Mr Crabby's Seafood House & Sports Bar (NJ)

399 NJ-10 E, Randolph
(973) 343-7688

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Today's Oysters on the Half Shell
House Brew Fish \u0026 Chips
Crabby's Famous Calamari
All You Can Eat Crab Legs
Low Country Shrimp Boil
Flash Fried Calamari
Wasabi Crusted Tuna
Blue Point Oysters
Crab Cake Sandwich
Clams & Lobster

Menu

Featured items
TRAD. PIZZA
TUSCAN TUNA SLD
FISH & CHIPS
LOBSTR MAC & CHZ
LOBSTER BISQUE

Starters
FRIED CALAMARI
WINGS
COCONUT SHRIMP
BONELESS WINGS
Celery, carrots, blue cheese Choice of sauce, traditional Buffalo, Sevendust rub, creamy Parmesan, BBQ, Sweet and spicy sriracha, mango habanero, Korean BBQ.
MUSSELS MARINARA
Gluten-free. Basil and herb Focaccia.
MOZZ STICKS
PRETZEL APP
CHZSTK ROLL
CRABBYS CHIPS
EMPANADAS
BURRATA
CLAMS APP
POTSTICKERS
WONTONS
SHRMP SKILLET
TUNA ROLL
PORK BELLY SKLT
EDAMAME

Soup
LOBSTER BISQUE
ENG. CHOWDER
SOUP OTD

Salad
TUSCAN TUNA SLD
CAESAR SALAD
COBB SALAD
MED SALMON SALAD
**Otter Salads
MIXED GREENS
APPLE PECAN SLD

Sea
FISH & CHIPS
STUFFED SHRIMP
WASABI TUNA
SNOW CRAB POT
SCALLOP ENTREE
PAELLA
Saffron rice, clams, mussels, octopus, shrimp, chorizo, and sausage.
SALMON ENTREE
CRAB CAKES
KING CRAB POT
BAKED SOLE
MAHI MAHI
Gluten-free. Pan-seared, lightly blackened, mango salsa, jasmine rice, and broccoli.
PAELLA FOR 2

Land
NY STRIP
SKIRT STEAK
Jasmine rice, truffle salted asparagus, and chipotle chimichurri.
WILDSIDE CHICKEN
Quarter chicken, jumbo shrimp, shiitake mushrooms, marsala cream sauce, wild rice, and broccoli.
COWBOY STEAK
Herb mashed potatoes, roasted garlic asparagus, caramelized onions, sautéed mushrooms, and demi-glace.
CHICKEN PARM
FILET MIGNON
8 oz. cut, herbed mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, onion rings, A-1 steak butter.

Sides
TRUFFLE FRIES
SIDE FRIES
CORN ON THE COB
COLESLAW
SWEET POT FRIES
BROCCOLI SAUTEED
BROCCOLI STEAMED
SPINACH SAUTEED
SPINACH STEAMED

Bowls
LOBSTR MAC & CHZ
SHRIMP SCAMPI
1/2 LOBSTR MAC
1/2 BRISKT MAC
BRISKT MAC & CHZ
KOREAN BBQ RAMEN
SEAFOOD RAMEN
ZUPPA DE PESCE
Hot or mild, linguine, zesty tomato sauce, garlic, calamari, mussels, clams, jumbo shrimp, and half lobster tail.
RUSTIC PASTA
BEEF RAMEN
1/2 PENNE PRIMA
LING & CLAMS
1/2 RUSTIC PASTA
PENNE PRIMAVERA
Zucchini, squash, shiitake mushrooms, heirloom tomato, artichoke, hearts, roasted garlic, and asiago cream.

Burgers
BURGER
TURKEY BURGER
Pepper jack cheese, pico de gallo, avocado, cherry pepper aioli, brioche bun, and sweet potato fries.
BACON-EATER BRGR
BEYOND BURGER
Vegan bun, lettuce, tomato, avocado, mixed greens. Vegan.

Tacos
MAHI TACOS
SHRIMP TACOS
CHICKEN TACOS
BRISKET TACOS
Sweet sour sauce, lettuce, mango salsa.

PIzza
TRAD. PIZZA
BURRATA PIZZA
RUSTIC PIZZA
Vodka sauce, sweet Italian sausage, Prosciutto, roasted garlic, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, and fresh basil.
SHRMP FRA PIZZA
BUFF CHICK PIZZA
VEGGIE PIZZA

Sandwiches
CHICKEN CIABATTA
SALMON CLUB
Arugula, cucumber, red onion, lemon caper aioli, multigrain bread, sweet potato fries.
LOBSTER ROLL
CRAB CAKE SAND
CHEESESTEAK
VEGGIE CIABATTA
BRISKET SANDWICH
LOBSTER REUBEN
Fresh lobster meat, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, 1000 Island, Texas toast, sweet potato fries.

Desserts
APPLE PIE
NY CHEESECAKE
KEY LIME PIE
ICE CREAM
MILKSHAKE
LEMON BAR
REESE'S PIE
GF SMORE'S PIE
GF CHOC CAKE
CHOC LAVA
CARROT CAKE

Extras
LOBSTER TAIL
SCALLOP ADD ON
SLICED STEAK
SIDE SALMON
GRILLED CHICKEN
GRILLED SHRIMP

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+97 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+96 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Went here on labor day to try it. Chris our waiter was outstanding!!! Working the bar and tables cant be easy but he was great. We ordered fried calamari and hubs got the oysters. He said they were the best oysters he ever had. Fresh and delicious!!! Fried calamari was ok a little overdone so it was a bit rubbery.
We all ordered the crab pot and were a little surprised when it was served with something that looked like a pot roast sauce not a typical garlic butter old...
September 2026
Food was excellent. We got 2 crab pots, and they were unbelievable. That garlic butter sauce was unreal. Server was fantastic - took such great care of us. Outside seating was perfect. Will definitely be back.
September 2026
We came here for dinner on Labor Day weekend. Delicious food, nice casual dining atmosphere, and great service. We ordered the oyster Rockefeller, crab cake sandwich, grilled swordfish, lobster Mac and cheese and funnel cake fries. Everything was good but the oysters were an absolute standout. Our server Chris, was also very attentive from start to finish. He even made sure our toddler was happy and entertained - our daughter got to color, eat some fruits and soft bread aside...
September 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dunkin' - 375 NJ-10
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee
The Corner Bistro NJ. - 477 NJ-10
Italian, American, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
Forte Pizzeria - 486 NJ-10
Italian, Pizza, Vegan, Vegetarian

Mr Crabby's Seafood House & Sports Bar (NJ)

399 NJ-10 E, Randolph, NJ 07869
(973) 343-7688