Randy's Homemade Ice Cream
322 Wanaque Ave suite d, Pompton Lakes
(973) 590-9111
Customers' Favorites
Cookie Monster Ice Cream
Strawberry
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Likely the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Got carrot cake and it was just like eating carrot cake but in ice cream form. Lots of great options on the menu to choose from. Very inviting spot and wish I lived near by to try all the flavors.
Always on the lookout for delicious homemade ice cream and Randy's did not disappoint. Hands on owner Randy whipping up some unique and traditional flavors. I sampled cinnamon rice pudding which was amazing. I went with Pumpkin Patch and Vermont Maple both excellent choices. My wife enjoyed her strawberry. Place was busy for a Sunday night and everything ran smoothly. I highly recommend Randy's and look forward to trying more flavors.
Best ice cream spot in the area. Hands down. Service is always friendly and the flavors are always creative and delicious. Got a milkshake for the first time this past Sunday and it may have been the best milkshake I’ve ever had.
You May Also Like
Mack's American Bar & Grill - 300 Wanaque Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Bar, Vegetarian
Mr. Sushi Pompton Lakes - 298 Wanaque Ave
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Asian, Vegetarian
Pompton Espresso Bar - 296 Wanaque Ave
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea