Rahway Bagels
Customers' Favorites
Bacon and Egg on Everything Bagel
Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich
Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese
Bacon Egg & Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bagel w Cream Cheese
Cream Cheese Spread
Meat Egg and Cheese
Bacon Egg & Cheese
Breakfast Sandwich
Menu
Bagel w/ Spreads
-
Bagel w/ Cream Cheese $3.50
-
Bagel w/ Butter $2.99
-
Bagel w/ Lox Slices and Cream Cheese $11.95
-
Bagel w/ Jelly $2.28
Featured items
-
Tropicana $2.75
-
Joe Tea $2.99
-
Yoo-Hoo $2.60
-
Nesquik $2.35
-
Red Bull $3.90
-
Gatorade $2.35
Bagels
-
One Bagel $1.35
-
Six Bagels $7.99
-
Bakers Dozen $15.99
Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich
-
Meat, Egg and Cheese $6.49
-
Egg and Cheese $3.63
-
Meat and Cheese $5.90
-
Meat and Egg $5.90
-
Meat $5.19
-
Egg $2.99
Side Orders
-
Side of Hashbrown $3.00
Potato Patty
-
Side of Homefries $3.59
-
Side of Meat $2.75
Drinks
-
Tropicana $2.75
-
Snapple $2.20
-
Arizona $1.30
-
Gatorade $2.35
-
Yoo-Hoo $2.60
-
Can of Soda $1.50
-
Nesquik $2.35
-
Bottle of Soda $3.25
-
Red Bull $3.90
-
Joe Tea $2.99
Bagel w/ Spreads
-
Bagel w/ Cream Cheese $3.50
-
Bagel w/ Butter $2.99
-
Bagel w/ Lox Slices and Cream Cheese $11.95
-
Bagel w/ Jelly $2.28
Tubs of Spread
-
Flavored Philly Cream Cheese $2.10
Vegetable, scallion, lox spread, strawberry, walnut, and jalapeno.
-
Butter One Size $5.75
-
Plain Philly Cream Cheese $1.64
Recent Reviews
Great bagels, the food not the complaint. Every employee is rude, whether it’s in person or over the phone. This happens every time i come here. Teach your employees how to treat customers, it doesn’t cost much to be nice.
June 2026
I love this place. The bagels are one of the best in New Jersey. It’s just the only thing is some of the people that work there need a little bit more training. I ordered two bagels and my bagel sat in front of the person that was working behind the cash register and she was just taking orders and filling up other people‘s orders and just leaving my bagels. Just sit there until I asked her to check me out.
June 2026
Our work oder's called in are constantly wrong. The bagels were really good at one time, but now they are hard and they don't taste flavorful. Bagels don't taste like the flavor it says it is.