Stefano's Pizzeria
569 NJ-23, Pompton Plains
(973) 616-6620
Customers' Favorites
Stuffed Artichoke Best Stuffed Artichoke in the Town
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Large
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Eggplant Rollatini
Linguine Bolognese
Specialty Slice
Seafood Luciano
Sicilian Pizza
Cannoli to Go
APPETIZERS
Garlic Knots ( 12 Pieces )
Fresh made daily with our handmade pizza dough fresh baked and seasoned with garlic, olive oil ,parm cheese and Italian seasoning serve with side marinara sauce
Buffalo Wings (10 count )
Bone in large wing fried to perfection top with your favorite wing sauce and serve with blue cheese or ranch
Buffalo Wings ( 5 count )
Bone in large wing fried to perfection top with your favorite wing sauce and serve with blue cheese or ranch
Stuffed Artichoke
Stuffed with Seasoned Italian Breadcrumbs,Parmesan Cheese,Olive Oil &Garlic Fresh Tomatoes and Olives
Fried Calamari
Fresh Calamari lightly dusted in flour fried to perfection golden brown and extra crispy serve with marinara sauce in the side and fresh lemon
Mac and Cheese Balls
Fresh Mac and cheese ball lightly breaded fried to perfection serve with side marinara sauce
Italian Rice Balls (Arancini )
Fresh made Italian risotto ball stuffed with meat sauce ,green peas, mozzarella lightly breaded fried to perfection serve with side marinara sauce
Mozzarella Sticks (6 pieces )
Breaded mozzarella sticks italian seasoning fried to perfection serve with side marinara
Jalapeno Poppers (6 pieces )
Jalapeños poppers stuffed with cheddar cheese fried to perfection serve with side sauce
Large French Fries
Fried to perfection serve with ketcup
Garlic Bread
Fresh Italian loaf of bread fresh garlic,Italian seasoning ,parmigiano regiano baked to perfection
Garlic Bread with Cheese
Fresh Italian loaf of bread fresh garlic,Italian seasoning ,parmigiano regiano ,melted mozzarella baked to perfection
Fresh Mozzarella Roasted Peppers Tomatoes Salad
Fresh cut slices tomatoes fresh mozzarella roasted red peppers over a bed of mix greens with balsamic vinegar and olive oil
Hot Antipasto
Shrimp and clams originator, stuffed peppers and mushrooms, mussels and fried calmari.
Clams Oreganato (6 pieces)
Fresh little neck clams stuffed with Italian seasoning breadcrumbs white wine lemon baked to perfection
Red Mussels
New Zealand mussels marinara sauce
White Mussels
New Zealand Mussels ,White wine Lemon Sauce
PIZZA
Small Spicy Pepperoni Duo
Red sauce ,mozzarella 2 kinds of Pepperoni -Classic and Mini spicy cups
Small Cheese Pizza
Red Pizza Sauce Mozzarella
Small White Pizza
Ricotta,Mozzarella,Parmesan
Small Bruschetta Pizza
Fresh Chopped Plum Tomato ,Fresh Mozzarella,Basil
Small Triesta Pizza
Pizza Sauce ,Mozzarella Breaded Chicken Cutlets,Roasted Red Peppers
Small Stefano Special Pizza
Red Pizza Sauce ,Mozzarella,Pepperoni,Sausage ,Meatballs,Broccoli, Spinach,Tomato,Olives ,Onions,Peppers
Small Dolce Pizza
Grilled Portabella mushrooms, roasted red peppers, fresh Mozzarella balsamic glaze.
Small Magherita Pizza
Fresh Plum Tomatoes,Fresh Mozzarella,Basil
Small Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Breaded Chicken , Bacon ,Mozzarella, Housemade Ranch
Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo Chicken ,Mozzarella ,Buffalo Hot Sauce
Small Chicken Francese Pie
Fresh Chicken ,Mozzarella,White Wine Lenon,Francese Sauce
Small Chicken Marsala Pie
Fresh Chicken ,Mozzarella, Mushrooms, Marsala Wine Sauce
Small Pie Veggetables
Peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives, spinach, broccoli, fresh tomatoes.
Calzone
Add topping for an additional charge. Ricotta and bacio mozzarella.
Stromboli
Pizza Dough,Mozzarella,Side Sauce
Large Spicy Pepperoni Duo
Red sauce ,mozzarella 2 kinds of Pepperoni-Classic and Mini spicy cups
Large Cheese Pizza
Red Pizza Sauce Mozzarella
Large White Pizza
Ricotta,Mozzarella,Parmesan
Large Stefano Special Pizza
Red Pizza Sauce ,Mozzarella,Pepperoni,Sausage ,Meatballs,Broccoli, Spinach,Tomato,Olives ,Onions,Peppers
Large Bruschetta Pizza
Fresh chopped tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil.
Large Triesta Pizza
Pizza Sauce ,Mozzarella Breaded Chicken Cutlets,Roasted Red Peppers
Genovese Pizza
Thin crust square pie with grilled chicken, pesto sauce, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers and arugula.
Large Dolce Pizza
Grilled portabella mushrooms, roasted red pappers, fresh mozzarella balsamic glaze.
Large Pie Chicken Francese
Fresh Chicken ,Mozzarella,White Wine Lenon,Francese Sauce
Large Pizza Chicken Marsala
Fresh Chicken ,Mozzarella, Mushrooms, Marsala Wine Sauce
Large Pizza Buffalo Chicken
Buffalo Chicken ,Mozzarella ,Buffalo Hot Sauce
Large Veggies Pizza
Peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives, spinach, broccoli, and fresh tomatoes.
Sicilian Pizza
Thick Crust ,Red Pizza Sauce ,Mozzarella
Margarita Square Pizza
Fresh Plum Tomatoes,Fresh Mozzarella,Basil
Napolitana Pie
Thin crust square pie, vodka sauce, Buffalo mozzarella.
Large Meatlovers Pizza
Roni, sausage, meatballs and bacon.
Large Pizza Chicken Bacon Ranch
Breaded Chicken , Bacon ,Mozzarella, Housemade Ranch
Large Chicken Parm Pizza
Red Sauce ,Breaded Chicken,Mozzarella
Large Pizza Broccoli Rabe and Sausage
Italian Sausage,Broccoli Rabe ,Mozzarella
Large BBQ Chicken Pizza
Barbecue Chicken ,Barbecue Sauce,Mozzarella
Large Cheesesteak Pizza with Peppers and Onions
Philly Steak ,peppers,onions,mozzarella,yellow American cheese
COMBOS
SLICE PIZZA COMBO ( CAESAR,MIX GREENS OR FRENCH FRIES)
Any slices and choice of (1 )mix green salad,Caesar salad or Fries.
SANDWICH COMBO
Choice any sandwich (1 )mix green salad ,Caesar salad or Fries
SALADS
Fig Salad
Stuffed figs with goat cheese ,wrapped in prosciutto over arugula & endive with fresh mango
Tossed Salad
Mix greens ,tomatoes,red onions, cucumbers , olives ,croutons
Cold Antipasto Salad
Mix greens ,tomato , cucumbers ,olives ,red onions ,hot peppers ,croutons, Ham ,Salami Provalone rolled up and cut in thin slices
Chef's Salad
Mix greens ,tomato,red onions ,olives , croutons hard boiled egg ,ham ,turkey,provolone ,yellow American cheese
Caesar Salad
Fresh Cut Romaine Lettuce Homemade Croutons and Caesar Dressing
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Fresh Cut Romaine Lettuce Homemade Croutons Grilled Chicken and Caesar Dressing
Grilled Chicken Salad
Mix greens ,tomato ,red onion,cucumbers, olives croutons Grilled chicken
Arugula Salad
Fresh Arugula ,Fresh Tomato Red Onions served with balsamic vinegar and olive oil
Spinach Salad
Fresh baby spinach ,fresh mushrooms, bacon and hard boiled egg
Tri Color Pasta with Veg Salad
Tricolore pasta rotini with mix vegetables and house made Italian dressing
Tuna Salad Platter
Mix greens , tomato ,red onions ,olives , 3 scoops tuna salad
Calamari Salad
Fresh steam and chid Calamari thin slices red onions, celery ,grape tomato serve over mix greens olive oil lemon dressing
Mesculin and Endive Salad
Mix greens ,fresh oranges ,goat cheese ,dried cranberries & raspberry vinaigrette
Tuscany Salad
Grilled portobello ,chicken ,feta cheese ,arugula,tomatoes & balsamic vinaigrette
3 Color Lettuce Salad
Fresh Arugula, Endives and Radicio serve with balsamic vinegar and olive oil
SOUPS
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Cannellini Italian beans ,pastini tube pasta ,tomato broth
Tortellini in Brodo Soup
Chicken Broth ,tortellini,fresh parsley
Spinach Soup
Chicken Broth,Fresh Spinach,Parmesan Cheese drop Egg
French Onion Soup
Caramelized onions ,rich beef broth ,homemade croutons,melted mozzarella and provolone
COLD SANDWICHES
Ham, Salami, and Provolone Sub 7"
Lettuce, Tomatoes,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar & Olive Oil
Ham, Salami, Capicola, and Provolone Sub 7"
Lettuce, Tomatoes,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar & Olive Oil
Prosci, Capicola, Salami, and Provolone Sub 7"
Lettuce, Tomatoes,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar & Olive Oil
Turkey Sub 7"
Lettuce, Tomatoes,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar & Olive Oil
Tuna Sub 7"
Lettuce, Tomatoes,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar & Olive Oil
Chicken Cutlet Sub 7"
Lettuce, Tomatoes,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar & Olive Oil
Grilled Chicken Sub 7"
Lettuce, Tomatoes,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar & Olive Oil
HOT SANDWICHES
VEAL AND PEPPERS SUB 7"
Tender veal slices Italian green peppers fresh plum tomato basil melted provolone
Veal Parm Sub 7"
Breaded Veal Cutlet,Marinara and Mozzarella
Chicken Parmigiana Sub 7"
Breaded Chicken Cutlet,Marinara Sauce ,Mozzarella
Eggplant Parm Sub 7"
Breaded Eggplant,Marinara Sauce,Mozzarella
Meatball Parm Sub 7"
Homemade Meatballs,Marinara Sauce,Mozzarella
Meatball Sub 7"
Homemade Meatballs,Marinara Sauce
Sausage Parm Sub 7"
Italian Sausage,Marinara Sauce,Mozzarella
Sausage Peppers Onions Sub 7"
Italian Sausage,Peppers, Onions,Marinara
Pepegg Sub 7"
Grilled Peppers,Eggs
Cheesesteak Sub 7"
Philly style steak ,peppers onion ,yellow American cheese
SPECIALTY SANDWICHES
The Slick Chick 7"
Grilled Chicken,Fresh Mozzarella,Roasted Red Peppers,Lettuce,Tomato,Balsamic Vinegar and Olive Oil
The Shushuline 7"
Breaded Chicken Cutlet ,Bacon,Prosciutto,Melted Provalone,Lettuce, Tomato, Onion Garlic Mayo
Old Blue Eyes Special 7"
Fresh Mozzarella,Roasted Red Peppers, Olive Oil
The Rat Pack Special 7"
Prosciutto,Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers,Sundried Tomato,Olive Oil
The 88 Magnum Special 7"
Ham, Salami,Provalone,Cappicola,Prosciutto.Fresh Mozzarella,Roasted Red Peppers,Lettuce ,Tomato ,Onion ,Garlic Sauce
WRAPS
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled Chicken ,Romain Lettuce,Caesar Dressing
Tuna Wrap
Tuna Salad ,Lettuce , Tomatoes,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar and Olive Oil
Turkey Wrap
Turkey ,Lettuce , Tomato,Onions,Balsamic Vinegar and Olive Oil
Philly Cheesesteak Wrap
Philly style steak ,Peppers,Onions
Veggie Wrap Special
Grilled Zucchini,Portabello Mushroom,Roasted Red Peppers,Eggplant ,Fresh Mozzarella,Balsamic Vinegar &Olive Oil
CHICKEN
CHICKEN FRANCHISE LUNCH
Battered chicken breast,pan fried to golden brown white wine lemon sauce
CHICKEN PARMIGIANA LUNCH
Breaded Chicken Cutlet,Marinara,Mozzarella Baked in the Oven
CHICKEN MARSALA LUNCH
Sautéed breast of chicken,mushrooms,Marsala wine sauce
CHICKEN CACCIATORE LUNCH
Sauted chicken, peppers, onions and mushrooms in lite red sauce.
CHICKEN SORENTINO LUNCH
Sautéed breast of chicken,topped with prosciutto,eggplant,mozzarella red sauce
CHICKEN SCARPARIELLO LUNCH
Sautéed breast of chicken,mushrooms,olives ,garlic,white wine lemon sauce
PASTA
PASTA VODKA LUNCH
Vodka ,Creamy tomato Sauce
PASTA BOLOGNESE LUNCH
Meat Sauce ,Recommend with Homemade Pappardelle Pasta
PASTA OIL AND GARLIC LUNCH
PASTA MARINARA LUNCH
Stefanos Marinara,Basil
LINGUINE RED CLAMS SAUCE LUNCH
Fresh Little Neck Clams ,Olive Oil & Garlic ,Red Sauce ,Basil
LINGUINE WHITE CLAMS SAUCE LUNCH
Fresh Little Neck Clams ,Olive Oil & Garlic
CAVATELLI AND BROCCOLI LUNCH
Cavatelli pasta fresh broccoli, fresh tomatoes,Olive &Oil and Garlic
RAVIOLI MARINARA LUNCH
Ravioli ,Marinara
PASTA ALFREDO LUNCH
BAKED DISHES
LASAGNA LUNCH
Fresh Pasta Sheets ,Meat Sauce ,Ricotta ,Baked with Mozzarella
MANICOTTI LUNCH
Tube Pasta Stuffed With Ricotta Cheese,Marinara,Melted Mozzarella
BAKED ZITI WITH RICOTTA LUNCH
Ziti Marinara ,Ricotta,Mozzarella,Baked In the Oven
BAKED RAVIOLIS LUNCH
Ravioli's,Marinara Sauce,Melted Mozzarella
EGGPLANT PARM LUNCH
Breaded Eggplant,Marinara,Mozzarella,Baked in the Oven
EGGPLANT ROLLATINI LUNCH
Stuffed Eggplant with Ricotta,Prosciutto,Marinara,Mozzarella,Baked in the Oven
SAUSAGE PARM LUNCH
Italian Sausage,Marinara, Mozzarella Baked in the Oven
MEATBALL PARM LUNCH
Homemade Meatballs, Marinara, Mozzarella Baked in the Oven
SAUSAGE PEPPERS ONIONS LUNCH
Italian Sausage,Green Peppers,Marinara
STUFFED SHELLS LUNCH
Stuffed shells with ricotta cheese ,marinara and melted mozzarella baked in the oven
VEAL
Veal Parm
Breaded Veal Cutlet ,Marinara,Mozzarella Baked in the Oven
Veal Francese
Veal Scalopini Egg Buttered,White wine lemon sauce
Veal Marsala
Veal Scalopini Sauted ,Fresh Mushrooms,Marsala wine sauce
Veal Piccata
Veal Scalopini Sautéed,Capers,Lemon White Wine
Veal Sorrentina
Veal Scalopini Sautéed,Topped With Prosciutto,Eggplant,Melted Mozzarella,Red Sauce
Veal Saltimbocca
Veal Scalopini Sautéed,Topped With Prosciutto,Sauted Spinach,Melted Mozzarella,Sherry Wine Sauce
Veal Lorenzo Special
Sautéed Veal Scalopini,peppers,onions,mushrooms,potatoes white wine
VEAL AND PEPPERS SPECIAL LUNCH
Tender veal Italian green peppers fresh plum tomatoes basil over Italian risotto
VEAL FRANCHISE LUNCH
Veal Scalopini Egg Buttered,White wine lemon sauce
VEAL PARM LUNCH
Breaded Veal Cutlet ,Marinara,Mozzarella Baked in the Oven
VEAL MARSALA LUNCH
Veal Scalopini Sauted ,Fresh Mushrooms,Marsala wine sauce
VEAL SORRENTINO LUNCH
Veal Scalopini Sautéed,Topped With Prosciutto,Eggplant,Melted Mozzarella,Red Sauce
SEAFOOD
Shrimp and Arugula Special
Fresh Chopped Tomato,Baby Arugula,Shrimp Olive Oil & Garlic
Shrimp and Broccoli
Jumbo Shrimp ,Fresh Broccoli,Grape tomatoes,Olive Oil and Garlic served over linguine
Shrimp Marinara
Jumbo Shrimp ,Fresh Plum Tomatoes,Marinara,Basil served over Linguine
Shrimp Francese
Jumbo shrimp egg buttered golden pan seared white wine lemon
Shrimp Scampi
Jumbo Shrimp lightly dusted in flour Sauted in the pan fresh garlic ,white wine lemon served over linguine
Shrimp Parm
Jumbo Shrimp Breaded in Italian breadcrumbs,Golden Fried ,Marinara Sauce ,Mozzarella Baked in the Oven
Flounder Francese
Fresh Flounder Egg Buttered Panfried ,lemon white wine sauce
Broiled Flounder
Fresh Flounder Broiled in the Oven ,Seasoned Italian breadcrumbs,white wine lemon sauce
Flounder Marinara
Fresh Flounder,Fresh plum tomatoes,Marinara,Basil
Calamari Marinara
Fresh Calamari ,Fresh Plum Tomatoes,Marinara,Basil,served over linguine
Mussels Marinara
New Zealand mussels marinara
Linguine Marchiara
Shrimp ,Clams,Mussels,Calamari,Salmon ,Fresh Plum Tomato Marinara ,Basil served over Linguine
Seafood Luciano Special
Clams,Mussels,Shrimp,Calamari,Salmon over Linguine creamy sherry wine sauce
3 Amici Special
Chicken,Veal,Shrimp Francese Style over Linguine white wine lemon sauce
LINGUINE MARECHIARA LUNCH
Shrimp ,Clams,Mussels,Calamari,Salmon ,Fresh Plum Tomato Marinara ,Basil served over Linguine
SHRIMP MARINARA LUNCH
Jumbo Shrimp ,Fresh Plum Tomatoes,Marinara,Basil served over Linguine
SHRIMP AND BROCCOLI LUNCH
Jumbo Shrimp ,Fresh Broccoli,Grape tomatoes,Olive Oil and Garlic served over linguine
SHRIMP SCAMPI LUNCH
Jumbo Shrimp lightly dusted in flour Sauted in the pan fresh garlic ,white wine lemon served over linguine
CALAMARI MARINARA LUNCH
Fresh Calamari ,Fresh Plum Tomatoes,Marinara,Basil,served over linguine
DESSERTS
Homemade Cannoli
Specialty Cannoli
Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Tartufo
Almond Cake
KIDS MENU
Kid Hamburger
Kid Cheeseburger
Kid Chix Fing with Fry
Kid Pasta Dish
SIDES
Side Sauteed Broccoli
Side Sauteed Broccoli Rabe
Side Sausage
Side Meatballs
Small French Fries
Small Salad
Side Chicken Cutlet
Side Grilled Chicken
Side sautéed spinach
Fresh baby spinach olive oil and garlic
Beverages
Soda
Fountain Soda
Lipton
Water
2 Liter Soda
Coffee
Cappuccino
Espresso
Photos
+51 photos
+50 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We had our staff holiday party at Stefano’s in January and it was excellent. Steve was easy to contact, and actually booking was a breeze. They made accommodations for our staff that have diet restrictions and made sure everyone had something yummy to eat! They were attentive in service, ensuring that there was enough food and soft drinks for everyone. This was our second party here, and we will certainly be considering them for more staff events in the future.
Thanks so much!
February 2026
From the moment we arrived, the service was exceptional. Every staff member was welcoming, attentive, and made sure we felt comfortable throughout our visit. The timing was perfect—our drinks and food arrived without delay, and any special requests were handled smoothly. As for the food, it was absolutely outstanding. Each dish was full of flavor, beautifully presented, and clearly made with high-quality ingredients. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, making the entire experience...
April 2025
I never write reviews but after so many years of being a regular for our household I figured it’s necessary. We absolutely love Stefano’s and have always been satisfied. From the pizza slices, the dinners, pastries and you can’t forget the amazing gelato. Accross the board they have been a weekly stop for us. Always accommodating even when we know it was difficult to fit us in. The foods always fresh and tastes amazing! Oh and the espresso too!!!
Kid-friendliness:...
Kid-friendliness:...
March 2025
You May Also Like
Stefano's Restaurant - 565 NJ-23
![]()
Fine Dining, Italian, Venues & Event Spaces, Pizza, Vegetarian
Dunkin' - 560 NJ-23
![]()
Coffee Shops, Donuts, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Just Salad - 500 NJ-23
![]()
Salad, Wraps, Juice Bar & Smoothies