Piece of Cake - Gourmet Gelatos, Ice Creams & Sorbets

62 W Inman Ave, Rahway
(732) 382-0281

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Ice Cream Pie Sampler
Pistachio Gelato
Fudge

Menu

Gelatos and Ice Creams (1 pint containers)
Caramel Seasalt Chocolate Pretzel Gelato
Caramel ice cream with chocolate covered pretzels and and salted candies. It is one of a kind in our collection of gelatos!
Cherry Pistachio Gelato
A classic and timeless favorite! Rich vanilla base swirled with fresh Boudreaux cherries and pistachio pieces in every spoon. Thick, creamy, crunchy, and packed with flavor. Yummmmm 🤤
Chocolate Gelato
The best chocolate and cocoa powder blended for that dark, rich, and smooth gelato. You don't have to be a chocolate connoisseur to appreciate the richness of our chocolate.🫕
Coffee Espresso Gelato
Rich coffee gelato loaded with crunchy chocolate covered espresso beans. This flavor is popular and for a good reason!
Death by Chocolate Gelato
Chocolate gelato, chocolate chips, chocolate flakes, chocolate cake crunch, chocolate brownies and a chocolate fudge swirl. Try it if you know and understand chocolate else look elsewhere!
Gram Slam Cracker Gelato
Graham cracker gelato, chocolate covered graham crackers, and a crunchy graham cracker swirl 🤤
Green Tea Gelato
Balance and consistency are the hallmark of any tea. We think we have made a perfect gelato with the balance and consistency. Give it a shot!🫖
Peanut Butter Craze Gelato
Calling all peanut butter lovers. This gelato is the one for you. It is loaded with peanut butter cups, Reese's pieces, and swirls of peanut butter. 🥜🥜🥜
Pistachio Gelato
Dig into this gelato with the real pistachio perfectly consistent with the sweetness that enhances the flavor. Don't be amazed to find nuts in every spoon😛
Roasted Marshmallow Gelato
Move over chemicals. We have the real roasted 🔥marshmallows in this gelato ❄️ that melt in your mouth. You will want to come back to this flavor again and again!
Birthday Cake Ice Cream
Birthday Cake 🍰 Ice Cream - FULLY LOADED 💥 A layered creamy vanilla ice cream with homemade cake crumbs and sprinkles.
Cherry Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream
Vanilla ice cream with Bordeaux cherries and chocolate chips swirled in. It is an old time classic flavor that everyone enjoys. 😝
Cookie Monster Ice Cream
Rich BLUE ice cream loaded with cookie dough and chocolate chip cookies 🤤. There is no age limit to enjoy this flavor!
Trash Can Ice Cream
Vanilla ice cream with M&Ms, heath bar, brownies, and caramel candies. If that were not enough, we add swirls of fudge and caramel.....Trash or treat? 🤗
Vanilla Ice Cream
If you like vanilla and have been searching for that perfect texture and taste that is not everyday vanilla, your search is over. 😎

Sorbets
Lemon Sorbet
We use fresh lemon juice🍋 to make our lemon sorbet and you will taste the difference.
Mango Sorbet
The intense taste of mango without the dairy...Yipee!
Raspberry Sorbet
Our raspberry sorbet is red from the goodness of raspberries, and not fruit color, artificial color or any of that stuff. Taste it and you will know what we are talking about.

Ice Cream Pies (10 slices per box)
Candied Heath Bar (TM) Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
Chocolate cookie crumb crust with vanilla ice cream. Generous topping and an additional layer of health bar with butter scotch. 10 slices in a box.
Cappuccino Coffee Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
A chocolate crust with layer upon layer of cappuccino ice cream and hot fudge. Accented with chocolate marble pirouette swirls and crowned with hot fudge. This delight is a model of gourmet goodness.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
Chocolate Ice cream with Peanut Butter mousse in a chocolate cookie crust. Topped with peanut butter cups and hot fudge.
Cookies and Cream Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
Our famous chocolate cookie crust with generous layers of our creamy vanilla ice cream with mounds of Oreo (TM) cookies, and swirled hot fudge.
Hot Fudge Sundae Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
Creamy vanilla and an even creamier chocolate in a cookie crumb crust. Topped with hot fudge and pecans.
Keylime Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
A graham cracker crust enhances a light and refreshing key lime ice cream. Need we say more!
Mint Chocolate Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
We've taken the legendary duo of luscious chocolate mint candies and green mint ice cream, added a layer of fudge and chocolate cookie crust to create this "cool minty gem"
Mudslide Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
Our exceptional favorite begins with a chocolate cookie crumb crust. Filled with layers of coffee and chocolate ice creams, topped with chocolate sandwich cookies, hot fudge, and toasted almonds
Orange and Cream Ice Cream Pie (10 slices)
We begin with a graham cracker crust, add creamy vanilla and orange ice cream to create your childhood favorite!
Pecan Caramel Nut Ice Cream Pie (10 Slices)
This pie combines mountains of pecan flavored ice cream and mammoth pecans in a deliciously delicate and light graham cracker crust. Topped with caramel.
Sampler Pie (10 slices)
Can't decide or want to try everything that we have to offer, try our assorted sampler pie with a slice of every pie that we have to offer!

Ice Cream Tartufos and Truffles (Single Serve except for Assorted Box)
Cappuccino Truffle
Cappuccino ice cream dipped in dark chocolate and garnished with decorative streaks of chocolate.
Chocolate Brownie Truffle
Our famous chocolate ice cream and hot fudge are dipped in dark chocolate and rolled in chocolate brownies.
Coconut Snowball Truffle
Velvety smooth vanilla ice cream hand rolled with shredded coconut.
Hazelnut Praline Crunch Truffle
Hazelnut ice cream dipped in dark chocolate and rolled in praline crunch.
Raspberry Vanilla Truffle
Vanilla ice cream with raspberry glace wrapped in white chocolate.
Strawberry Chocolate Truffle
Strawberry Ice Cream dipped in rich dark chocolate and garnished with streaks of strawberry chocolate.
Tartufo
Piece of Cake's tartufo is ~7 oz and can be cut into two or four pieces. Tartufo has vanilla and chocolate ice creams fused together with cherry and toasted almonds in the middle. We would dare to say that it is unlike any tartufo you have tasted before.
Pistachio Tartufo
Our Tartufos are larger than usual at ~7 oz each and can be cut into two or four pieces. Pistachio tartufo is filled with pistachio ice cream with cherry and pistachio nuts in the middle, and covered with chocolate.
Tropical Tartufo
For those with a sweet tooth, mango and passion fruit sorbets fused with raspberry sorbet in the center. If that were not enough for sweetness, we have it wrapped in white chocolate!
Assorted Truffles Box (12 per box)
2 of each Truffle - Coconut, Hazelnut Praline, Chocolate Brownie, Raspberry Vanilla, Strawberry Chocolate, and Cappuccino

Ice Cream Novelties (Single Serve except for Assorted Box)
New World Spumoni
Made with layers of chocolate, vanilla and pistachio gelatos with maraschino cherries in the middle and also at the top along with pistachio.
Nutty Almond Joy
For all Almond lovers....Nutty Almond ice cream dipped in chocolate and "wrapped" with crushed almonds. Ganache and a whole almond at the top.
Raspberry Sorbet Burst
Rich raspberry flavor from the ripest natural berries and the best quality of dark chocolate come together to deliver an explosion of flavor and decadence.
Triple Chocolate Bypass
Rich chocolate gelato, dipped in bittersweet chocolate and rolled in chocolate cake crumbs, topped with a chocolate ganache and a chocolate center piece.
Tortoni
Almond ice cream topped with toasted coconut crunch and a maraschino cherry.
Assorted Novelties Box (12 per box)
3 each - Nutty Almond Joy and New World Spumoni; 2 each - Raspberry Sorbet Burst, Triple Chocolate Bypass, and Tortoni

Baked Goods
Boston Chocolate Cheesecake
10" BOSTON CHOCOLATE CHEESECAKE – We start with our creamy smooth original cheesecake add a layer of rich chocolate mousse cream and a chocolate ganache pour on top to finish. 14 servings per cake.
New York Cheesecake
10" CHEESECAKE – We use a shortbread crust and twice bake our cheesecake to maintain a creamy and smooth inside. This cake uses 7 natural ingredients as if you made it at home. The number one ingredient is a direct set cream cheese from Vermont. (14 slices per cake)
Carrot Cake
10" CALIFORNIA CARROT CAKE- This cake uses sweet California juicing carrots ground on premises to preserve freshness. Vermont cream cheese is the number one ingredient used in our frosting, unlike the overly sweet, sugar-filled icings you may have come across! (14 slices per box)
Chocolate Mousse Cake
10" CHOCOLATE MOUSSE CAKE- Chocolate genoise cake, layered with chocolate mousse and glazed with premium melted chocolate.
Flourless Chocolate Cake
10" GLUTEN FREE, FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE CAKE-The finest Belgium chocolate is used to make a delicately rich, smooth moist and creamy texture. Sure to delight.
Lemoncello Mascarpone Cake
10" LEMONCELLO MASCARPONE CAKE- A combination of Sicilian lemon infused sponge cake and Italian mascarpone finished with white chocolate curls. Light and creamy! (14 slices per cake)
Tiramisu Tray
Espresso filled lady finger cookies covered with a mixture of mascarpone and heavy cream, dusted with a layer of cocoa powder.
Tiramisu Cup (Single Serve)
Espresso filled lady finger cookies covered with a mixture of mascarpone and heavy cream, dusted with a layer of cocoa powder.
Caramel Apple (Single Serve)
Using freshly sliced apples with no preservatives from Empire Harvest, we make our signature apple dessert. We use a two-step baking process to achieve a golden finish while preserving a silky custard caramel filling. This dessert is best served warm with vanilla ice cream!
Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse (Single Serve)
This favorite dessert is a combination of peanut butter and chocolate. We start with our velvety chocolate sponge, layer it with our decadent chocolate mousse made with a premium blend of semi-sweet and dark chocolates and then our creamy peanut butter mousse. It is finished off with rich chocolate ganache.
Molten Lava (Single Serve)
3.75" MOLTEN LAVA – A delicious chocolate cake finished with a chocolate ganache top.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+32 photos
Photo credit: google
+31 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

What a treasure of a find and right in town! Excellent customer service and so quick and efficient! Delicious gelato and we are looking forward to enjoying the heath bar ice cream cake for my son’s birthday 😊 We will continue to be repeat customers for sure!
February 2026
stopped in to try this place after having some ice cream at a restaurant who used Piece of Cake as their sessert supplier. We took home an assortment if ice cream and other desserts. The ice cream was very creamy and tasty and I would go back for more
July 2025
Great gelato with awesome flavors. Blueberry pie and Cherry Pistachio but my fav is the Graham Cracker is so good and original. Unique desserts like tiramisu cups and truffles are delicious
February 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Firehouse Eatery & Pub - 455 St Georges Ave
Pubs, American, New American
Madina Halal Platter - 395 St Georges Ave
Halal, Falafel, Vegetarian
Stewart's Drive-In - 347 Jaques Ave
Burgers, Hot Dogs, American

Piece of Cake - Gourmet Gelatos, Ice Creams & Sorbets

62 W Inman Ave, Rahway, NJ 07065
(732) 382-0281