Take away service doesn't match the food. Ordered placed and “ the computer was down” so there's an additional 1/2 wait—- following visit, online order placed- call made to make sure it was received —- pizza not started when we arrive. It’s a shame. Great food, makes the price tolerable, but the low quality preparedness and long wait once you arrive is disappointing. “ we don't like to put the pizza in until you get here.”
Then why place an order online?
🤔
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Alexa St.Clair
Best pizza in SJ
Calisa
This food was horrible ! BBQ pizza was rough over cooked .. nasty .. wings was so burnt dry and over cooked .. calamari was nasty!! I’m sorry I didn’t take a picture bc I tossed it out. How do you knowingly see burnt black over cooked chicken and still sell it .. shame on you .. for this .. don’t eat here ! Food nasty over cooked ! Don’t waste your money .
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Ritzie
Perhaps the best Caesar salad I ever had..pizza too was exceptional...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick St Germain Jr
There is no doubt that high-quality ingredients are being used here. The flavor profiles they aim for are thoughtful and heading in the right direction. However, where the experience falls short is in the balance and portioning of toppings what was provided felt minimal. Given this, I can understand why some may consider the offerings to be overpriced.
Service was prompt in taking my order upon arrival, which I appreciated. However, I was not offered a place to sit while I waited and ended up sitting outside in 95-degree heat. Meanwhile, several staff members were gathered around the POS system appearing unoccupied. After about 20 minutes, I returned inside to find my order sitting on a rack, cooling. This lack of attentiveness from the staff left a poor impression.
Lastly, while subjective, I personally found the overall layout and atmosphere of the establishment to be uninviting. The setup did not contribute to a comfortable or welcoming dining experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 3
Arielle
We had a 6 pm reservation and waited standing by the door for 30 minutes. We had no where to stand, we were in everyone's way. We then were seated and our food took 40 minutes and people that were sat after us got their food before us. We had to eat the food fast to make it to the show.
Rita
We had a great experience! Second time going before a Broadway pitman play, works perfect. Slightly pricey To some but I thought reasonable. Staff is wonderful and attentive. Great experiences. Food is delicious
Theresa
Always fantastic service when we are there. Staff is always friendly and professional. Food is delicious! Highly recommend! Thank you!
Antonio Perez
Food is good, but over priced. Place seems to be prejudice. I've been made to feel very uncomfortable while dinning here on more than one occasion. Even witnessed them give me & my black family different dishes. When I asked about it (politely) the waiter became rude and defensive. I'd never said anything about it in the past thinking it was a once or twice type of thing. Happened multiple times. Its 2025... we should be able to eat anywhere we like.
The pizza is beyond compare! Look forward to getting it every time I have a show at the Pitman Theater!
Suzanne Capece
We love coming here for pizza! Wood fire cooking is so much tastier and I love the boardwalk pie and frutti di mare seafood medley.
There can be a wait, so I recommend calling ahead if you're able to, and sitting outside is always a great option if the weather is nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
j
Pizza is ok. A little on the pricier side for what you get. Make sure to have the staff clarify what's on the pizza as they don't list all of the toppings they put on and it took us by surprise.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Tammy Rowe
Ordered Rustica and was not disappointed. Pizza crust was perfect, crispy, and amazing. The best Tiramisu I have ever had. I was also able to order a bottle from local winery. I enjoyed watching them prepare the food also. It was like dinner and a show.
Best margarita pizza ever!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Take away service doesn't match the food. Ordered placed and “ the computer was down” so there's an additional 1/2 wait—- following visit, online order placed- call made to make sure it was received —- pizza not started when we arrive. It’s a shame. Great food, makes the price tolerable, but the low quality preparedness and long wait once you arrive is disappointing. “ we don't like to put the pizza in until you get here.”
Then why place an order online?
🤔
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Best pizza in SJ
This food was horrible ! BBQ pizza was rough over cooked .. nasty .. wings was so burnt dry and over cooked .. calamari was nasty!! I’m sorry I didn’t take a picture bc I tossed it out. How do you knowingly see burnt black over cooked chicken and still sell it .. shame on you .. for this .. don’t eat here ! Food nasty over cooked ! Don’t waste your money .
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Perhaps the best Caesar salad I ever had..pizza too was exceptional...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There is no doubt that high-quality ingredients are being used here. The flavor profiles they aim for are thoughtful and heading in the right direction. However, where the experience falls short is in the balance and portioning of toppings what was provided felt minimal. Given this, I can understand why some may consider the offerings to be overpriced.
Service was prompt in taking my order upon arrival, which I appreciated. However, I was not offered a place to sit while I waited and ended up sitting outside in 95-degree heat. Meanwhile, several staff members were gathered around the POS system appearing unoccupied. After about 20 minutes, I returned inside to find my order sitting on a rack, cooling. This lack of attentiveness from the staff left a poor impression.
Lastly, while subjective, I personally found the overall layout and atmosphere of the establishment to be uninviting. The setup did not contribute to a comfortable or welcoming dining experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 3
We had a 6 pm reservation and waited standing by the door for 30 minutes. We had no where to stand, we were in everyone's way. We then were seated and our food took 40 minutes and people that were sat after us got their food before us. We had to eat the food fast to make it to the show.
We had a great experience! Second time going before a Broadway pitman play, works perfect. Slightly pricey To some but I thought reasonable. Staff is wonderful and attentive. Great experiences. Food is delicious
Always fantastic service when we are there. Staff is always friendly and professional. Food is delicious! Highly recommend! Thank you!
Food is good, but over priced. Place seems to be prejudice. I've been made to feel very uncomfortable while dinning here on more than one occasion. Even witnessed them give me & my black family different dishes. When I asked about it (politely) the waiter became rude and defensive. I'd never said anything about it in the past thinking it was a once or twice type of thing. Happened multiple times. Its 2025... we should be able to eat anywhere we like.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza is beyond compare! Look forward to getting it every time I have a show at the Pitman Theater!
We love coming here for pizza! Wood fire cooking is so much tastier and I love the boardwalk pie and frutti di mare seafood medley.
There can be a wait, so I recommend calling ahead if you're able to, and sitting outside is always a great option if the weather is nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Pizza is ok. A little on the pricier side for what you get. Make sure to have the staff clarify what's on the pizza as they don't list all of the toppings they put on and it took us by surprise.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 4
Ordered Rustica and was not disappointed. Pizza crust was perfect, crispy, and amazing. The best Tiramisu I have ever had. I was also able to order a bottle from local winery. I enjoyed watching them prepare the food also. It was like dinner and a show.
Peak pizza for all the guys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...