this place is horrible. Horrible customer service. Their manager is horrible food horrible all she had to do was say come back we will remake it or credit I would of been fine with remaking it but she was nasty ass he’ll and said nothing we could do and hung up the phone then I called right back like 4 times no answer every social media page will see this for the next couple of weeks sad how you have a manager like that it should be called attitude pizzeria

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

William Slootmaker

I would not recommend take out pizza, if you want pizza eat it in house. Tastes a lot better. Also lots of great Italian dishes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Raquel Ruiz

I can only speak for the pizza, it was hard to get through the slice. It wasn't good, maybe the ingredients? Reminded me of frozen pizza. The woman at the register was kind and friendly though.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Nancy Woodcock

Was there 10/6 for my wife’s birthday and the service was awful-staff was rude-had to go to counter to ask for plates, forks. Will never go back

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 1

Kim Rea

I have had mussels from from here many times. Excellent! Unfortunately the mussels were terrible today, so many did not open and the ones that did had nothing more than some "strings" in them, no actual mussel meat. Hopefully if we order again they will be worth it.

Food: 2

Patti M

Awesome team, amazing food, really nice neighborhood spot. Love it!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jack Atzmon

Excellent pesto pizza. WOW.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jason Giblin

ordered delivery, got two different anti pastas ( aka salads) didn't receive any dressings, so thats cool, after i called the dressing guy showed up, with four , maybe they were busy, i guess my order was fufilled but i would not order again things were just meh at best, plus 2 salads no dressing, so my review is not great

Food: 2

Lorrayne Robertson

Ordered for Mother’s Day. Outstanding quality food! More than enough !

Kid-friendliness: Outstanding choices for children too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Francese, Penne Vodka, Antipasto, Antipasto Salad

joey cai

The signature dish - Zuppa Di Pesce tastes so wonderful.The owners and team are friendly and lovely making the place a cozy and relaxing ambience for a great dinner. ??As a tourist, I'm here 2 nights consecutively for dinner. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Santa Lucia, Sauce, Zuppa Di Pesce

james luski

Been here a bunch of times. Today I ordered ahead the mother's day catering special. They accommodated my gluten free and dairy free needs. I got half tray of penne pomodoro, half tray of grilled chicken with peppers, onions and potatoes, a large house salad, broccoli rabe with sausage and a bag of dinner rolls. In total, it came to just over $88. Food was great, not heavy at all, fresh ingredients. There was a rude, obnoxious woman complaining about waiting for 30 minutes, causing a scene. But to be fair, I waited almost 40 minutes, and there were 7 other people waiting too. They were slammed being a holiday with several catering orders.

Vegetarian options: Pizza, apps, and more

Parking: Share parking for all shops in the plaza

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Large House Salad, Cheese Pizza

Robert Tarlo

I used to frequent this establishment 40 years ago. They still had the dish that I craved for. Said they still used the same menu. Did not meet the satisfaction I had remembered. Short changed me on a Calzone on my order. NEVER AGAIN.

Food: 2

Service: 4

Panayiotis Tsitouras

Very nice food at reasonable prices. Superb service. Standard small restaurant atmosphere. Overall a positive experience.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 5

Alexis Paliotta

We recently had our sons 5th birthday party rock n roll theme with classmates and cousins here. We couldn't have been more impressed with everything from the kids making their own pizzas to the service and food. Thanks to Al and Sam for going above and beyond and were such a pleasure to work with. The kids and parents had a blast & our son said he had a super awesome time! Definitely recommend Pizza Man for parties and food. I'm sure we will be back! ☺️

Tony Vaccaro31

The best Rigatoni vodka with (grilled chicken and added mozz cheese) in the world!! Highly recommend! Pizza was fantastic too! Thank you so much!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...