Always on point and great food. Affordable, tasty, and quick when delivered.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jyunior
Delicious, I feel like the cheese has herbs in it already. Pizza sauce is flavorful not too saucy if they can improve on the texture and taste of the dough/crust it’s a perfect 10. I appreciate their fast delivery too 🍕🏎️ 8/10 ⭐️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aciya Dillard
Food was great!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamie Lewis
I placed an order through uber eats. The total bill for a lg pepperoni pizza and 2 garlic sticks plus 10 dollar tip was 60 dollars. The only problem I had was I never got the lg pepperoni pizza. There garlic sticks are awesome. I can’t tell you about the pizza because I never got it. This was going to be my first Otto’s Pizza I was excited to see what all the hype was about. I don’t know if the Uber driver stole it or Otto’s never gave it to them.
Food: 5
Jairo
Fast delivery, good phone courtesy and patience. AMAZING WINGS (mango habanero)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Blanca Mercado
Pizza is delicious! Chicken cheesesteak was yummy! Nice people! Definitely on the list of local spots now. Check out Otto’s.
Sam “The Carpet Man” Ghanim
Most delicious red sauce I have ever tasted! Their pizza is delicious! Thank you. 😊
Ivette perez
This is the best, most flavorful pizza around!!! I've also had the chicken Caesar wraps/salads/wings... also FANTASTIC!! Basically everything here tastes awesome!
Ed Merced
Food is simply incredible—especially pizza! You can’t beat the deliciousness of a classic Margarita pizza; it’s nothing short of extraordinary! And let’s not forget the fantastic service that makes the experience even better!
First Name
Their pizza used to be good. We’ve been getting pies here for several years, but the past 3 times were awful. The pizza was definitely not fresh. It was stale, dry, and overcooked. The edges of the crust were burnt to a crisp, and it tasted as though had been sitting around all day.
At first I did not know this place existed in 2022 until I tried it 2 years later and which it tasted great! The place is not small nor large but has a great area, the wait is not long and the pizza is hot and crispy and flavorful, there is also not much you have to pay for them and their close to my house so you know I can just snag one of their pies, and you can see how their pies are made which there very fresh and natural and everyone that is there is super nice and happy, guys get up from your couch and try this place please, trust me, your gonna love it! (pictures coming soon)
Parking: It’s in plaza which has lots of parking so it’s easy to find
Kid-friendliness: Well it’s a pizza place, it has flatbread which a little kid could possibly eat and does not have stuff to knock over
Just moved to Piscataway Otto’s pizza is by far the best we’ve had and we have tried a few 😩 haha Can’t wait to try the rest of their menu items ! 😄
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie with Pepperoni
Miguel Camacho
Luv the Italian chicken cheese steak, Caesar salad with chicken or shrimp. Great customer service. I have been a customer since almost day one.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Meyer
Incredible food, from pastA, to piZza and everything around and between, customer service the family way, and an abundance of kindness, if you not only want to taste; rather FEEL a meal, Otto’s is the way to go
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Courtney Forman
I’ve been living in Plainfield for years so I can confidently say Otto’s has the best pizza out here!! It’s also a welcoming environment with excellent customer service!! I never ever leave reviews but felt as a pizza lover it was necessary that I share this update!! #Ferraro’s lost a customer!!
Always on point and great food. Affordable, tasty, and quick when delivered.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious, I feel like the cheese has herbs in it already. Pizza sauce is flavorful not too saucy if they can improve on the texture and taste of the dough/crust it’s a perfect 10. I appreciate their fast delivery too 🍕🏎️ 8/10 ⭐️
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was great!
Food: 5
Service: 5
I placed an order through uber eats. The total bill for a lg pepperoni pizza and 2 garlic sticks plus 10 dollar tip was 60 dollars. The only problem I had was I never got the lg pepperoni pizza. There garlic sticks are awesome. I can’t tell you about the pizza because I never got it. This was going to be my first Otto’s Pizza I was excited to see what all the hype was about. I don’t know if the Uber driver stole it or Otto’s never gave it to them.
Food: 5
Fast delivery, good phone courtesy and patience. AMAZING WINGS (mango habanero)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza is delicious! Chicken cheesesteak was yummy! Nice people! Definitely on the list of local spots now. Check out Otto’s.
Most delicious red sauce I have ever tasted! Their pizza is delicious! Thank you. 😊
This is the best, most flavorful pizza around!!! I've also had the chicken Caesar wraps/salads/wings... also FANTASTIC!! Basically everything here tastes awesome!
Food is simply incredible—especially pizza! You can’t beat the deliciousness of a classic Margarita pizza; it’s nothing short of extraordinary! And let’s not forget the fantastic service that makes the experience even better!
Their pizza used to be good. We’ve been getting pies here for several years, but the past 3 times were awful. The pizza was definitely not fresh. It was stale, dry, and overcooked. The edges of the crust were burnt to a crisp, and it tasted as though had been sitting around all day.
Restaurantji Recommends
At first I did not know this place existed in 2022 until I tried it 2 years later and which it tasted great! The place is not small nor large but has a great area, the wait is not long and the pizza is hot and crispy and flavorful, there is also not much you have to pay for them and their close to my house so you know I can just snag one of their pies, and you can see how their pies are made which there very fresh and natural and everyone that is there is super nice and happy, guys get up from your couch and try this place please, trust me, your gonna love it! (pictures coming soon)
Parking: It’s in plaza which has lots of parking so it’s easy to find
Kid-friendliness: Well it’s a pizza place, it has flatbread which a little kid could possibly eat and does not have stuff to knock over
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Marinara Sauce, Garlic Bread, Lasagna, Mozzarella Sticks, Plain Slice, Vodka Sauce, Flatbread, Margarita Pizza, White Pizza with Grilled Chicken, Cannoli
Just moved to Piscataway
Otto’s pizza is by far the best we’ve had and we have tried a few 😩 haha
Can’t wait to try the rest of their menu items ! 😄
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie with Pepperoni
Luv the Italian chicken cheese steak, Caesar salad with chicken or shrimp. Great customer service. I have been a customer since almost day one.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible food, from pastA, to piZza and everything around and between, customer service the family way, and an abundance of kindness, if you not only want to taste; rather FEEL a meal, Otto’s is the way to go
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I’ve been living in Plainfield for years so I can confidently say Otto’s has the best pizza out here!! It’s also a welcoming environment with excellent customer service!! I never ever leave reviews but felt as a pizza lover it was necessary that I share this update!! #Ferraro’s lost a customer!!
Loading...