Randy's Homemade Ice Cream

Friendly staff, great homemade ice cream . Clean nice atmosphere. Giving free chocolate bars at least the week of 7/24/2025 for paying customers.

As a local this place is the real deal! I always pass by, but never walk in. I see the long lines and I'm wondering why are there always long lines. Well now I know the ice cream is out of this world.

Quick service! Great prices! And you get the bang for your buck. For eight bucks I got this huge cup of ice cream. It was absolutely amazing especially on a hot day. The two guys working, they were super friendly and super helpful, and I asked them if they had caramel and they offered all their caramel selections. Definitely try the Milky Way caramel out of this world delicious.

So happy to enjoy homemade ice cream made by a local business in town absolutely great work guys!

Staff was very disrespectful and rude not friendly whats so ever they didn’t care about they’re customers it’s expensive and it’s not even good I was asked 3 times what I wanted they don’t listen I wouldn’t recommend this place to my worst enemy honestly

Best ice cream around. Creamy and delicious with fresh ingredients. It’s always exciting to try the new flavors. The hardest part about going to Randy’s is deciding which flavor to get next. In addition to great ice cream the employees are all friendly. Prices are fair.

The ice cream was good but don't be expected to be welcomed with a smile.

I loved my ice cream! It was so good and the animal cracker on top gives it the perfect crunch and great flavor!

Fresh and delicious. Best ice cream we’ve tried in NJ!

Great place and lots of flavors! Highly recommend

Randy and team make the best ice cream in Jersey. The most unique and outrageous flavors, and every one of them is great. Don’t bother going anywhere else.

Excellent quality ice cream, interesting flavor selection, and pup cups for the dog (she loved it).

I’ve been searching for real homemade ice cream in the area, and I finally struck gold. I’m mad it took me years to come across this gem. This place is SOOOOOO good. Like 1000000/10 good…and yes, I consider myself a seasoned food critic (with elite taste buds) 😅. I tried the lemon poppy seed and pure Vermont maple syrup—both were next-level delicious. I even got a grow a pear 🍐 flavor to take home and my husband and son ate it all before we even got home 🤣. Every flavor is handcrafted in small batches using real milk and real quality ingredients. Not junk. You can taste the goodness and the owner takes pride in all his flavors bc HE makes them ! Not some franchise vendor or uncle Sam’s farm in PA.

I even told the owner I’d be telling all my crunchy mom friends about this place—because finding ice cream that isn’t made with weird chemicals and fake junk is a rare find these days.

Absolutely fantastic ice cream, my favorite in the state. Randy's a great guy as well!

Randy’s Homemade Ice Cream offers amazing ice cream and outstanding customer service—truly a great experience all around!

Best Ice Cream in town!

Love this place, can’t wait for them to re open !