Randy's Homemade Ice Cream
322 Wanaque Ave suite d, Pompton Lakes
(973) 590-9111
Customers' Favorites
Cookie Monster Ice Cream
Strawberry
Menu
Photos
+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best ice cream around. Creamy and delicious with fresh ingredients. It’s always exciting to try the new flavors. The hardest part about going to Randy’s is deciding which flavor to get next. In addition to great ice cream the employees are all friendly. Prices are fair.
I’ve been searching for real homemade ice cream in the area, and I finally struck gold. I’m mad it took me years to come across this gem. This place is SOOOOOO good. Like 1000000/10 good…and yes, I consider myself a seasoned food critic (with elite taste buds) 😅. I tried the lemon poppy seed and pure Vermont maple syrup—both were next-level delicious. I even got a grow a pear 🍐 flavor to take home and my husband and son ate it all before we even got home 🤣....
You May Also Like
Mack's American Bar & Grill - 300 Wanaque Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Bar, Vegetarian
Mr. Sushi Pompton Lakes - 298 Wanaque Ave
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Asian, Vegetarian
Pompton Espresso Bar - 296 Wanaque Ave
![]()
Cafe, Coffee & Tea
Quick service! Great prices! And you get the bang for your buck. For eight bucks I got this huge cup of ice cream. It was absolutely amazing especially on a hot day. The two guys working, they were super friendly and super helpful, and I asked them if they...